Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Election 2019 Exit Poll (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33708500)

Sephiroth 13-12-2019 19:20

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by noel43 (Post 36020221)
All of them. He will now sell this country to america for a silver dollar.

Evidence? No wisdom behind your statement.

papa smurf 13-12-2019 19:29

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36020236)
Evidence? No wisdom behind your statement.

Let the Labour voters grieve in any way that gives them comfort;)

Sephiroth 13-12-2019 19:47

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36020237)
Let the Labour voters grieve in any way that gives them comfort;)

Why? A vote for Corbyn's party was a vote that tolerated antisemitism. They should be reflecting on their disgraceful choice of party.

papa smurf 13-12-2019 21:21

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36020239)
Why? A vote for Corbyn's party was a vote that tolerated antisemitism. They should be reflecting on their disgraceful choice of party.

Jezza said it's time for reflection,maybe they are reflecting on their actions /inactions/ choices :shrug:

nomadking 13-12-2019 21:26

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
People like Corbyn and McDonnell, along with their supporters and polices haven't just sprung up in the past couple of years. They've been around for decades. Labour have had plenty of time to deal with them.

OLD BOY 14-12-2019 07:50

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36020239)
Why? A vote for Corbyn's party was a vote that tolerated antisemitism. They should be reflecting on their disgraceful choice of party.

Antisemitism would have been the least of our problems if that rabble had got in.

Sephiroth 14-12-2019 08:50

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OLD BOY (Post 36020248)
Antisemitism would have been the least of our problems if that rabble had got in.

No, OB. That ranks high alongside the other bad stuff those commie sumps would have inflicted on us.

I am proud of the British people who rejected every aspect of Corbynism, and those who voted Labour should re-evaluate themselves on the antisemitism basis at the very least and then remember Corbyn’s support for terrorist organisations around the world. Corbyn May be finished but his sentiments remain among those who voted Labour.


Hugh 14-12-2019 09:08

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Must be nice to have a viewpoint that has no shades of grey, and everything in the world can have broad brushstrokes applied to it, and nuance doesn’t exist.

"All those who disagree with me are completely wrong, and it’s OK to apply actions of a minority of a group to all members of that group, and castigate and denigrate all members of that group" seems to be a very simplistic approach to a very complex issue.

Can you imagine the outrage if others applied that viewpoint to all members of the Conservative party, saying they held the same viewpoints as some of the virulent supporters of Boris, such as Katie Hopkins and Tommy Robinson, or the Conservative candidate for Leeds North East who was de-selected for his Antisemitic views?

OLD BOY 14-12-2019 10:01

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36020251)
No, OB. That ranks high alongside the other bad stuff those commie sumps would have inflicted on us.

I am proud of the British people who rejected every aspect of Corbynism, and those who voted Labour should re-evaluate themselves on the antisemitism basis at the very least and then remember Corbyn’s support for terrorist organisations around the world. Corbyn May be finished but his sentiments remain among those who voted Labour.


In no way am I minimising the impact of Labour's antisemitism problems and the impact on the Jewish people. But even that is dwarfed by sheer the devastation that would have been inflicted on this country by Labour's economic policies under the Corbyn regime. Added to that, the very security and safety of our country was at severe risk from this Marxist threat.

Fortunately, the electorate have more common sense than to vote in favour of such an agenda. In fact, over the years, the electorate seem to have made pretty good judgements about which government was likely to serve the country better, and this is but the latest example. The hard left will never find favour with the British people. It's not what we are.

papa smurf 14-12-2019 12:38

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
John McDonnell admits he won't be part of new Labour leadership team 'We will all go'


https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/12...ection-results


JOHN MCDONNELL has revealed a completely new team will be appointed for the next Labour's shadow cabinet following the staggering defeat of Jeremy Corbyn's party at the general election.

Chris 14-12-2019 14:23

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Absolutely delicious ... Boris begins his victory lap in Sedgefield, Labour ex-stronghold and former constituency of one Anthony Charles Lynton Blair :D

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2019-50790445

Julian 14-12-2019 15:32

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
An interesting opinion piece on Labour's collapse HERE

The journalist makes some apparently valid points.

Pierre 14-12-2019 16:47

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36020283)
John McDonnell admits he won't be part of new Labour leadership team 'We will all go'


https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/12...ection-results


JOHN MCDONNELL has revealed a completely new team will be appointed for the next Labour's shadow cabinet following the staggering defeat of Jeremy Corbyn's party at the general election.

But if it’s orchestrated by Momentum it will be more of the same.

papa smurf 14-12-2019 16:49

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Where it all went wrong for Melanie Onn - and the guy from Cuba who became a symbol for how Corbyn and co just did not get Grimsby

https://www.grimsbytelegraph.co.uk/n...n-cuba-3642843

OLD BOY 14-12-2019 20:33

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36020302)
But if it’s orchestrated by Momentum it will be more of the same.

Which is good news for the Conservatives.

Do Labour wish to continue to be the main party of opposition?

---------- Post added at 20:33 ---------- Previous post was at 20:32 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36020293)
Absolutely delicious ... Boris begins his victory lap in Sedgefield, Labour ex-stronghold and former constituency of one Anthony Charles Lynton Blair :D

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/election-2019-50790445

Marking out his territory!

Damien 14-12-2019 20:54

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
I saw this: https://twitter.com/JakeLex1989/stat...39960739696641

Quote:

OK guys, we're organising a rally in #Islington some time in early to mid Feb 2020 to show our thanks to @jeremycorbyn. Early stages right now but for updates you can follow @JezzFest which is the dedicated account. Would love to see you all there!! ��✊��❤️
Just in case any of you Tory voters wanted to pop along and show your appreciation for everything Corbyn has done for you. ;)

Chris 14-12-2019 20:57

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36020328)
I saw this: https://twitter.com/JakeLex1989/stat...39960739696641



Just in case any of you Tory voters wanted to pop along and show your appreciation for everything Corbyn has done for you. ;)

Oh, Jeremy Corbyn!

:rofl:

papa smurf 14-12-2019 21:21

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36020328)
I saw this: https://twitter.com/JakeLex1989/stat...39960739696641



Just in case any of you Tory voters wanted to pop along and show your appreciation for everything Corbyn has done for you. ;)

We couldn't have won without him :tu:

OLD BOY 14-12-2019 22:23

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36020332)
We couldn't have won without him :tu:

If he stayed on, we could win again!

1andrew1 14-12-2019 22:30

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36020328)
I saw this: https://twitter.com/JakeLex1989/stat...39960739696641



Just in case any of you Tory voters wanted to pop along and show your appreciation for everything Corbyn has done for you. ;)

Is Dominic Cummings organising it? ;)

Uncle Peter 15-12-2019 17:49

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36020302)
But if it’s orchestrated by Momentum it will be more of the same.

Momentum are probably lining up a talent show on Channel 4 to find the next Trotskyist narcissist to don the Comrade Lenin cap.

Search for a Red Star ?

I'm not repressed yet, get me out of here?

papa smurf 18-12-2019 12:47

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Uncle Peter (Post 36020383)
Momentum are probably lining up a talent show on Channel 4 to find the next Trotskyist narcissist to don the Comrade Lenin cap.

Search for a Red Star ?

I'm not repressed yet, get me out of here?

Emily five belly's is going for it'
https://www.express.co.uk/news/polit...johnson-brexit

Chris 18-12-2019 14:35

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 36020615)
Emily five belly's is going for it'
https://www.express.co.uk/news/polit...johnson-brexit

Because working class Labour voters don’t feel patronised enough yet.

papa smurf 18-12-2019 15:29

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36020621)
Because working class Labour voters don’t feel patronised enough yet.

They need someone superior to look up to;)

papa smurf 19-12-2019 18:05

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Melanie Onn blanked by Jeremy Corbyn as he walks past her without a word following catastrophic Labour election


https://www.grimsbytelegraph.co.uk/n...corbyn-3659414

It's not just Boris that jezza is blanking.

Sephiroth 27-12-2019 20:36

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Gues what I got as a Christmas present (nicely framed):

https://bobcartoons.newsprints.co.uk...0corbyn%20ciga

Beautiful.

---------- Post added at 20:36 ---------- Previous post was at 20:34 ----------

... and this is one I bought last year. Brilliant.

https://bobcartoons.newsprints.co.uk...may%20wait%20i

Mr K 27-12-2019 21:17

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36021333)
Gues what I got as a Christmas present (nicely framed):

https://bobcartoons.newsprints.co.uk...0corbyn%20ciga

Beautiful.

---------- Post added at 20:36 ---------- Previous post was at 20:34 ----------

... and this is one I bought last year. Brilliant.

https://bobcartoons.newsprints.co.uk...may%20wait%20i

Wouldn't socks have been better for Xmas? They'll be more useful than Boris. He's decided to the ignore the floods now the elections over and bugger off to the Carribbean.....

Sephiroth 27-12-2019 22:15

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021336)
Wouldn't socks have been better for Xmas? They'll be more useful than Boris. He's decided to the ignore the floods now the elections over and bugger off to the Carribbean.....

Got those too.

OLD BOY 30-12-2019 16:10

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021336)
Wouldn't socks have been better for Xmas? They'll be more useful than Boris. He's decided to the ignore the floods now the elections over and bugger off to the Carribbean.....

No doubt, you expected him to man the pumps personally? :rolleyes:

Well, I've got news for you. He's got a chap for that. :D

tweetiepooh 31-12-2019 09:29

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
The man is entitled to a holiday - best taken when parliament isn't doing much and much of the rest of the world has also slowed down. And what would he add? If he did attend some would say that he is just publicity seeking in areas he doesn't normally show up in.

Sephiroth 31-12-2019 10:43

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Mr K is just indulging in irrational sour grapes. The General Election has put Mr K in his proper place.

Mr K 31-12-2019 11:00

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36021645)
Mr K is just indulging in irrational sour grapes. The General Election has put Mr K in his proper place.

Glad you think so ! :D :D

---------- Post added at 11:00 ---------- Previous post was at 10:58 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by tweetiepooh (Post 36021635)
The man is entitled to a holiday - best taken when parliament isn't doing much and much of the rest of the world has also slowed down. And what would he add? If he did attend some would say that he is just publicity seeking in areas he doesn't normally show up in.

Its the sort of crap he did during the GE campaign. Likewise, I doubt we'll ever see him near an NHS hospital again....

Sephiroth 31-12-2019 11:10

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021647)
Glad you think so ! :D :D

---------- Post added at 11:00 ---------- Previous post was at 10:58 ----------



Its the sort of crap he did during the GE campaign. Likewise, I doubt we'll ever see him near an NHS hospital again....

There you go again. Gratuitous negativity just nbecause you don't like the Tories and BoJo in particular. I'm no fan of BoJo for reasons explained at the past but I don't let that spoil my objectivity.

Mr K 31-12-2019 11:13

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36021650)
There you go again. Gratuitous negativity just nbecause you don't like the Tories and BoJo in particular. I'm no fan of BoJo for reasons explained at the past but I don't let that spoil my objectivity.

Well I shall expect to see him at the opening of each of the 40 new hospitals he's promised very shortly...

heero_yuy 31-12-2019 12:13

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Even your Marxist Labour party cannot magically produce hospitals out of thin air no matter how much they claim they'd spend.

Mr K 31-12-2019 12:58

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 36021660)
Even your Marxist Labour party cannot magically produce hospitals out of thin air no matter how much they claim they'd spend.

Boris can though, it seems. 40 new hospitals promised, 40 new hospitals now expected (does anyone know the locations?) , oh and 50,000 new nurses, which should be interesting given they can't fill 43,000 vacancies at the moment. Maybe the EU will supply them.as overseas aid to deprived countries?

OLD BOY 31-12-2019 15:06

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021652)
Well I shall expect to see him at the opening of each of the 40 new hospitals he's promised very shortly...

He didn't say 'shortly', as you well know. You will not win any arguments on here if you distort the facts. They will always suss you out!

---------- Post added at 15:06 ---------- Previous post was at 15:04 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021666)
Boris can though, it seems. 40 new hospitals promised, 40 new hospitals now expected (does anyone know the locations?) , oh and 50,000 new nurses, which should be interesting given they can't fill 43,000 vacancies at the moment. Maybe the EU will supply them.as overseas aid to deprived countries?

What's wrong with qualified doctors and nurses outside of the EU?

Once again, get your timetable right, Mr K.

Sephiroth 01-01-2020 20:38

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
I'm just grateful that we have a Conservative government that can actually govern.

All Boris needs to do is lead on and deliver his promises.


Mr K 02-01-2020 07:10

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36021789)
I'm just grateful that we have a Conservative government that can actually govern.

All Boris needs to do is lead on and deliver his promises.


That's going to be difficult for an habitual liar, who has been sacked from 3 jobs for telling porky pies.

denphone 02-01-2020 08:05

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021801)
That's going to be difficult for an habitual liar, who has been sacked from 3 jobs for telling porky pies.

The clear general election result means that the Boris Johnson and Tories now fully own Brexit and all of its consequences.

There will be no parliamentary paralysis or obstructive opposition parties to blame if it goes horribly wrong as the buck stops with them and them only.

Sephiroth 02-01-2020 09:16

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Fair point, Den.

tweetiepooh 02-01-2020 10:00

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
It will all have been even better with a different result. Always the way.

An asteroid could hit London and it will be those in charges' fault, it could miss and still their fault because it could have.

This is not to say that there isn't consequence to action but some can't win - damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Pierre 02-01-2020 10:59

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021801)
That's going to be difficult for an habitual liar, who has been sacked from 3 jobs for telling porky pies.

Well we’ll know in five years, as that is how long he has to set his promises in motion.

1andrew1 02-01-2020 16:23

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by denphone (Post 36021802)
The clear general election result means that the Boris Johnson and Tories now fully own Brexit and all of its consequences.

There will be no parliamentary paralysis or obstructive opposition parties to blame if it goes horribly wrong as the buck stops with them and them only.

I'm sure the EU and some of its member states will be scapegoated during the course of this Parliament. "The buck stops here" is not in Cummings' phrase book.

Sephiroth 02-01-2020 17:35

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36021829)
I'm sure the EU and some of its member states will be scapegoated during the course of this Parliament. "The buck stops here" is not in Cummings' phrase book.

Bleat, bleat bleat. So what? They're gonna try to stiff us during trade negotiations and we (UK) are entitled to scapegoat accordingly.

Mr K 02-01-2020 18:17

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36021833)
Bleat, bleat bleat. So what? They're gonna try to stiff us during trade negotiations and we (UK) are entitled to scapegoat accordingly.

I thought our position was strong and the EU would give us all we want.? If so, why do we need to scapegoat anybody?

27 versus 1, work it out. Who is in the the stronger negotiating position? The UK is going to have a very bad hangover from this.


.

1andrew1 02-01-2020 19:08

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sephiroth (Post 36021833)
Bleat, bleat bleat. So what? They're gonna try to stiff us during trade negotiations and we (UK) are entitled to scapegoat accordingly.

The general point is that now the opposition can't be blamed, others will be found instead. We've already seen today's announcement that Northern Rail is losing its franchise early, whereas most of the problems lie with the Government-owned Network Rail. Expect more of this type of thing with the EU, civil servants and outsourcing companies picking up the rap for anything going imperfectly, even if it is actually the Government's fault.

Hugh 02-01-2020 20:30

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
But if they won't give us what we want, it's their fault, surely?

nomadking 02-01-2020 20:56

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
The bigger problem is those that keep convincing the EU that we will roll over and agree to whatever they say.

Hugh 02-01-2020 21:13

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36021852)
The bigger problem is those that keep convincing the EU that we will roll over and agree to whatever they say.

But surely they will only listen to those in charge, who say the opposite?

1andrew1 02-01-2020 23:05

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadking (Post 36021852)
The bigger problem is those that keep convincing the EU that we will roll over and agree to whatever they say.

Much as I would like to see BoJo called out on this - for his withdrawal agreement is precisely as you describe - I don't think the British electorate has the energy for yet another general election! ;)

---------- Post added at 23:05 ---------- Previous post was at 21:19 ----------

Meanwhile, Dominic Cummings is seeking "Weirdos and misfits with odd skills" and other talented individuals to work for him.
https://dominiccummings.com/2020/01/...orted-weirdos/

Pierre 02-01-2020 23:58

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36021837)
27 versus 1, work it out. Who is in the the stronger negotiating position? The UK is going to have a very bad hangover from this.
.

But that 1 is a very big 1

https://fullfact.org/economy/uk-largest-economies-eu/

https://facts4eu.org/news/2019_apr_eu28_to_eu10

A trade deal, an equitable trade deal, is both parties interest, and the U.K. is no minion in this.

heero_yuy 20-01-2020 14:12

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Quote from Politicshome: The Tories have a 17-point lead over Labour as Boris Johnson exceeds voters' expectations in Number 10, according to a new poll.

The Opinium survey puts the Conservatives on 47%, compared to 30% for Labour. Support for the the Lib Dems, meanwhile, is at just 9%.

At the general election last month, the Tories received around 43% of the vote, compared to Labour's 32%.
Looks like Boris' honeymoon is still going.

Mr K 20-01-2020 20:26

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 36023196)
Looks like Boris' honeymoon is still going.

Honeymoon over...
Quote:

Boris Johnson suffers first parliamentary defeat since election
Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal has received a setback in the Lords over the right of EU citizens to be given official documentation if they lawfully reside in the UK after Brexit.

Peers backed a cross-party amendment to the European Union (withdrawal agreement) bill allowing them physical proof of their status – the first defeat for the government since the general election.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics...y_to_clipboard

Chris 20-01-2020 20:33

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36023243)

No need to wet your pants over a symbolic defeat in the Lords where the government doesn’t have a majority.

They will simply overturn the amendments when the bill returns to the Commons, and thereafter convention requires the Lords to leave it alone because it is a matter of government policy that is subject to a manifesto commitment.

Mick 21-01-2020 07:07

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36023243)

Oh dear, someone doesn’t quite know the difference between the Elected and Unelected chambers.

1andrew1 26-01-2020 14:24

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Interesting article by Dan Hodges on why some ministers are asking if Boris has any idea on what he's going to do apart from Brexit.
Quote:

...No clear line on Iran. Uncertainty and continued Cabinet infighting over Huawei. Chaotic briefing and counter-briefing over HS2. Most tellingly of all, little, 45 days in, that even resembles a coherent strategy or vision for the country.

Another Minister painted the following picture: 'Everything's just being left to pile up. We had no coherent Iran response for days. We've got HS2, another rail report, 5G, something on education, the Budget and nothing's being decided.'...
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/a...clue-next.html

Pierre 26-01-2020 16:48

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 1andrew1 (Post 36023650)
Interesting article by Dan Hodges on why some ministers are asking if Boris has any idea on what he's going to do apart from Brexit.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/a...clue-next.html

Interesting if you like journalists and newspapers that lost the Brexit argument and now have turned their sights on attacking the government. Given the total paralysis the country has been in for the last 3+ years, I’m willing to give them a little more time.

No doubt Huawei is a delicate issue - all I’d say as someone who works in telecoms is that I wouldn’t use them, or limit their use to passive components.

HS2 will definitely go ahead from London to Birmingham. It’s the onward sections that are an issue. Given that many Northerners lent their vote to the Tory’s he can’t be seen to ditch them, so some skilful politicking is required.

The criticism over Iran is baseless.

Hugh 26-01-2020 17:13

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36023663)
Interesting if you like journalists and newspapers that lost the Brexit argument and now have turned their sights on attacking the government. Given the total paralysis the country has been in for the last 3+ years, I’m willing to give them a little more time.

No doubt Huawei is a delicate issue - all I’d say as someone who works in telecoms is that I wouldn’t use them, or limit their use to passive components.

HS2 will definitely go ahead from London to Birmingham. It’s the onward sections that are an issue. Given that many Northerners lent their vote to the Tory’s he can’t be seen to ditch them, so some skilful politicking is required.

The criticism over Iran is baseless.

Dan Hodges writes for the Mail on Sunday, and before that, the Telegraph and the Spectator (not reknowned for being anti-Brexit)...

He also supported BJ in his campaign to be Mayor of London.

nomadking 26-01-2020 17:18

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
So who does have the definitive answers on those matter, and what are they? Gets tedious people saying X doesn't have an answer for Y, when they don't either, other than giving in to their demands.

Chris 26-01-2020 17:49

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Hugh (Post 36023667)
Dan Hodges writes for the Mail on Sunday, and before that, the Telegraph and the Spectator (not reknowned for being anti-Brexit)...

He also supported BJ in his campaign to be Mayor of London.

Dan Hodges is Glenda Jackson’s son, a former Labour Party member (I think he left after Corbyn got the leadership) and was definitely on the Blairite wing of the party.

I used to very much enjoy reading him back in the halcyon days of the Telegraph Blogs. He was challenging of the assumptions of the centre right that are often lazily and uncritically accepted on papers like the telegraph or the mail, while also being a very accessible voice of the left, which all too often is unbearably self righteous and shrill.

Damien 26-01-2020 19:18

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Hodges has been extremely critical of Labour since 2010 though, as Chris says he is clearly on the 'right' of the Labour Party. So I think he has earned the right to be listened too by the right as he isn't a propagandist for the left.

---------- Post added at 19:18 ---------- Previous post was at 19:09 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36023663)
I
HS2 will definitely go ahead from London to Birmingham. It’s the onward sections that are an issue. Given that many Northerners lent their vote to the Tory’s he can’t be seen to ditch them, so some skilful politicking is required.
.

HS2 should just happen now. Just do it.

People are deluded if they think it's cancellation will lead to investment in the existing railway infrastructure in the North instead. The same thing will happen again. There will be years, far beyond this Government's parliamentary term, of public consultation and government case studies before anything is proposed. Then, between 2025 and 2030, when a proposal is put forward it'll be beset by court cases and disagreement with politicians of every stripe opposing it in favour of something else before a final plan is somehow agreed in 2035 and we're all back here in 2040 wondering if it's about to be cancelled. :rolleyes:

This country is absolutely pathetic when it comes to infrastructure projects. It's a wonder we have a Eurostar or M25. How we built the London Underground will become a mystery to future generations of Brits in the same way the Pyramids are now.

It may not be the most optimal use of money but HS2 is a unicorn in that it's a project that is actually being built and has passed all the bureaucracy and nonsense that we throw at any attempt to do anything.

A case in point is a new bridge at the Dartford Crossing on the M25. The tunnel itself, running from South to North, is already a nightmare. For over 10 years they've been having public discussions on how/when/where to build another bridge (to match the one going Clockwise) to help this pressure but as of yet nothing has been decided and ALREADY the demand exceeds the capacity. By the time they start building half of the M25 will be paralysed.

Pierre 26-01-2020 19:59

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36023677)
Hodges has been extremely critical of Labour since 2010 though, as Chris says he is clearly on the 'right' of the Labour Party. So I think he has earned the right to be listened too by the right as he isn't a propagandist for the left.

---------- Post added at 19:18 ---------- Previous post was at 19:09 ----------



HS2 should just happen now. Just do it.

People are deluded if they think it's cancellation will lead to investment in the existing railway infrastructure in the North instead. The same thing will happen again. There will be years, far beyond this Government's parliamentary term, of public consultation and government case studies before anything is proposed. Then, between 2025 and 2030, when a proposal is put forward it'll be beset by court cases and disagreement with politicians of every stripe opposing it in favour of something else before a final plan is somehow agreed in 2035 and we're all back here in 2040 wondering if it's about to be cancelled. :rolleyes:

This country is absolutely pathetic when it comes to infrastructure projects. It's a wonder we have a Eurostar or M25. How we built the London Underground will become a mystery to future generations of Brits in the same way the Pyramids are now.

It may not be the most optimal use of money but HS2 is a unicorn in that it's a project that is actually being built and has passed all the bureaucracy and nonsense that we throw at any attempt to do anything.

A case in point is a new bridge at the Dartford Crossing on the M25. The tunnel itself, running from South to North, is already a nightmare. For over 10 years they've been having public discussions on how/when/where to build another bridge (to match the one going Clockwise) to help this pressure but as of yet nothing has been decided and ALREADY the demand exceeds the capacity. By the time they start building half of the M25 will be paralysed.

One of the problems in delivering a project like this, why it’s so expensive, and why the likes of China to it faster and better is.......

We adhere to all the environmental bollocks. For a project like this you will have Natural England, the JNCC and several other NGOs throwing as many hurdles in front of it as possible. Endless environmental impact assessments, mitigations, NIMBYs, consultations etc yadda yadda yadda.

You may think it right or wrong, but I guarantee you China just build it. I doubt the French are even as anal.

Environmental impact? Of course there will be but it’s a 50m strip at most, and although during construction it will be more, that is temporary and will recover.

I think there needs to be some legislation to help support major national infrastructure projects.

Mr K 26-01-2020 20:48

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 36023681)
One of the problems in delivering a project like this, why it’s so expensive, and why the likes of China to it faster and better is.......

We adhere to all the environmental bollocks. For a project like this you will have Natural England, the JNCC and several other NGOs throwing as many hurdles in front of it as possible. Endless environmental impact assessments, mitigations, NIMBYs, consultations etc yadda yadda yadda.

You may think it right or wrong, but I guarantee you China just build it. I doubt the French are even as anal.

Environmental impact? Of course there will be but it’s a 50m strip at most, and although during construction it will be more, that is temporary and will recover.

I think there needs to be some legislation to help support major national infrastructure projects.

China's got a bit more land to play with. If we're not careful our green and pleasant land will end up a grey concreted metropolis.

The cost of HS2 is obscene and will only benefit a few. All to save a few minutes on a train ride. Social care would be a much better beneficiary of that money for our ageing population.

Chris 26-01-2020 20:52

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36023683)
China's got a bit more land to play with. If we're not careful our green and pleasant land will end up a grey concreted metropolis.

The cost of HS2 is obscene and will only benefit a few. All to save a few minutes on a train ride. Social care would be a much better way to direct that money on our ageing population.

HS2 will benefit every commuter in central England and eventually the north, by taking inter city traffic off the legacy network and thereby creating capacity. It’s not just about faster inter city services, except in the minds of the short-sighted, self loathing types who feel physical pain whenever they are forced to think about this country achieving something.

Mr K 26-01-2020 20:59

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 36023684)
HS2 will benefit every commuter in central England and eventually the north, by taking inter city traffic off the legacy network and thereby creating capacity. It’s not just about faster inter city services, except in the minds of the short-sighted, self loathing types who feel physical pain whenever they are forced to think about this country achieving something.

'eventually the north ', mmm, sounds like a Tory policy ! . Failing branch lines in the North are more in need of any investment going than this vanity project.

1andrew1 26-01-2020 21:32

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36023683)
China's got a bit more land to play with. If we're not careful our green and pleasant land will end up a grey concreted metropolis.

The cost of HS2 is obscene and will only benefit a few. All to save a few minutes on a train ride. Social care would be a much better beneficiary of that money for our ageing population.

HS2 is not a good brand name as it's about capacity not speed.

Pierre 26-01-2020 21:45

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36023683)
China's got a bit more land to play with. If we're not careful our green and pleasant land will end up a grey concreted metropolis.

The cost of HS2 is obscene and will only benefit a few. All to save a few minutes on a train ride. Social care would be a much better beneficiary of that money for our ageing population.

Approximately 10% of the U.K. is developed.

https://fullfact.org/economy/has-92-...ot-been-built/

A train line is not going destroy the greenery of the nation.

China can build 2,300 km of high speed rail per year.

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/pr...ther-countries

Because they are an Autocratic regime, if they want it done, it gets done. It’s for the prosperity of the country and they do it.

We, thank god, are not an autocratic regime, but I do think for projects of national importance we should be able to do what’s required instead of trying to appease everyone.

Damien 26-01-2020 21:57

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Also HS2 isn't the end of it. Once completed we could build connections to those hubs, either high speed or normal speed, to further connect the country. Also people downplay the speed but it is important. Even 30 mins from Birmingham means a day trip to London takes an hour less. From Manchester it's a two hours less. If it goes up to Scotland then the benefits are greater still. It makes trips around the U.K in a day a lot more feasible.

Chris 26-01-2020 22:39

Re: Election 2019 Exit Poll
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr K (Post 36023686)
'eventually the north ', mmm, sounds like a Tory policy ! . Failing branch lines in the North are more in need of any investment going than this vanity project.

Actually the origin of the plan to build out from London to Birmingham and then the north is in 2009, and the last full year of Labour government. Given the treasury’s standing orders since forever, it’s not surprising that the business case for starting with the London-Birmingham link was easier to make. A Tory government has just changed those standing orders. That’s one of the reasons I think the project is going to continue.

---------- Post added at 22:09 ---------- Previous post was at 22:01 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 36023699)
Also HS2 isn't the end of it. Once completed we could build connections to those hubs, either high speed or normal speed, to further connect the country. Also people downplay the speed but it is important. Even 30 mins from Birmingham means a day trip to London takes an hour less. From Manchester it's a two hours less. If it goes up to Scotland then the benefits are greater still. It makes trips around the U.K in a day a lot more feasible.

Indeed.

We need to move stuff out of London. State owned or controlled concerns like government departments and the BBC can simply be ordered to do so. Private businesses need incentives. With Birmingham and Manchester reliably less than a day trip away, businesses can have the confidence that moving operations out of the capital doesn’t disconnect them from it.

Getting the Edinburgh/Glasgow-London journey time comfortably below 4 hours from centre to centre, with no security checks, queueing and checking in, makes the journey, even on mostly non-high speed track, competitive with flying, especially as you can get productive work done on the train.

---------- Post added at 22:39 ---------- Previous post was at 22:09 ----------

I don’t think we need a general purpose political thread now the election is done with. Feel free to start a new thread to discuss any specific issues.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:50.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum