Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Virgin Media TV Service (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33683352)

Alan Fry 05-12-2011 16:21

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by telegramsam (Post 35340819)
It will but only once sky realise virgin aren`t going to pay over the odds for it. And as I`ve previously said you aren`t missing much at all.

I thinking you are not a big fan of HBO programmes

HD Boy 05-12-2011 16:23

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Fry (Post 35340866)
I thinking you are not a big fan of HBO programmes

Sky Atlantic is not all HBO programmes.

Quote:

While 40% of the channel’s content will be HBO material, Sky is also in negotiations to acquire UK and US indie features.
http://www.screendaily.com/news/uk-i...021990.article

denphone 05-12-2011 16:51

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Fry (Post 35340746)
Sky Atlantic should come to Virgin TV

It will in due time.

Hugh 05-12-2011 23:48

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HD Boy (Post 35340871)
Sky Atlantic is not all HBO programmes.

http://www.screendaily.com/news/uk-i...021990.article

"in negotiation" - do they have any yet?

MovedGoalPosts 06-12-2011 00:07

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Fry (Post 35340866)
I thinking you are not a big fan of HBO programmes

HBO don't necessarily make good programmes. For example Band of Brothers = awesome. Pacific = mediocre. At least in my book.

The real issue here is that for those of us on VM, freeview, freesat, we don't know what we are missing, if anything, as these shows haven't made it to more accessible channels and unless you subscrfibe to more unauthorised aquisition methods you have no idea if it is or is not of quality.

Thus of the voters who so far say it is overhyped or not, I assume you are mostly satellite TV subscribers rather than other digital TV users.

muppetman11 06-12-2011 00:30

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob (Post 35341209)
Thus of the voters who so far say it is overhyped or not, I assume you are mostly satellite TV subscribers rather than other digital TV users.

If only , reading the comments I'm pretty sure the majority are VM subscribers but I'm sure you know that :D

kop32 06-12-2011 07:41

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
I have had Sky Atlantic HD since it launched on Sky and would like to add a couple of points.

1. Yes there are some very good programs on it (which is inevitable as it is Sky's flagship channel),but as with every channel the content is not to everyones taste.

2. Is it over hyped?,in my opinion it is not,but,you only have to read on here the reaction not having the channel on Virgin Media has on people.

I personally hope Virgin Media do get the channel,fix the red button issues etc,etc and then I can wave goodbye to Sky for good and have all my services with VM.

andy_m 06-12-2011 08:41

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob (Post 35341209)
HBO don't necessarily make good programmes. For example Band of Brothers = awesome. Pacific = mediocre. At least in my book.

The real issue here is that for those of us on VM, freeview, freesat, we don't know what we are missing, if anything, as these shows haven't made it to more accessible channels and unless you subscrfibe to more unauthorised aquisition methods you have no idea if it is or is not of quality.

Thus of the voters who so far say it is overhyped or not, I assume you are mostly satellite TV subscribers rather than other digital TV users.

In the unlikely event you don't have the box set, Band of Brothers is currently being re shown on TCM.

Alan Fry 06-12-2011 10:11

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Sky Atlantic also show Mad Men, one of the best tv shows in the world in my opinion!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mad_Men...onal_broadcast

denphone 06-12-2011 10:29

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by andy_m (Post 35341272)
In the unlikely event you don't have the box set, Band of Brothers is currently being re shown on TCM.

And excellent it is too.

LexDiamond 06-12-2011 11:05

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kop32 (Post 35341258)
I have had Sky Atlantic HD since it launched on Sky and would like to add a couple of points.

1. Yes there are some very good programs on it (which is inevitable as it is Sky's flagship channel),but as with every channel the content is not to everyones taste.

2. Is it over hyped?,in my opinion it is not,but,you only have to read on here the reaction not having the channel on Virgin Media has on people.

I personally hope Virgin Media do get the channel,fix the red button issues etc,etc and then I can wave goodbye to Sky for good and have all my services with VM.

I agree. It is about as good (or as bad depending on how you look at it) as a basic pay tv channel should be.

Along with channels such as Sky1, FX, Sky Living and a few others this channel probably forms the upper end of the basic pay tv channels. The majority of the good shows on first run only exist on a hand full of channels and Atlantic is one of them.

I can see why Sky put out this channel but it is no better than any of the most popular channels in its class of channels so I can't see why Sky don't just take VM's money.

muppetman11 06-12-2011 11:49

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LexDiamond (Post 35341307)
I agree. It is about as good (or as bad depending on how you look at it) as a basic pay tv channel should be.

Along with channels such as Sky1, FX, Sky Living and a few others this channel probably forms the upper end of the basic pay tv channels. The majority of the good shows on first run only exist on a hand full of channels and Atlantic is one of them.

I can see why Sky put out this channel but it is no better than any of the most popular channels in its class of channels so I can't see why Sky don't just take VM's money.

To be fair we don't know what VM are offering , maybe Sky feel there's more benefit as an exclusive over what's being offered.

LexDiamond 06-12-2011 12:40

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by muppetman11 (Post 35341329)
To be fair we don't know what VM are offering , maybe Sky feel there's more benefit as an exclusive over what's being offered.

Fair point

telegramsam 06-12-2011 14:44

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Fry (Post 35340866)
I thinking you are not a big fan of HBO programmes

I`m sure I watch some HBO programs on FX just none on sky Atlantic

Chad 06-12-2011 18:35

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by telegramsam (Post 35341424)
I`m sure I watch some HBO programs on FX just none on sky Atlantic

Not all of HBO's current programming is on SKY Atlantic.

True Blood - FX & Channel 4
The Ricky Gervais Show - Channel 4
Hung - More4
24/7 - 5* & BoxNation
Eastbound & Down - FX

Hugh 06-12-2011 18:40

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
So, in summary to the OP's question - some think it is, some don't, and some don't care......:D

muppetman11 06-12-2011 18:51

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chad (Post 35341576)
Not all of HBO's current programming is on SKY Atlantic.

True Blood - FX & Channel 4
The Ricky Gervais Show - Channel 4
Hung - More4
24/7 - 5* & BoxNation
Eastbound & Down - FX

Hung on More4 is Series 2 , Sky Atlantic are showing the new Series
http://skyatlantic.sky.com/hung/well...ic-search-sslc

Can't say I've watched it though.

Tezcatlipoca 06-12-2011 20:54

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chad (Post 35341576)
Not all of HBO's current programming is on SKY Atlantic.

True Blood - FX & Channel 4
The Ricky Gervais Show - Channel 4
Hung - More4
24/7 - 5* & BoxNation
Eastbound & Down - FX

Shows with existing deals, such as True Blood, were excluded from the Sky/HBO deal. I believe that FX actually has the lifetime pay-TV rights to True Blood...

... which is a shame, really, given how far behind the US the FX broadcasts are. At least if it was on Atlantic, people (well, those with Sky ;) ) wouldn't have to wait ages to see it.

RamJet 11-12-2011 10:45

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LexDiamond (Post 35341307)
I can see why Sky put out this channel but it is no better than any of the most popular channels in its class of channels so I can't see why Sky don't just take VM's money.

I agree - with the economic times we are living through - surely Sky and VM have a vested interest in keeping the overall number of Subscriptions ( for Sky+VM) up as high as they can ( overall advertsing )

they need to co-operate very closely

I read somewhere that the number of subscriptions in the USA for linear TV ( ie Sky / VM channels ) is falling rapidly

a United Front is needed from SKY/VM ( ie put Sky Atlantic on VM etc etc ) or it could go the same way here

Jameseh 11-12-2011 12:37

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RamJet (Post 35343754)
I read somewhere that the number of subscriptions in the USA for linear TV ( ie Sky / VM channels ) is falling rapidly

Yes because they have Hulu (Plus) and Netflix which is essentially premium catchup and older shows. You can access pretty much any episode of any show and a boatload of films for something like $20 a month.

But the UK have a different TV model than the US and quite a lot of Sky and VM customers are watching the football so they can't be compared IMO.

muppetman11 11-12-2011 13:00

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RamJet (Post 35343754)
I agree - with the economic times we are living through - surely Sky and VM have a vested interest in keeping the overall number of Subscriptions ( for Sky+VM) up as high as they can ( overall advertsing )

they need to co-operate very closely

I read somewhere that the number of subscriptions in the USA for linear TV ( ie Sky / VM channels ) is falling rapidly

a United Front is needed from SKY/VM ( ie put Sky Atlantic on VM etc etc ) or it could go the same way here

Trust me I won't be ditching linear TV completely in favour of streaming , not until they can offer me a seamless operation with at least 1080i picture.

denphone 11-12-2011 13:04

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by muppetman11 (Post 35343809)
Trust me I won't be ditching linear TV completely in favour of streaming , not until they can offer me a seamless operation with at least 1080i picture.

l won't be ditching linear TV fullstop but might dabble in streaming at some time in the future if it is of good enough quality.

RamJet 11-12-2011 21:52

Re: Is Sky Atlantic overhyped ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jameseh (Post 35343801)
Yes because they have Hulu (Plus) and Netflix which is essentially premium catchup and older shows. You can access pretty much any episode of any show and a boatload of films for something like $20 a month.

But the UK have a different TV model than the US and quite a lot of Sky and VM customers are watching the football so they can't be compared IMO.

wellI for one would be very happy with the HuLu/Netfix TV model - I only watch episodes of a handfull of shows and would really appreciate getting episodes whenever I want ( & I hardly ever watch yawn yawn football)

Sky Anytime on VM and esp the Cricket On_Demand episodes seem to be going in that direction - How long will it take to move to the US model ?

I can't wait - no more of those yuk yuk Shopping channels etc


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 17:52.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum