![]() |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Or something like that. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
The question I’m asking you is which programmes does the BBC make that other channels wouldn’t if the BBC ceased to exist? Songs of Praise is the only one I can come up with. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
I provided two programmes that showed they did. Whether other channels would show these events in the absence of the BBC was not in the question. Obviously, popular shows like these would be viable for any commercial channel. |
Re: TV licence fee
The problem with the BBC is that it is a law unto itself, leading to the £159 licence fee. The famous 43p/day for a week is half a chicken to poor families.
Being a law unto itself, a variant of Parkinson's Law has been applied, allowing the BBC to grow and increase its capacity rather than remain within previous boundaries. Something along the lines that I posted here should be the way forward and better still to be supported by advertising. EDIT: Thought for a Sunday: In the beginning the lord gave the word and the word was "cash" (not the BBC). |
Re: TV licence fee
A chicken for 86p??
How is the BBC a "law unto itself", when the Government appoint the Board, set the Licence Fee, are currently conducting a Mid-Term Review (run by the Secretary of State for the DCMS) focussing on the governance and regulatory arrangements for the BBC, and it is regulated by OFCOM and audited by the National Audit Office? |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
‘The BBC is a public service broadcaster making programmes and providing services others don't as they don't make money.’ |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Over 2.5 million viewers watch Eastenders. Statistica has the BBC having 55 million viewers over a year but dunno how they work it out
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Quote:
Old Boy has since posed a new question but it's not one I have the answer to as quickly. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
More than 50% of TV viewers ticks my box for "most of us" but you may well have a broader definition than this, which is your perogative. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Eurovision is not a good example, Andrew, given it’s popularity (not in this house, mind). |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Obviously, you're not going to get the majority of the population watching one TV programme when there's other forms of entertainment out there. So I know Old Boy is bright enough not to mean this unusual definition and instead the industry definition as used in BroadbandTVNews. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
However, I don't agree with The Daddy when he says that most of us don't watch the BBC. On the contrary, I think most do, but my argument is that those who don't shouldn't have to pay, and that is why I like the idea of a subscription model for today's audience. I also think there should be an ad-funded version available for those who do not wish or cannot pay. The constant refrain that other channels would not make some of the programmes it does if the Beeb didn't exist I find hard to fathom. There are examples of similar programmes on other channels, which disproves that. If the BBC didn't already have the rights to Eurovision, Wimbledon, etc, do you really think other channels wouldn't pick them up? |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
https://www.nuj.org.uk/resource-repo...ats-facts.html |
Re: TV licence fee
My BBC watching is mainly Politics Live, Newsnight, Antiques Roadshow (sometimes); the odd Drama series.
Newsnight has an ITV equivalent, Peston. Current news I can get from many sources and GB News is getting there, I would add. ARENA and the like appear on the UK TV type channels so no issue there. BBC in its current bloated form is not a necessity, imo. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
My more fundamental point is that we're the fifth richest country in the world. If people cannot afford to pay for a TV licence then there's something fundamentally wrong with the country. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Whilst what you say is true, it's definitely not the point. A TV licence, forcing people to pay for something they might not want, on pain of criminal record, is plain wrong. A different funding model for the BBC must be found or a very much lower licence fee for a cut down BBC and no criminality for not paying. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
But I agree that despite what some people claim, most do watch it, albeit some occasionally, and if the licence fee changed to a subscription fee with only a modest increase in payment, it would be a workable proposition.The advertisement laden alternative would make up any shortfall. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
---------- Post added at 17:23 ---------- Previous post was at 17:21 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Having seen many TV shows being filmed (Including QI), the do many retake's to make it broadcastable, and when stuff goes wrong. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Why do I say "partially"? To me, this is the real debating ground. Should catering for various minorities or cultures by adding new channels be a decision that comes at the BBC's whim when it implies an increase in licence fee? SHould the BBC cater for minorities within the BBC1 / BBC2 constraints? |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
No wonder the BCC need more than £159 for their licence fee; they gratuitously decided that the programme needed 4 hosts, including Mary Berry and that ridiculous Sue Perkins. Jeez, what money wasters. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
The BBC programme was a pudding for Liz.
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
I appreciate that there are alleged workarounds, but it shouldn't be necessary to do that. I acknowledge that at this point in time, a subscription system won't work because anyone can receive a signal free of charge through their aerial. However, there will be no excuse when we go IPTV only, which believe me is the way things are going. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
If we all stream everything thing it will buffer a lot more. Terrestrial is here for a few decades yet . |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
TBH most of what I view is downloaded series I watch very little live TV. If I can get rid of the stream box next negotiation in July I may stop paying it |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Are you sure? |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
I only watch Rugby League which is broadcasted by SKY. Why should the BBC get a payment for a channel they do not own, have no involvement with at all simply because i choice to watch SKY ?.
---------- Post added at 13:15 ---------- Previous post was at 13:11 ---------- Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
https://inews.co.uk/news/new-culture...rapped-1837803
Nice to see that the new Culture Secretary wants the BBC licence fee abolished. I hope she gets on with it. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
The latest in a long line to fail. |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
Not saying she’s likely to have changed her mind, but context is important. Personal views expressed a few years ago don’t translate immediately into policy proposals. Sometimes they don’t translate at all, because some things are too big for one minister to change by fiat. |
Re: TV licence fee
Should have been scrapped years ago. Corrupted organisation.
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
:D |
Re: TV licence fee
Had 2 threatening letters already and not even cancelled it a month yet hahaha
|
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
You are under no obligation to open your door and certainly no obligation to let them in. They have NO right of entry, whatever they might like to imply. As for TV detectors: That's gawping in your window or listening through the letterbox.:D |
Re: TV licence fee
Quote:
|
Re: TV licence fee
Yeah those TV detector vans are a load of nonsense.
The may have existed many moons ago but with the amount of different signals zapping round the place now they'd have no chance. I get an e-mail every 18 months or so where I have to state I do not require a license. I watch no BBC channels and am mostly on Netflix, Disney+, or other subscription channels. |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:24. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum