Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media News Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   .com to be shut down temporarily (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=4383)

dialanothernumb 21-11-2003 16:01

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
NOTE : this is an opinion - please do not flame :D

I think that NTL have been looking for an excuse for a while, and when a good one failed to arrive, they decided to "temporarily" close the site to cause all the members to go elsewhere...

Bad for .com - good for .co.uk (which I hope will continue in its current, helpful way)

I agree, I think they have been looking for an excuse. Far better than to have to £really explain the role of .com if community fully launched.

I had been following the "future" threads a bit over the last while and I don't really think the threads were either helpful or harmful to .coms fate as such. The threads did eventually start to make for dreary reading though (I'm not going into why or who's fault this was because its irrelevant)
If community takes off and successfully delivers on mild to moderate technical issues, then great. the .co.uk site is for that "little bit extra" for "gripes" and for the social aspect. Since a fair chunk of the active and social community is already here or will soon join, have we really lost ANYTHING?

I'd like to make an appeal. Those who've joined from .com and who've been involved in the more intense debates (such as Erol and Neil) Can you let byegones be byegones and start afresh. No revisting history or apportioning blame, just getting on with being a community? That would be a great "way ahead"

Now where's me mate UDT?

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:01

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by erol
It was Neil who claimed that it was my and CJ's behaviour that led to the closure of the site, not NTL's reason, just to be clear on that point. Of course as the longest serving 'mod' there and the main 'power' behind the team there, he bears no personal culpability what so ever for what has happened to the site under his guardianship. It is all down to me and CJ, according to him.

That may have been said in the heat of the moment .... lets not have a personal argument here ....:nono:

zovat 21-11-2003 16:02

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
what heavy handed moderation it was good

There was a stage (a while back now) where anything that was nasty about NTL got jumped on by one of the then moderators :grind: , I seem to recall there was a phase of a certain element posting stuff on one forum about the other in order to stir things up a bit. :shrug:

That was some time ago - and .com was working well from a user perspective before they decided to pull the plug :(

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:02

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by erol
It was Neil who claimed that it was my and CJ's behaviour that led to the closure of the site, not NTL's reason, just to be clear on that point. Of course as the longest serving 'mod' there and the main 'power' behind the team there, he bears no personal culpability what so ever for what has happened to the site under his guardianship. It is all down to me and CJ, according to him.


cant see it being down to a couple of people somehow
:nono:

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:03

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
good point... pointing the finger of blame is easy. it was a cheap shot in my opinion to blame Erolz and Craig or anyone for that matter. other than the person who pulled the plug.

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:06

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
good point... pointing the finger of blame is easy. it was a cheap shot in my opinion to blame Erolz and Craig or anyone for that matter. other than the person who pulled the plug.


who will probably remain nameless for all of eternity :naughty:

zovat 21-11-2003 16:06

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
good point... pointing the finger of blame is easy. it was a cheap shot in my opinion to blame Erolz and Craig or anyone for that matter. other than the person who pulled the plug.

Agreed - lets just get on with helping each other here, and keep away from "blamestorming" the past. :romance:

th'engineer 21-11-2003 16:08

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
Agreed - lets just get on with helping each other here, and keep away from "blamestorming" the past. :romance:

Thats what its about helping newbies and other members, and trying to get NTL to smell the roses

Chris 21-11-2003 16:08

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
Agreed - lets just get on with helping each other here, and keep away from "blamestorming" the past. :romance:

'Blamestorming' - now that's a good word.

/writes it down in order to use in future posts

I think we should all get in the habit of using this smiley: :ghugs:

zovat 21-11-2003 16:10

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
'Blamestorming' - now that's a good word.

/writes it down in order to use in future posts

I think we should all get in the habit of using this smiley: :ghugs:

It is a very good word - best thing ever to come from the US..

Just for you - :ghugs:

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:10

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
'Blamestorming' - now that's a good word.

/writes it down in order to use in future posts

I think we should all get in the habit of using this smiley: :ghugs:

Yep ... :ghugs:

Nor 21-11-2003 16:10

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Maybe someone can help me here..... what I don't understand is Mick and Neil announcing their arrival here when it is them who infact run the site under alias's. Its been said on another site that Neil is Andre and Mick is Dr Plummer.

Maybe someone could explain it to me.

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:11

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Maybe someone can help me here..... what I don't understand is Mick and Neil announcing their arrival here when it is them who infact run the site under alias's. Its been said on another site that Neil is Andre and Mick is Dr Plummer.

Maybe someone could explain it to me.

I was waiting for this to come up .... WHO CARES !!!!

basa 21-11-2003 16:11

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Maybe someone can help me here..... what I don't understand is Mick and Neil announcing their arrival here when it is them who infact run the site under alias's. Its been said on another site that Neil is Andre and Mick is Dr Plummer.

Maybe someone could explain it to me.

Ouch......!!! :rofl:

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:12

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Maybe someone can help me here..... what I don't understand is Mick and Neil announcing their arrival here when it is them who infact run the site under alias's. Its been said on another site that Neil is Andre and Mick is Dr Plummer.

Maybe someone could explain it to me.


is it ???????????????

Linda 21-11-2003 16:12

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
:ghugs:

I'll miss something from the .com site - Orangebirds's Avatar - that was always cute :)

Chris 21-11-2003 16:12

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Maybe someone can help me here..... what I don't understand is Mick and Neil announcing their arrival here when it is them who infact run the site under alias's. Its been said on another site that Neil is Andre and Mick is Dr Plummer.

Maybe someone could explain it to me.

Yes, this has been stated ad nauseam by various mischief makers on this forum and elsewhere. However I have seen Russ post more than once that this is emphatically not true. And I completely trust Russ not to tell a direct and blatant lie.

That settles it as far as I'm concerned.

:ghugs:

Pointman 21-11-2003 16:13

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Well at least it'll save me jumping between sites for a while, trying to keep up with all your feedback.

Nor 21-11-2003 16:13

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis
I was waiting for this to come up .... WHO CARES !!!!

Well I don't let it keep me awake at night, but personally I don't think it lends them much credability by coming on pretending to have just arrived and Mick asking the mods to change his name to Minder, and hes the mod ? I'm at a loss.

th'engineer 21-11-2003 16:13

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
:D
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Maybe someone can help me here..... what I don't understand is Mick and Neil announcing their arrival here when it is them who infact run the site under alias's. Its been said on another site that Neil is Andre and Mick is Dr Plummer.

Maybe someone could explain it to me.

Thought that had been put to bed as a rumour spread by others next you will say Fraz is Russ

basa 21-11-2003 16:13

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
is it ???????????????

So we are "reliably" informed :erm: :erm: :erm:

th'engineer 21-11-2003 16:14

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by basa
So we are "reliably" informed :erm: :erm: :erm:

By who

Bex 21-11-2003 16:14

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis
I was waiting for this to come up .... WHO CARES !!!!

i agree with nemmy.....
afaik the person who has said that neil and mike are andre and dr p is cj....is he a reliable source???

Neil 21-11-2003 16:15

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
With respect to all concerned here, it was me who was on the conference call when the 'suspension' of the site was announced, & not the people who are debating this.

The site had become unmanageable thanks to Erol & his 'user empowerment' mission-fact.

The threads he created dominated the site, & customer issues were getting overlooked-fact.

The site was not there for people to boost their egos with their grand plans of how things should be done, it was their to help customers who had been let down by ntl.

We all know that ntl customer service sucks at times, but creating multiple threads & dominating the site with suggestions doesn't help the people posting for help & getting missed.

As I have said before-Erol's ideas are good (nothing that we haven't suggested to ntl before though), but the way he went about his 'quest' was all wrong, & the disruption it caused was unacceptable.

What should have happened was that Erol (or whoever) should have forst approached the NTHW Team (out of courtesy if nothing else), with this proposition, & we could have taken it (with Erol) to ntl to see if they were even interested in the ideas. What I didn't want to happen was for Erol (or whoever) to waste people's time collating all the info he had suggested, only to take it to ntl & for it to disappear into a black hole (like most of the ideas we have taken to them)-that is a complete waste of everybody's time & energy, & not in any way helpful to man nor beast.

I was/we were there to help customers who posted asking for help-starting multiple threads on the subject was counter productive to that-fact.

(sorry for rambling-I hope that makes sense)

[Edit]-Spelling

[Edit]-Also-I really don't want to debate this whole situation any more, I didn't come here to debate it-I came here to offer my help to users of the site.

I really have had enough this afternoon, please remember that it is only a few hours since I heard that .com was being 'suspended'

Chris 21-11-2003 16:15

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
:D Thought that had been put to bed as a rumour spread by others next you will say Fraz is Russ

:eek:

Now that would explain a few things!

;)

:ghugs:

Nor 21-11-2003 16:15

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
By who

By CJ who apparantly was part of this team when the site was set up, but left. Frankly I find it hard to trust any of them after the soap opera that I read on nthell but I didn't see Neil or Mick denying it.

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:16

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
Well I don't let it keep me awake at night, but personally I don't think it lends them much credability by coming on pretending to have just arrived and Mick asking the mods to change his name to Minder, and hes the mod ? I'm at a loss.

There's a number of rumours .... and probably reasons behind each and every one of them.

This site is well run, fairly moderated, helpful and has managed to produce a real sense of community.

The only thing it lacks is the CLT input ....

It may be run by people who have been on .Com, but I can understand their reasons for anonimity, if these rumours end up being true.

Remember where theses rumours came from ....

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:16

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
i agree with nemmy.....
afaik the person who has said that neil and mike are andre and dr p is cj....is he a reliable source???


you surely couldnt have cj on here could you , people would spot it a mile off i reckon :(

Chris 21-11-2003 16:17

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nor
I read on nthell

I think we've spotted the problem then.

Bex 21-11-2003 16:18

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
:eek:

Now that would explain a few things!

;)

:ghugs:

aren't u pleased i asked dr p to find a hug smilie? :p

:ghugs:

thanks for the post neil...explained some stuff methinks

Fawkes 21-11-2003 16:19

The last thread!
 
The last thread on .com can be viewed here.

No offense to this site but I like many others found .com a valuable resource and I for one hope it will return soon in some form or another. If not lets hope that as many people form the old site find this place and get the same level help (or better!) from this site.

zovat 21-11-2003 16:19

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by basa
So we are "reliably" informed :erm: :erm: :erm:

I have to say -

1 - IF this is true (big if) does it really matter ? :erm:

2 - If not - lets not get off to a flaming start to this phase of the forum (which I can only think will continue to grow and grow with .com down). :D

3 - If Russ says it ain't so - then I for one am happy with that. :D



as ever - feel free to ignore my opinions :beer:

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:19

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
With respect to all concerned here, it was me who was on the conference call when the 'suspension' of the site was announced, & not the people who are debating this.

The site had become unmanageable thanks to Erol & his 'user empowerment' mission-fact.

The threads he created dominated the site, & customer issues were getting overlooked-fact.

The site was not there for people to boost their egos with their grand plans of how things should be done, it was their to help customers who had been let down by ntl.

We all know that ntl customer service sucks at times, but creating myltiple threads & dominating the site with suggestions doesn't help the people posting for help & getting missed.

As I have said before-Erol's ideas are good (nothing that we haven't suggested to ntl before though), but the way he went about his 'quest' was all wrong, & the disruption it caused was unacceptable.

What should have happened was that Erol (or whoever) should have forst approached the NTHW Team (out of courtesy if nothing else), with this proposition, & we could have taken it (with Erol) to ntl to see if they were even interested in the ideas. What I didn't want to happen was for Erol (or whoever) to waste people's time collating all the info he had suggested, only to take it to ntl & for it to disappear into a black hole (like most of the ideas we have taken to them)-that is a complete waste of everybody's time & energy, & not in any way helpful to man nor beast.

I was/we were there to help customers who posted asking for help-starting multiple threads on the subject was counter productive to that-fact.

(sorry for rambling-I hope that makes sense)



sorry but if that was the case then why wasnt it moderated instead of the site being shutdown , btw im not having a go neil :)

cjmillsnun 21-11-2003 16:20

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Personally I think .com is dead for good.

I also think that the moderation ONLY became heavy handed after NTL took over, and that CJ was the main culprit.

I feel like welcoming anyone from .com over here, and because of this sites ownership, have no fears about the style changing

Bex 21-11-2003 16:20

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
you surely couldnt have cj on here could you , people would spot it a mile off i reckon :(

:erm: dont understand what ur saying huni

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:21

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bexy
:erm: dont understand what ur saying huni

usually his tone gives him away
:rolleyes:

Ben 21-11-2003 16:21

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
I/we -(Myself/Neil/Mick) do not run .co.uk! I'm getting sick of hearing it - I have registered on here to express my views and I'm sure the mods/admins don't mind this (I hope)

With all the goings on recently about the future of the site and all in my eyes it was only time that was stopping this happening. Erolz - you havenââ‚ÆšÂ¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¾Ã‚¢t made it any easier thatââ‚ ¬Ã¢â€žÂ¢s for sure and I too believe that you have played a part in getting .com shut down for however long (forever?)

For that I will never forgive you as *if* NTL do decide to "pull the plug" then they will be making a massive mistake.

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:21

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
With respect to all concerned here, it was me who was on the conference call when the 'suspension' of the site was announced, & not the people who are debating this.

The site had become unmanageable thanks to Erol & his 'user empowerment' mission-fact.

The threads he created dominated the site, & customer issues were getting overlooked-fact.

The site was not there for people to boost their egos with their grand plans of how things should be done, it was their to help customers who had been let down by ntl.

We all know that ntl customer service sucks at times, but creating myltiple threads & dominating the site with suggestions doesn't help the people posting for help & getting missed...............

but this doesnt make sense as Erolz was suspended a long time before the site was closed and you had agreed this morning that site discussion was now a lot better (cant quote your exact words as the site is not available!).

the fact is, the site was working fine when it was taken down. the multi threads issue had been resolved (by Erolz suspension) and the site discussion was down to one thread which had become extremely pleasant.

suggesting that this was all about boosting egos is insulting to those people contributing constuctively in that thread.

Nor 21-11-2003 16:22

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
I think we've spotted the problem then.

I don't really get involved in the politics of the different sites. I just read what people say. In the soap opera of a thread where CJ, Neil and Mick had words I didn't see Neil or Mick dispute what CJ had said regarding the mods of this site.


Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
I have to say -

1 - IF this is true (big if) does it really matter ? :erm:

Personally I couldn't care less who runs this site. If its run well and helps people thats all that matters. However... if it is true it means people are lying. If thats the case I think that negatively impacts on helping people.

rodd 21-11-2003 16:22

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
good point... pointing the finger of blame is easy. it was a cheap shot in my opinion to blame Erolz and Craig or anyone for that matter. other than the person who pulled the plug.

I DO hope that it was not because of anything that I said of Ashg!!
Such as what I posted recently on .com ---

Quote:

Originally Posted by rodd
Does Ashg really not have an inkling on what to do about this site and what this site's future is to be after how many months? 6/9 months, and he still doesn't know!. Perhaps someone else at ntl would be able to figure it out.

He's either given up completely, or pulled the plug to try and think of something, with a bit of peace and quiet. Or could be, there is to be a change at the top, and management are going to allow him to move on to his full potential. ;)

Bex 21-11-2003 16:22

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulyoung666
usually his tone gives him away
:rolleyes:

i never said cj was on this site, i merely said that afaik....from what i have heard from others, it is cj whom is telling people of neil/mike/franks involvement in this site

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:23

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben
I/we -(Myself/Neil/Mick) do not run .co.uk! I'm getting sick of hearing it - I have registered on here to express my views and I'm sure the mods/admins don't mind this (I hope)

With all the goings on recently about the future of the site and all in my eyes it was only time that was stopping this happening. Erolz - you havenââ‚ÆšÂ¬ÃƒÂ¢Ã¢â‚¬Å¾Ã‚¢t made it any easier thatââ‚ ¬Ã¢â€žÂ¢s for sure and I too believe that you have played a part in getting .com shut down for however long (forever?)

For that I will never forgive you as *if* NTL do decide to "pull the plug" then they will be making a massive mistake.


please lets dont get into a slanging match for this sites / threads sake :(

Chris 21-11-2003 16:23

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shabba
Yip! That free speach malarky!!

What a problem that is eh?

Free speech is great, that's what we do on this site.

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:24

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben
For that I will never forgive you as *if* NTL do decide to "pull the plug" then they will be making a massive mistake.

Erolz was a member working within the rules. He was suspended when he broke those. To now pile the blame on him and use words like "I will never forgive you"..... oh dear!

zovat 21-11-2003 16:26

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
but this doesnt make sense as Erolz was suspended a long time before the site was closed and you had agreed this morning that site discussion was now a lot better (cant quote your exact words as the site is not available!).

the fact is, the site was working fine when it was taken down. the multi threads issue had been resolved (by Erolz suspension) and the site discussion was down to one thread which had become extremely pleasant.

suggesting that this was all about boosting egos is insulting to those people contributing constuctively in that thread.


come on guys - lets not get into that "blamestorming" phase (sorry but I like the word :blush: )

whatever caused it, we need to concentrate on moving forwards, not looking back. :angel:

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:27

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
Erolz was a member working within the rules. He was suspended when he broke those. To now pile the blame on him and use words like "I will never forgive you"..... oh dear!

Hey can we calm it .... .Com is suspended ... if you have issues with Neil/Ben/Mick then take it to PM ....

Now play nice ... please :D

th'engineer 21-11-2003 16:27

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
:angel: wonder what UDT will make of all this :D

Nor 21-11-2003 16:28

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
How you can blame Erolz is frankly beyond me.

zovat 21-11-2003 16:28

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
:angel: wonder what UDT will make of all this :D

:LOL:

dialanothernumb 21-11-2003 16:29

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Oh Bloody heck! Now this thread really IS looking like it was imported from .com

Neil, Erol and all others who feel pee'd off one way or another, I really understand that you are annoyed, but please just DROP the past! Everyone will have a view, everyone gets a chance to move on! Unfinished Business (no not a user name!) could easily be discussed elsewhere surely

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:32

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dialanothernumb
Oh Bloody heck! Now this thread really IS looking like it was imported from .com

Neil, Erol and all others who feel pee'd off one way or another, I really understand that you are annoyed, but please just DROP the past! Everyone will have a view, everyone gets a chance to move on! Unfinished Business (no not a user name!) could easily be discussed elsewhere surely

Take it to PM or MSN .... don't spoil our forum ..

Chris 21-11-2003 16:33

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
:Peaceman:

Yes, this is a nice place full of nice people who (usually) disagree nicely! Let's keep it that way!

zovat 21-11-2003 16:34

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis
Take it to PM or MSN .... don't spoil our forum ..

Once again I am forced to agree - I haven't been this agreeable for ages :D

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 16:34

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis
Take it to PM or MSN .... don't spoil our forum ..



well said , dont spoil it for the majority please , the last thing i want to see is thread suspended :Peaceman: please ;)

Seb 21-11-2003 16:34

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by towny
102 now on the site, 54 of them guests.

There used to be a 'most users ever online' stat at the foot of the front page before we got this new version of vBulletin. Can anyone remember what the figure was, or can one of the Admins reveal some of the site stats for us? Are we anywhere near record attendance figures?

Apologies if this has already been answered, but this thread is moving too fast for my ickle brain to keep up. Towny if you look at http://forum.nthellworld.co.uk/online.php? then at the top it says the stat for most users online. [Higlighted in attachment if you cant find it]

Welcome to all the new members :ghugs:

Seb

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:35

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
come on guys - lets not get into that "blamestorming" phase (sorry but I like the word :blush: )

whatever caused it, we need to concentrate on moving forwards, not looking back. :angel:

sorry mate. I just wasnt happy with the idea of it going on record that Erolz or anyone other than the plug puller was to blame for this.

Chris 21-11-2003 16:36

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Seb
Apologies if this has already been answered, but this thread is moving too fast for my ickle brain to keep up. Towny if you look at http://forum.nthellworld.co.uk/online.php? then at the top it says the stat for most users online. [Higlighted in attachment if you cant find it]

Welcome to all the new members :ghugs:

Seb

Got it now ... thanks Seb, I was just looking at the forum front page for my stats. :tu:

zovat 21-11-2003 16:38

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
sorry mate. I just wasnt happy with the idea of it going on record that Erolz or anyone other than the plug puller was to blame for this.

NP, just didn't want to see a flame war start up.

:ghugs:

erol 21-11-2003 16:39

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
The site had become unmanageable thanks to Erol & his 'user empowerment' mission-fact.

One user, me, was able to make the site unmanagable by posting 3 constructive threads in a row and getting suspended for it? Do you have any idea how ridiculous that sounds?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
The threads he created dominated the site, & customer issues were getting overlooked-fact.

Three threads, quickly merged into one (all constructive btw) dominated the site? The only customers that were not getting help were those that I could of helped personaly (as I had been doing consistently for some time previous) but was unable to help because of my suspension.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
The site was not there for people to boost their egos with their grand plans of how things should be done, it was their to help customers who had been let down by ntl.

Was it there so you could make constant accusations about me and my ego?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
We all know that ntl customer service sucks at times, but creating myltiple threads & dominating the site with suggestions doesn't help the people posting for help & getting missed.

Three threads, quickly merged into one and my being suspended can not be considered 'domination' of the site by any reasonable person imo. There was only one set of people 'dominating' the site and I was not one of them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
As I have said before-Erol's ideas are good (nothing that we haven't suggested to ntl before though), but the way he went about his 'quest' was all wrong, & the disruption it caused was unacceptable.

No you have said before that the ideas were 'pointless' or simply ignored them in the past. If my actions were unacceptable, as you clearly thought they were, then you had the power and did suspend me.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
What should have happened was that Erol (or whoever) should have forst approached the NTHW Team (out of courtesy if nothing else), with this proposition, & we could have taken it (with Erol) to ntl to see if they were even interested in the ideas. What I didn't want to happen was for Erol (or whoever) to waste people's time collating all the info he had suggested, only to take it to ntl & for it to disappear into a black hole (like most of the ideas we have taken to them)-that is a complete waste of everybody's time & energy, & not in any way helpful to man nor beast.

The whole point of each of the three ideas I posted, that earnt my suspension, were that they were collaborative, constructvie things that users could do _regardless_ of any support from the NTHW mods or NTL. Take the 'user stats' idea. Every time previously when this had been mentioned by myself or others in the past it was ignored by the mods. When they did finally comment on the idea, they first suggested that it breached NTLs company confidentiality. When this was pointed out as being ridiculous, they then said it was pointless becuase the site was being closed soon anyway. Finaly they said that it was pointless for users to collect stats themesleves, unless NTL has first 'agreed' to this, which was totaly _not_ the point of such an idea. So given this historic response to this idea, the right way to have suggested it in your opinion was first to submit it to yourself ? Add to that that you have used every opportunity to rubbish me personaly are you really suggesting that if it had been suggested to you privately first, you would have been able to put aside you personal issue with me and view it fairly and dispaionately? The inof I suggested be collected was for users, by users. The suggestion was for thsoe that _wanted too_ to collect such stats. If you though it was piointless all you had to do was leave those that did not to get on with it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
I was/we were there to help customers who posted asking for help-starting multiple threads on the subject was counter productive to that-fact.

(sorry for rambling-I hope that makes sense)

I am sorry for bringing this up here. I will not be adding to this 'defense; any more. I have no wish to 'burden' this site with my and Neils 'spat. I have made my response and will leave it at that. Appologies to all here. Like I say I will not be posting here on any regular basis and will refrain from posting here for a minimum of one week, least accusations be raised against me that I am trying to 'dominate' this site.

downquark1 21-11-2003 16:40

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
If .com is closed I feel sorry for all those 'anti-.co.uk' who have to swallow their pride and register here.

th'engineer 21-11-2003 16:41

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
erol can we stop this repercusions no need for it you both have different views

Seb 21-11-2003 16:42

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Any one got a spare keyboard, i think i have worn out my F5 key having to refresh all the time?? :D

Graham F 21-11-2003 16:43

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
I think its a shame that dot com has finally gone, which in my opinion it has. Maybe they might even get community launched :rofl: :rofl:

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:45

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scooby
I think its a shame that dot com has finally gone, which in my opinion it has. Maybe they might even get community launched :rofl: :rofl:

http://forum.nthellworld.co.uk/showp...4&postcount=14 :D LOL

Nor 21-11-2003 16:45

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mick
I can understand your view point Nor and I know we have never really seen eye to eye on many occasions but if you believe everything that Craig posts is fact, then your gullible as you can ever get. I'd rather not start debating about Craig, because quite frankly the subject bores me rigid. He is water under the bridge as far as I am concerned and the Earth does not orbit him as much as he would like it to. If nthw.com is closed for good, we need to move on, not let history get in the way. You may not trust me now, but I hope in the future I can earn your trust.

Fair enough Mick. I don't really have a major issue with you. Just that one incident where I felt you were wrong when you merged 2 threads which were on completely different subjects just because they had the same title. But, in the grand scheme of things its hardly that important Sadly I felt your inability to see the error and additionally the deletion of all posts which showed you were wrong damaged your reputation in my eyes, but lets not get back into that.

After reading all the stuff on nthell I have to say, in my eyes, nobody came out of it looking squeaky clean and I imagine the truth of it all lies somewhere in the grey area in between. The only reason I brought up the mod thing is that I didn't see you dispute it. If you say you aren't a mod/admin of this site and have never been (and never been involved in running it in any way) then I'm prepared to believe you and will drop the whole subject. Not that I plan on carrying it on anyway.

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:45

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
erol can we stop this repercusions no need for it you both have different views

let the man have his right to reply.


(perhaps Erolz and Neil should have their own thread. :rofl: )

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:46

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
let the man have his right to reply.


(perhaps Erolz and Neil should have their own thread. :rofl: )

He has the right of reply ... just this forum is not the place to do it .. PM/MSN/EMAIL/PHONE but not here

th'engineer 21-11-2003 16:47

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
let the man have his right to reply.
:rofl:

(perhaps Erolz and Neil should have their own thread. )

Good idea you going to add UDT as well:rofl:

Graham F 21-11-2003 16:49

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis


Me wonders how I could of missed that in such a small, slow moving thread :dunce: :p

Nemesis 21-11-2003 16:51

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scooby
Me wonders how I could of missed that in such a small, slow moving thread :dunce: :p

LOL :rofl: :rofl: Sorry Scooby

Psychotext 21-11-2003 16:51

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Another former .com member here. I've been a customer of NTL's for about 7 years now and I'm one of the more critical of their service. I'm also the first to praise when they get something right. I'm not surprised about the closure of the site. Especially given some of the things covered on there lately (Not least the threads related to outsourcing and job losses).

Personally, I would be very very surprised if the closure of the site wasn't somehow related to this news story http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/7/34120.html (NTL to remove 2000 jobs). Again given their new use of outsourcing I doubt this news would have gone down too well on the forums for them.

Been lurking around here since NTL took over the other site. Seems pretty good and hopefully it will continue to be that way.

zovat 21-11-2003 16:51

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
Good idea you going to add UDT as well:rofl:


:LOL: :rofl:

come on guys - lets get back to being nice ....

everyone has a right of reply, and this has now been replied to - lets just move on.

:ghugs:

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:52

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemesis
He has the right of reply ... just this forum is not the place to do it .. PM/MSN/EMAIL/PHONE but not here

I disagree, if you had someone accuse you of ending a site then either you have the right to reply or the initial post containing those accusations is removed if you arent allowed the right to reply to it.

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 16:54

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
everyone has a right of reply, and this has now been replied to - lets just move on.

:ghugs:


ok baby! so back on topic... now the other site is 'down' .... do you think it would be possible to get NTL to put a link on the 'sorry .com is out of service page' linking to this site?

:shrug: do you think they'll take that suggestion on board?

Chris 21-11-2003 16:58

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Psychotext
Another former .com member here.

Welcome, psychotext :wavey:

Sociable 21-11-2003 17:00

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
:LOL: :rofl:

come on guys - lets get back to being nice ....

everyone has a right of reply, and this has now been replied to - lets just move on.

:ghugs:

Ahhh but what if ALL these players are one and the same person would that mean they all have a right to talk to themselves. :smokin:

Sorry will behave now just couldn't resist and I honestly have no serious belief this is just a case of rabid scitzophrenia it just seemed a funny notion given all the who is who speculations.

:luv: Kiss and make up guys I for one intend to always remain "Sociable" :kiss:

zovat 21-11-2003 17:01

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
ok baby! so back on topic... now the other site is 'down' .... do you think it would be possible to get NTL to put a link on the 'sorry .com is out of service page' linking to this site?

:shrug: do you think they'll take that suggestion on board?

somehow I doubt that - after all - they don't control this site. :angel:

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 17:02

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
perhaps they could just redirect all traffic to this site?

:rofl:

Mick 21-11-2003 17:05

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
perhaps they could just redirect all traffic to this site?

:rofl:

I'll have whatever your smoking baby. :smokin: :rofl:

Jon T 21-11-2003 17:19

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
been registered here for a while(think since the site started) and posted here occasionally, it's no big secret that i've posted on .com a lot more frequently and more recently than here on co.uk, I shall now treat this as home instead.

For anybody that's interested or dosn't know, i was regestered as "tech_jon" on .com.

Jon

markmarkymark 21-11-2003 17:21

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Greetings All..

I did join some time ago - but not so active on here ...

cheers

Mark

Bex 21-11-2003 17:22

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon T
been registered here for a while(think since the site started) and posted here occasionally, it's no big secret that i've posted on .com a lot more frequently and more recently than here on co.uk, I shall now treat this as home instead.

For anybody that's interested or dosn't know, i was regestered as "tech_jon" on .com.

Jon

:wavey: well will look forward to seeing lots of newer ppl posting here.....

so i was the opposite, i was a member on .com for a long time before i moved over here and then made this my home......i prefer it over here, it feels a lot more like a community :ghugs:

Derek 21-11-2003 17:25

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Well I'll just move over here until (if) .com rises from the ashes.

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 17:26

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by markmarkymark
Greetings All..

I did join some time ago - but not so active on here ...

cheers

Mark


good to see some new / old faces
:tu:

bigitup_j 21-11-2003 17:27

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
well...thought i'd better say something. so, goodbye .com, basically, hello community.ntl.com,
don't really have the same ring to it;
nthellworld...ntlcommunity.

nthw.co.uk is my new home...

:wavey:

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 17:29

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dezzo
Well I'll just move over here until (if) .com rises from the ashes.


meaning you prefer .com to this site i presume

zovat 21-11-2003 17:30

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bigitup_j
well...thought i'd better say something. so, goodbye .com, basically, hello community.ntl.com,
don't really have the same ring to it;
nthellworld...ntlcommunity.

nthw.co.uk is my new home...

:wavey:

I think that will be the case for many of us - even if .com re-opens, it will take time to re-build its reputation and trust with those of us that remember the statement - "new owner - same team and service" (or something like that :grind: )

bigitup_j 21-11-2003 17:31

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
i can't see ntl reopening nthw.com again, no point, as they'll just close it again and use the community forums.

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 17:33

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
I think that will be the case for many of us - even if .com re-opens, it will take time to re-build its reputation and trust with those of us that remember the statement - "new owner - same team and service" (or something like that :grind: )


IF it does it has lost most of my respect , i mean they couldnt even give a good excuse for it going apart from what neil posted or was he told to post it , not having a go at you neil btw , more to this than what has been said so far on there i reckon

Linda 21-11-2003 17:36

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
I've been reading over here for a little while - a few weeks before today.

Seems pleasant enough here and I noticed a lack of trolls. It was never my intention to have a swipe at anyone :ninja: but I came close last night at .com and that would have been a shame.

wheeliebin 21-11-2003 17:38

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
With respect to all concerned here, it was me who was on the conference call when the 'suspension' of the site was announced, & not the people who are debating this. The site had become unmanageable thanks to Erol & his 'user empowerment' mission-fact.


With respect to you Neil i think that NTHW.com has been under risk of this happening for some time now. I dont see how you and your admin team didnt see this coming. Trying to blame Erol is wrong imho. A discussion site is for discussing not censoring. I do beleive that if the NTHW.com admin team should have left along with frank. After all the .co.uk site has been here long enough. I believe that you as an admin are looking for others to blame as all you have lost is your admin role at .com . There will be plenty of customers needing help here, it may prove more worthwhile to stay here permanently and help customers who need it.
It seems to me that you are more intent on remaining as an admin at all costs otherwise you would have stood down a long time ago. I would guess that the .com site will be allowed to continue in a censored fashion, if this is the case will you stand down or carry on ?

I am not questioning your ability or willingness to help customers. I am however suggesting that you have lost sight of some things.

wheeliebin 21-11-2003 17:41

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zovat
:LOL:


LOL No doubt he will be getting OFTEL to sort it out :)

th'engineer 21-11-2003 17:43

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wheeliebin
With respect to you Neil i think that NTHW.com has been under risk of this happening for some time now. I dont see how you and your admin team didnt see this coming. Trying to blame Erol is wrong imho. A discussion site is for discussing not censoring. I do beleive that if the NTHW.com admin team should have left along with frank. After all the .co.uk site has been here long enough. I believe that you as an admin are looking for others to blame as all you have lost is your admin role at .com . There will be plenty of customers needing help here, it may prove more worthwhile to stay here permanently and help customers who need it.
It seems to me that you are more intent on remaining as an admin at all costs otherwise you would have stood down a long time ago. I would guess that the .com site will be allowed to continue in a censored fashion, if this is the case will you stand down or carry on ?

I am not questioning your ability or willingness to help customers. I am however suggesting that you have lost sight of some things.

nice to see you here wheeliebin

wheeliebin 21-11-2003 17:45

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by th'engineer
nice to see you here wheeliebin


Hi Theng .

Hope all is well in Castlefield!

You get about ;)

markmarkymark 21-11-2003 17:45

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Yo again

Must just say I have had a quick look around and its nice to see so many people here, and many people I recognise from .com. Further, clearly there is a massive amount of quality information here. I look really forward to being part of this ...

well done .co.uk - this site is mega

cheers

MArk

th'engineer 21-11-2003 17:47

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wheeliebin
Hi Theng .

Hope all is well in Castlefield!

You get about ;)

you geting your fields and tons mixed up:p

andygrif 21-11-2003 17:50

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by etccarmageddon
good point... pointing the finger of blame is easy. it was a cheap shot in my opinion to blame Erolz and Craig or anyone for that matter. other than the person who pulled the plug.

Not to mention potentially libellous.

etccarmageddon 21-11-2003 17:53

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
welcome aboard Andy. and wheelie bin. and marky mark.

Dee V. Bee 21-11-2003 19:05

Oh well even though I don't have any NTL services but am a former employee, I will stick around here and help customers when I can.

This is the second time there has been a suicide note on the .com home page. Cry wolf too many times and people start to ignore you....

paulyoung666 21-11-2003 19:07

Re: .com to be shut down temporarily
 
i wonder if this is truly nthellworld rising from the ashes of nthworld :tu:


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:00.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum