Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Science & Technology (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help. (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33671880)

Chris 16-11-2010 13:52

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
Please mind your language and do not attempt to dodge the swear filter.

Osem 16-11-2010 14:38

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
Given what you've said I think I'd contact my local newspapers about all this. It's a serious safety issue and hopefully they'll be interested enough in what's going on to take up the matter with your HA. If there are other HA owned properties nearby I'd also knock on a few doors and find out if their occupiers have been having similar problems with the contractors. If you can get some support to back up your claims that wouldn't hurt your case.

Mick Fisher 16-11-2010 14:43

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
The water locally is extremely hard.

When I worked as a self employed plumber I would highly recommend corrosion resistant elements to the extent of refusing to offer any guarantee if the customer insisted on a cheap job.

I also did work for some property management companies. They unanimously insisted I fit the cheapest copper elements I could source and accepted my policy of not guarantying them, although that did not stop them moaning when they failed within just a few months of being fitted.

Even using corrosion resistant elements, any element life after 12 months is a bonus in this area.

Thermostats were rarely a problem.

Welshchris 16-11-2010 18:01

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35123115)
Given what you've said I think I'd contact my local newspapers about all this. It's a serious safety issue and hopefully they'll be interested enough in what's going on to take up the matter with your HA. If there are other HA owned properties nearby I'd also knock on a few doors and find out if their occupiers have been having similar problems with the contractors. If you can get some support to back up your claims that wouldn't hurt your case.

I have already threatened legal action in the passed after i reported a leak in the roof in the communal hall in DEC 2009 which was making the staircase wet and was told it wasnt cost effective to have done and i kept complaining and was told in DEC 2009 it would get fixed after christmas.. They actually got around to fixing it 6 weeks ago and only reason they did there was a powercut and i had to use the stairs instead of the lift and there was no lighting and having back issues i have problems with steps and the stairs was wet due to heavy rain and i didnt see it and fell.

I have been in contact with the Housing ombudsman again who are sending me a complaints form also.

My Housing officer and the electrician is coming back out tomorrow to see if the econemy 7 heats tonight and it didnt last night and the electrician said theres nothing he can do as all voltages now checks out and it could be a problem with Swalec my electric supplier which is rubbish and he also said changing the tank wont make a difference and they havnt even tried as this was supposed to have been done 2 years ago.

---------- Post added at 18:01 ---------- Previous post was at 17:58 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick Fisher (Post 35123119)
The water locally is extremely hard.

When I worked as a self employed plumber I would highly recommend corrosion resistant elements to the extent of refusing to offer any guarantee if the customer insisted on a cheap job.

I also did work for some property management companies. They unanimously insisted I fit the cheapest copper elements I could source and accepted my policy of not guarantying them, although that did not stop them moaning when they failed within just a few months of being fitted.

Even using corrosion resistant elements, any element life after 12 months is a bonus in this area.

Thermostats were rarely a problem.

water here is soft water and the elements were only changed again yesterday these are number 3 and 4 in the way way of elements and 12 new thermistats, 5 since last Thursday as when they were being fitted and powered they kept tripping and then had to be put on MAX to get any life.

raging bull 16-11-2010 19:39

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
It is a shame you live so far away from me in Yorkshire.
I would have checked/replaced as required and confirmed system worked before I left.
Does the booster work at all?
(All this does is provide a 'timed electrical supply' direct to upper element)
Brian

Welshchris 16-11-2010 23:13

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
I left the booster on for over an hour and a half last night and it give me about 3" of hot water in the bath... When it was working fine i only needed to leave it on for about 30 mins and got a full bath full..

The electrician said he cannot help the ammount of hot water it gives he has done his job.. As i said to the housing officer at the end of the day they have a duty to fix it to a reasonable working standard even if it means changing the complete tank for something different. I was told theres something called a Non Vented system or something they could try instead but the housing officer is unwilling to spend out and this is one of the largest housing associations in South Wales. He will soon have a shock when a second Complaint is launched with the Ombudsman. Its also started affecting my health, i suffer from stress and anxiety and ive started having palpitations again to a point i was forced to have an ECG today and waiting for results and have been put on beta blockers.

Osem 17-11-2010 08:41

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
There is nothing wrong with E7 water heating - it's a very simple system, if a little expensive to run compared to gas. We had E7 water heating for over 20years and the only issues we had were the elements periodically failing. If you're in a soft water area there must either be something wrong with the basic installation, the work being done and/or the parts being used. There's so little which can go wrong any decent professional ought to be able to sort it out. It's a potential health/safety issue and I still think the newspapers are the way to go - a critical piece in the local rag ought to embarrass the HA to get their finger out and might be far quicker than just relying on the formal processes you've started.

One other thought, you've mentioned the problem with the Boost setting but what happens when the main element is on overnight to heat the whole tank? Do you get a full tank of hot water in the morning or just the same small amount because of the same problems with the element/thermostat?

Keep us posted.

Welshchris 17-11-2010 09:56

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
when working my E7 heating and water is more efficiant and costs less than my parents who have Gas.

Seems as tho now the problem is fixed touch wood i had piping hot water for the first time in 3 weeks almost so i have just got to keep an eye on it now for a few days to make sure all is well.

Apparently according to the electrician the problem was and i quote which im not taking the micky here he said that proberbly "your flat must be haunted".

Im thinking of writing a book on it called "The Pantom of the Immersion Heater". The Phantom does nothing at all except adjusts ur thermostat when ur asleep.

raging bull 17-11-2010 11:42

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
One last question for you Chris!
Can you advise on what temperature the 2 thermostats have been set to.
(Should have a isolation switch adjacent to each of the 2 heaters, switch off to prevent accident)
Removing the screw/nut holding the cover in place, look at the setting @60/65°C.
Replace cover then switch back on power.

Mick Fisher 17-11-2010 14:12

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
It's been years since I worked on these but I'm sure I remember that the Boost option is a timed 1 hour activation. I also remember a full tank/half tank setting courtesy of an element positioned halfway up the cylinder as opposed to the one positioned at the base of the cylinder.

Re: Your 3 inches of hot water after using the Boost. Is it possible that only the half tank element is energised when boost is enabled.

IIRC that boost is only intended give enough extra HW for washing up or hands & face washing etc. IIRC one bath about empties the whole tank.

raging bull 17-11-2010 14:40

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
On economy 7 installations the boost (is now) provided by a push button switch.
(Push 1/2 -1 -2hr depending on how many times button is pressed)
With the boost element positioned vertically at top of tank.
Depending on length of element determines band of hot water at switch off temp.
(I used 11 inch for both top/side entry elements)

Mick Fisher 17-11-2010 15:10

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
Thanks for the heads up.

It looks like we don't really have enough information to diagnose what might be going on with Chris's system. :(

Welshchris 17-11-2010 18:15

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by raging bull (Post 35123476)
One last question for you Chris!
Can you advise on what temperature the 2 thermostats have been set to.
(Should have a isolation switch adjacent to each of the 2 heaters, switch off to prevent accident)
Removing the screw/nut holding the cover in place, look at the setting @60/65°C.
Replace cover then switch back on power.

the thermostat is set just over the default mark now .

There r no temp marks on it just - and + at other end and then a thick white dot marking out the default temp.

raging bull 04-01-2011 20:23

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
A final heads up on water heaters.
Be aware that if you have the new style 1/4 turn taps (ceramic cartridge instead of rubber plug), the ceramic faces are only for use up to 65°C.
(Just changed a hot water cartridge after it had been damaged by very hot water, just 2years old)!!
At 8 pounds per cartridge, it was an expensive hot water system

Welshchris 27-09-2011 11:26

Re: Economy 7 Immersion Heater Help.
 
Again im having problems with this but dont know if it was just a one off so i will give it the benefit of the doubt for now but if it carries on will contact the housing association.

2 days ago i realised i didnt have hot water which should have heated over night and discovered the thermistat had tripped so i reset it. I decided also as the water was a bit hot to turn it down so i moved it 1/2 a notch clockwise which the arrow went towards the -.

Now either 1... I am being totally thick and did it wrong or 2 the thermistat may have a problem as the water now is even HOTTER! i mean to a point u cant even wash ur hands under the tap after going to the loo. I have to instead fill the sink and add cold each time otherwise it will take the skin off ur hands.

anyone tell me what it is lol


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:38.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum