![]() |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
For the sake of a balanced discussion … he has a mandate from the one place he actually needs one. From the King, acting on advice, that he’s the one most likely to enjoy the confidence etc etc etc.
At the risk of taking this off on a tangent, I’m curious to hear other posters’ ideas for how this system should be reformed. Because it seems to me that simply holding another general election doesn’t actually address the claimed problem (we don’t elect a prime minister and it’s clear from detailed polling and regional variations in people’s reasons for voting for various candidates that most people understand that’s not what they’re doing). |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Regarding the new (again) Home Secretary, here is her recent signature piece that would not be out of place in Putins's Russia or North Korea: https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/pub...-anti-protest/ Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
All of those grounds are things a judge would have to review before deciding whether to grant an injunction. The bill empowers the Home Secretary to ask, not to act.
Presumably there’s some addendum to Godwin’s Law aimed at people who have totally devalued the word ‘fascism’ by using it against anyone minded to believe the police should have the power to ensure public safety rather than simply carrying a bottle of Loctite De-Bonder on their belt loops. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Quote:
Just as well he’s not leading a left wing socialist Government in South America or an oil rich one in the Middle East. It’d be grounds for US intervention. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
I’m no Sunak fan, I still think a GE should have happened. But we are, where we are. I do think in PMQs he gave Starmer a pasting, Starmer tried to attack him on the Nom-dom issue, but Sunak just threw it back regarding Starmer being the guy propping up Putin apologist, Jeremy Corbyn.
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
The issue with Truss was she tried to bulldoze through a completely different agenda claiming she had a mandate for this because Tory Members elected her for it. That blew up so they change PM again and this time with a different agenda. He has paid lip service to following the mandate from 2019 but let's see what actually comes out. We need to allow governing parties to change leaders - especially when it becomes clear the leader is a buffoon - but if these changes precipitate a big shift in ideology and policy then they should seek a mandate from the entire country rather than this self-absorbed melodrama we've seen from them this summer. A lot of this chaos has happened because the Tories wanted to have an internal debate on who they should be as a party. We elect parties on a general idea of who they are. We don't hand them the keys for 5 years to use the country as a test subject which they can use to experiment with their internal competing ideas. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Rishi Sunak brings back fracking ban lifted by Truss.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/u...-b2210893.html |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
We might also see triple-locked pensions not triple-locked again: https://twitter.com/JasonGroves1/sta...50247009189889
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
I think there is also a question of how much can a country change before it's better to just go back to the public and say that you need a new mandate.
It'll be disingenuous to hold the Tories to everything in the 2019 manfesto after COVID, after Ukraine and with high inflation across the world. That's why I think parties should govern to a theme/idea rather than explicitly the words as written in a prior time. However, if the change is so fundamental that it requires a fundamental shift in governing approach then wouldn't it be healthier to seek a new mandate? |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Our constitution is decorated by pageantry and crown authority but the reality is the King can’t do this without advice, and the advice is always that the leader of the largest party in the Commons is the choice for PM. The largest party in the Commons is put there by the electorate which understands it is voting for a batch of local MPs who will support one of a range of published manifestos for a period of up to 5 years. And the electorate also understands that manifesto commitments do not override prevailing political or economic conditions, and also that the next opportunity to judge the party of government against its manifesto is the next election. I know some people want to constantly paint this place like some sort of banana republic but the mess of the past few weeks ultimately shows that we are anything but. Truss and her fellow travellers tried to tear up the rules and conventions by force of will and they failed. The worst political instability in decades has simply demonstrated just how stable a system we fundamentally have. If Sunak can stabilise the ship in the coming weeks, then he should have the two-and-a-bit years left to led the party elected to government, to try to implement its manifesto. And then we will get a vote on whether to allow them to continue. Meanwhile nobody is going to park tanks on College Green, take over the BBC or start yelling viva la revolución from the palace balcony. If there’s one lesson to be learned here it’s that the constitutional position of the PM must be respected, and that means changing the leader mid-term must only be a job for those whose confidence the incomer requires, namely the Commons. Polling the wider party membership risks electing a Liz Truss and also gives succour to those who want to make ill-informed demands for a nationwide say in the process. Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Regardless of how many words you choose to describe it it’s neither a mandate from the party membership (who indeed chose someone else when he was on the ballot) nor from the electorate itself. If anything the Truss debacle undermines our democratic credentials rather than reinforces it. By your measure she had a mandate to deliver until she didn’t. Removing the right of a party membership to elect it’s leader is profoundly undemocratic. In turn when it picks a PM it evokes more images of Putin’s Russia than home of the self-styled mother of all Parliaments. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Until the Tories bring in a properly Conservative prime minister, I'm not voting for them again.
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
- The UK's too populated for fracking so some towns and villages would be negatively impacted. - Any gas would be sold to the highest bidder globally and there would not be enough to impact global prices. - It would take several years for gas to be extracted so would come on stream when the immediate crisis is over. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
I don't want to go too much off-topic on this but to respond to your points.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 16:26 ---------- Previous post was at 16:17 ---------- Quote:
I think that if a PM is changed, we should mandate a GE. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Spurrier's submission is hardly bringing anything novel to the discussion in any case. New acts of parliament often bring activities that previously were not criminal into the purview of criminal law. That's sort of the whole point. People find new and inventive ways of imposing themselves on others; eventually the put-upon majority decides enough is enough and begins to demand action. Sooner or later, politicians hear the clamour, realise it's a popular issue, and act on it. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
To paraphrase you essentially say a majority can elect away the rights of minorities should they feel suitably aggrieved without reference to any protections of fundamental rights (for example that to protest, or that to strike). Both among the first to go as fascism rises, usually with a democratic mandate. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Quote:
Although I did make a mistake in my previous post because I almost implied if this Government did so it had democratic mandate for it. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
https://www.theguardian.com/world/20...more-difficult Quote:
https://www.theguardian.com/commenti...ection-protest Quote:
---------- Post added at 17:21 ---------- Previous post was at 17:19 ---------- Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
(And just because you predict someone will say you’re over-reacting, does not mean that they’re wrong) ;) |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
The right to block roads (and by corollary allow people to die in ambulances) should be severely curtailed. In some ways, it's a pity that the law won't prescribe that people glued to walls should be left there so that they pee their pants, shit their clothes and end up with the worst of it. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
The former Chairman of the Conservative Party has said there were multiple breaches of the ministerial code from Braverman's
https://twitter.com/PiersUncensored/...61104062058508 Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Peston reporting here that Sunak is believed to have over-ruled cabinet secretary Case in re-appointing Suella Braverman.
He notes that this raises important constitutional issues, particularly the role of the Cabinet Secretary in preventing ministers from becoming a security risk. William Wragg, Chair of the Commons Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, is being urged to investigate this. https://twitter.com/Peston/status/1585321216318898176 |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
I repeat my point from earlier, the proposal is to grant the Home Secretary the power to ask, not to act. A judge would decide whether the situation satisfied what is clearly quite a high legal bar in terms of the seriousness of disruption. Insinuating that people who attend a half-million march through London in 2023 face any significant prospect of getting caught in some neo-fascist dragnet any time up to 2028 is absurd. But then his nickname isn’t Moonbat for nothing. This is the man who thinks 75 million ha.of agricultural land in continental Europe should be ‘rewilded’. Ukraine has 41m ha, and look how close some parts of the developing world are to serious food shortages this winter just because *some* of what’s grown there can’t get out. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 23:18 ---------- Previous post was at 23:16 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
So business as usual?Hopefully until the GE.
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
https://www.sciencemediacentre.org/e...ergy-security/ Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Have never been convinced of fracking argument, plus, the sheer amounts of shale gas, is not guaranteed for UK domestic markets, it will be extracted and sold to highest bidder.
It was the stupidest idea ever, to cease our storage capacity of gas, become too reliant on imports, no one ever thinking that one day, that supply is rationed as Europe suffers with energy stocks, thanks to Putin. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...cerns-MI5.html Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
A more complete summary of the Act: https://www.cableforum.uk/images/local/2022/10/10.jpg |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
All I’m hearing, in protest against this bill is self-serving demands that those who think they’ve found a means of holding society to ransom in pursuit of their political goals, should be allowed to carry on, and the rest of us should just let them get on with it, or, worse, abandon our own convictions and give in to their blackmail. Well I’m sorry but no. If people want to bring the M25 to a halt, cause millions in lost business and prevent tens of thousands of people from going about their business, then I’m more than happy for them to spend a few weeks in jail in recompense. If nothing else, it will weed out the dilettantes who think this lunacy is an attractive way of virtue signalling to their mates. (Edit) And references to Russia, Iran and Egypt are simply more contemptible left-wing dog whistling, and nonsensical to anyone who is actually familiar with what human rights abuses in those countries actually look like. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
BREAKING: Speaker suspends Commons for an hour due to Penny Mordaunt no-show - Independent.
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Update: Penny met with King Charles III, as part of her remit of Lord President of the council, while she was due to answer leader of the house questions in Parliament. - Guido.
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
John, ian is off on one. He ignores the need for such a law and focuses only on the comparison with Russia. Totally ridiculous. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 14:37 ---------- Previous post was at 14:35 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
At a literal reading it has the potential to outlaw protest and removes rights under the Human Rights Act for peaceful assembly and association among people who haven’t actually committed any offences at all. Over decades and centuries the history of this country is littered with protests. In no way, shape or form can anyone claim that disruption now meaningfully disrupts people’s lives any more than at any point in history. It’s a lazy right wing trope to claim that they do. But when your economic policies (not you personally) are shot to pieces I suppose that’s all they have left. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
I really cant be bothered to read through pages of more arguments, so someone please tell me - What exactly has all this got to do with the topic (Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister) ?
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
I’m not being patronising. I am criticising your paranoia. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 17:26 ---------- Previous post was at 17:24 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 18:15 ---------- Previous post was at 18:13 ---------- Quote:
Here's an article from Justice on the dangers of the Bill: https://justice.org.uk/public-order-bill/ There is even an article on Conservative Home :) MPs must make a stand against the Public Order Bill’s restrictions on free speech |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
:rofl:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
I don't think there's been a backlash here about Sunak's race, as alleged in the US's Daily Show. There will always be some people that hold this view but I don't think it's a significant proportion of the electorate.
He's of course received criticism over Suella Braverman's appointment and for his wife's former tax status. https://www.msn.com/en-gb/entertainm...6b8d18f8606559 |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
As far as I can tell the evidence for this "backlash" is based solely on one idiot that called into LBC or Talk TV. I don't think anyone (apart from the usual nutters) could care less about his ethnicity, we just want him to sort this mess out. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
The US commentary on the U.K is almost always very bad. They can't help but see everything through their own lens. That's why they think Boris Johnson was Trump.
That Noah commentary is awful. First of all anyone who says 'the Prime Minister of England' should then be ignored when commenting on British politics but he sets up a strawman so he can have a US-Centric argument. He even said it was ironic Brexiters ended up with an Asian PM which makes no sense at all. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 11:41 ---------- Previous post was at 11:40 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
"Xenophobic" may be a better term. Every faction has its proportion of racists so picking on Brexiteers, especially in the context of Sunak, is poor rhetoric. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Assigning precise numbers is difficult due to the complexity and nuance in the competing factors that went into the 2016 decision. Here is an interesting article in Nature on this precise subject: Prejudice and the Brexit vote: a tangled web |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
I’ve read that article - it is a very bad article, imo. It lumps all of the ”nuances” of prejudice such as Islamophobia, Homophobia etc into equating prejudice with racism. Clearly this is where you get to use the term “racism”, possibly to emphasise your point but the article on which you rely explains why it does not use the word "racism". So the first think to debunk is the article’s equivalence of prejudice with racism. We all have prejudices to a certain degree (nuance). For example, people may be prejudiced against Germans because of what happened 80 years ago; even though it’s ridiculous to be prejudiced against all Germans, it can’t be said to be racist, although the article includes that sort of prejudice and classifies this as racist. Quote:
Finally, the paper falls down on the first sentence of the extract pasted below. Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
I can't imagine that the section of your regional compatriots who voted for Brexit voted to avoid a PM of Asian heritage. That article was rubbish and you did rely on it to support your notion of racism, preferring the term to "prejudice". Very naughty but it fits your narrative of regarding Brexiteers as somewhat despicable. Naught but not nice. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 23:01 ---------- Previous post was at 22:55 ---------- Quote:
Anyway, that's enough on the irony of Sunak. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
---------- Post added at 07:51 ---------- Previous post was at 07:48 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Just when the government was looking cohesive, who pops up to give Starmer a helping hand?
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
TBH, I dont give a flying **** about who attends COP27.
No doubt that annoying teenager will be there. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Some more changes:
- Williamson has resigned over the bullying allegations - Investment zones are due to be axed in the Autum statement https://news.sky.com/story/sir-gavin...lying-12742023 |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Ah, the old "It wasn't me, Guv!" excuse...
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-63592909 Apparently, a big girl made him do it, then ran away... Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
They used to be good friends, I bet they aren't any more. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Most of the leaks around the time did suggest it was Truss who was the more bullish of the two on the mini-budget. Besides she said she was going to do this in her leadership bid so she can't claim otherwise.
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Never mind I'm sure there's goodies for all in the Budget this week. I have faith that 12 years of austerity/the Tories, plus our Brexit bonus is about to be rewarded.. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
Not going so well with that other one, Raab. Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
And with worse to come.. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
I think we reached rock bottom with Truss. The last few Prime Ministers have been successively worse but Sunak is an improvement on Truss but not without his mistakes.
Dominic Raab will be taking PMQs today. This surely can't go well given the bullying allegations hanging over him. |
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
Re: Rishi Sunak is Prime Minister
Quote:
|
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:40. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum