Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Lifestyle (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   Out of Control Children (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33663730)

martyh 07-04-2010 23:45

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34996823)
Because we don't know if the person being accused of bad parenting was actually a parent. All we know to some degree of certainty was she "looked like a chav".

in the context of the original post chris wasn't discussing if the woman was the mother just the bad language used by the child and the fact that the woman who looked like a chav didn't seem to care

Welshchris 07-04-2010 23:46

Re: Out of Control Children
 
defirish and thats what some people would have seen if it was posted by anyone else except me.

martyh 07-04-2010 23:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defirish (Post 34996831)
I think taken from Welshchris post is that there are unruly kids today not being taken to task for there behaivour and left go the behaviour gets out of hand and not checked and the child constantly then is left away with bad behaviour and left run riot and then as the child gets older the child has no respect for no one and then thats how they get into trouble. Thats what I took from what he was trying to say and it does happen

at last some one with a bit of sense :clap::clap::clap:

Jimmy-J 07-04-2010 23:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34996797)
If you genuinely do have a disability, you need to stop using it as an excuse. If you have the wit and intelligence to switch your PC on and push your mouse, then you have the wit and intelligence to type 'you' instead of 'u', which in the context of your slagging off someone for being a 'chav' is simply lazy and ignorant. IMO.

"Practice what you preach" comes to mind. Lazy or what? :D ;)

Sasha222 07-04-2010 23:50

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Well thats how I read it and its behaviour that I see time and time again on the street and also its getting a stage that even at the age of 10 there are some kids that your would be afraid to pass. I dont blame children for there behaviour I blame the parents for not keeping a check on them and teaching them basic manners. Only today when we were coming back from shopping I heard a child call out to other children who was about 8 and the language out of his mouth was disgusting and I had to look twice as he was so young to be using that language let alone know what understanding what exactly what he was saying

Maggy 07-04-2010 23:50

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996816)
why not just take the original post at face value and discuss bad parenting and unruly children which i think was the intent behind the thread instead of smacking the poster down

Why should I? I'm merely pointing out that I have been in that sort of situation and watched such a situation but I wouldn't immediately assume that she was a bad parent because of my experiences in 36 years of teaching.

One of the rules one of my lecturers taught me was NOT to go on first appearances.He explained how he got thumped by a teenager whom he had asked to read out loud in the class..who could barely read and hated being made to read out loud to the class.

Welshchris 07-04-2010 23:52

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Maggy and being a teacher one of the things u should have been taught if an unruly child was playing up and causing others problems or harm by throwing objects then they should be calmed down and diciplined not left to their own devices and grinned at.

Russ 07-04-2010 23:52

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34996832)
in the context of the original post chris wasn't discussing if the woman was the mother just the bad language used by the child and the fact that the woman who looked like a chav didn't seem to care

I think it's all about the context. Saying she "looked like a chav" automatically shows he doesn't know anything about the situation as it was based on perception. Taking it further, accusing her of bad parenting would also be pointless as again, nobody knows if she is actually a parent.

Gary L 07-04-2010 23:53

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34996828)
Yeah I did. Note my repeated use of the word 'prejudice'.

Which takes us back to post #73 the only prejudiced term used was Chav.

Russ 07-04-2010 23:55

Re: Out of Control Children
 
The opening line was...

Quote:

Isnt it a wonder that there are so many idiots on the streets now when Parents cant be bothered to correct their kids...
How do we know this woman is a parent?

Welshchris 07-04-2010 23:56

Re: Out of Control Children
 
how do we know she wasnt? works both ways Russ

Sasha222 07-04-2010 23:56

Re: Out of Control Children
 
While I think it must have been very embarassing for the teenager not to be able to read and was embarrased when asked to do so he could have done it better than talking with his fists. When I was in school I hated maths as im dyslix with maths and the teacher always asked me to go to the board to do something because she knew I would get it wrong. As much as it was embarrassing for me not once did I think of using my fists at my frustration of the injustice of what she was doing

Maggy 07-04-2010 23:56

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996840)
Maggy and being a teacher one of the things u should have been taught if an unruly child was playing up and causing others problems or harm by throwing objects then they should be calmed down and diciplined not left to their own devices and grinned at.

But you only have a snapshot of the situation..You have no idea how many times that parent,carer has tried to shush the child that day before you came across them..

Anyway wait until you are a parent yourself..then see how you like being judged by others who don't know you.;)

Chris 07-04-2010 23:56

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996809)
please keep on being discriminating because im taking this all down :)

Take down as much as you like, Chris. However, I do believe that those in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

You have absolutely no idea what this woman's background and circumstances are, yet you jump on her from behind the comfortable anonymity of your keyboard. Then, when I have a go at you for it, you are so, so quick to plead mitigating circumstances for yourself and attempt to pour shame on me for not making allowances for you.

Your behaviour in this thread has been downright hypocritical.

Maggy 07-04-2010 23:58

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defirish (Post 34996845)
While I think it must have been very embarassing for the teenager not to be able to read and was embarrased when asked to do so he could have done it better than talking with his fists. When I was in school I hated maths as im dyslix with maths and the teacher always asked me to go to the board to do something because she knew I would get it wrong. As much as it was embarrassing for me not once did I think of using my fists at my frustration of the injustice of what she was doing

Well that's you..but not everyone is a saint..;)

Russ 07-04-2010 23:59

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34996848)
You have absolutely no idea what this woman's background and circumstances are, yet you jump on her from behind the comfortable anonymity of your keyboard. Then, when I have a go at you for it, you are so, so quick to plead mitigating circumstances for yourself and attempt to pour shame on me for not making allowances for you.

:clap:

Gary L 07-04-2010 23:59

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34996843)
The opening line was...



How do we know this woman is a parent?

We used that later. we originally argued about the prejudiced term of Chav.

You quoted another line other than the opening one.

Quote:

I was in the post office earlier on an there was a large line of people and a woman id say in her mid 20s joined the queue looked a chav to be honest and she had a young girl in the pram.

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:00

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34996848)
Take down as much as you like, Chris. However, I do believe that those in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

You have absolutely no idea what this woman's background and circumstances are, yet you jump on her from behind the comfortable anonymity of your keyboard. Then, when I have a go at you for it, you are so, so quick to plead mitigating circumstances for yourself and attempt to pour shame on me for not making allowances for you.

Your behaviour in this thread has been downright hypocritical.

"yet you jump on her from behind the comfortable anonymity of your keyboard"

u do realise that could be taken as a threat?

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:04

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34996849)
Well that's you..but not everyone is a saint..;)

Im no saint Maggy. I just dont believe using my fists is the right answer thats all

---------- Post added at 23:04 ---------- Previous post was at 23:00 ----------

I dont see what all the fighting is all about. A thread was made. Not everybody liked what they saw and read and took from it what they wanted. We are all adults and should act like adults. We all say things that other people dont like and if we dont like it then we just move on and not reply to the thread. Simple

Russ 08-04-2010 00:04

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996851)
We used that later. we originally argued about the prejudiced term of Chav.

No. You tried arguing with me. I made the same point all along.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris
u do realise that could be taken as a threat?

Only by people who misunderstood the words used?

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:05

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defirish (Post 34996854)
Im no saint Maggy. I just dont believe using my fists is the right answer thats all

Well some do..and it's easy to point the finger at them without knowing just what all their problems are..

Anyway what I was trying to point out was that sometimes one needs to go deeper into why some people behave badly rather than decide that everything is just black and white and not actually differing tones and hues of white and black.Something that too many on CF tend to do about many issues,sometimes with barely any actual facts.

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:05

Re: Out of Control Children
 
im fedup of arguing as ive stated before if i make a blog saying 2+2=4 then i would still get attacked by certain parties and its sad and a lot of members on here have noticed this pattern.

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:07

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defirish (Post 34996854)
Im no saint Maggy. I just dont believe using my fists is the right answer thats all

---------- Post added at 23:04 ---------- Previous post was at 23:00 ----------

I dont see what all the fighting is all about. A thread was made. Not everybody liked what they saw and read and took from it what they wanted. We are all adults and should act like adults. We all say things that other people dont like and if we dont like it then we just move on and not reply to the thread. Simple

Again why should we..if one feels strongly about something then one should stand one's ground.;)

Gary L 08-04-2010 00:07

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34996857)
No. You tried arguing with me. I made the same point all along.

Ok Russ.

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:09

Re: Out of Control Children
 
People instead of taking it personally should just take it for what it is and if they dont like it just ignore it. I know what excatly what he was trying to say. Maybe he didn't say it the way people would have liked but nobody is perfect.

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:09

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996859)
im fedup of arguing as ive stated before if i make a blog saying 2+2=4 then i would still get attacked by certain parties and its sad and a lot of members on here have noticed this pattern.

With all due respect unless one is prepared to defend one's point of view then possibly one shouldn't post it...;)

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:11

Re: Out of Control Children
 
whats the point of defending oneself? we are just going to go around with pure speculation of what might be and have beens when people didnt see what happened and how people reacted. We could be here for months.

And i still stand by if this was posted by any other user then this would never have happened.

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:11

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Maybe he didn't expect the reaction he was going to get and just posted it not thinking there would be a big argument. We all do things without thinking

Xaccers 08-04-2010 00:13

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Many moons ago I was talking to a WPC who was complaining that she was called a "see you next tuesday" by a 5 year old girl in front of her mother.
When she asked the mother if she was going to just stand there and let her daughter say such things, the reply was "well you lot arrested her brother so what do you expect?"
Charming.
The chavs (oh and before anyone objects, they were definitely chavs) over the road from me had a 3 year old son who could barely talk, was still in nappies, but could swear like a trooper, encouraged by his mother, his older siblings and their friends.

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:13

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Defirish i could post a blog on here about how bad the things Hiter did in WWII and be attacked and people would find a way of saying he did what he did because of whatever.

Its just how it is on here for me.

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:16

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34996858)
Well some do..and it's easy to point the finger at them without knowing just what all their problems are..

Anyway what I was trying to point out was that sometimes one needs to go deeper into why some people behave badly rather than decide that everything is just black and white and not actually differing tones and hues of white and black.Something that too many on CF tend to do about many issues,sometimes with barely any actual facts.

Ok let me tell you my life. I was taken from my parents when I was two and put into a home. The teacher knew all this and done everthing to embarras me no matter what and she kept looking for a reaction and the more she didn't get a reaction the more she pushed. I was a child and she was the adult and yet she was the one who was doing the bullying but yet I would not rist to the bait. I have had a hell of a lot of probs in my life and more than you would ever imagine but I never once made what happened to me as an excuse to do harm onto others or disrespect other people or there property or use bad language.

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:17

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996867)
whats the point of defending oneself? we are just going to go around with pure speculation of what might be and have beens when people didnt see what happened and how people reacted. We could be here for months.

And i still stand by if this was posted by any other user then this would never have happened.

You can be assured by me that is not the case as far as I'm concerned.I've given my opinion fairly and squarely about the issue.You have responded and we have debated the issue.

The point about forums is that one can't just say anything one likes without expecting someone to challenge you about it..Did you expect us all to just wholesale agree with you? That's not how conversations go with my acquaintances and family.

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:20

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defirish (Post 34996871)
Ok let me tell you my life. I was taken from my parents when I was two and put into a home. The teacher knew all this and done everthing to embarras me no matter what and she kept looking for a reaction and the more she didn't get a reaction the more she pushed. I was a child and she was the adult and yet she was the one who was doing the bullying but yet I would not rist to the bait. I have had a hell of a lot of probs in my life and more than you would ever imagine but I never once made what happened to me as an excuse to do harm onto others or disrespect other people or there property or use bad language.

we had a deputy head teacher like that in our secondary school he made a comment infront of a class about a boy who was taken into care cos his dad was beating him and the deputy head teacher said "He didnt want you"... The same teacher while an investigation was happening made a comment about me infront of my cousons class saying "He should be thrown out of school because he has bad skin" cos i have psoriasis. My brother went down the school and told the headmaster if something wasnt done about it he would do something himself and the teacher was suspended and later sacked.

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:20

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by defirish (Post 34996871)
Ok let me tell you my life. I was taken from my parents when I was two and put into a home. The teacher knew all this and done everthing to embarras me no matter what and she kept looking for a reaction and the more she didn't get a reaction the more she pushed. I was a child and she was the adult and yet she was the one who was doing the bullying but yet I would not rist to the bait. I have had a hell of a lot of probs in my life and more than you would ever imagine but I never once made what happened to me as an excuse to do harm onto others or disrespect other people or there property or use bad language.

Then well done to you for being an adult in your responses .May I point out that you of all people should appreciate that no one should judge others on appearances though because we don't always know ALL of the situation..

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:21

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34996872)
You can be assured by me that is not the case as far as I'm concerned.I've given my opinion fairly and squarely about the issue.You have responded and we have debated the issue.

The point about forums is that one can't just say anything one likes without expecting someone to challenge you about it..Did you expect us all to just wholesale agree with you? That's not how conversations go with my acquaintances and family.

have u noticed tho that on the whole its only the mods that really disagreed with me?

Funny that ;)

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:22

Re: Out of Control Children
 
No I dont expect anyone to agree with me. Im just telling you what it was like for me and how I handled things. I had no parents to guide me and show me right from wrong but I instilled that in myself. I dont go around thinking that I am better than anyone else or that I am perfect. I was just saying that today its all to easy now for children to use an excuse for bad behaviour

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:25

Re: Out of Control Children
 
defrish, ive been the victim of out of control kids since the age of 7, Bullied for having Psoriasis, Attacked at the age of 11 for having Psoriasis which left me with spinal problems which is debilitating, and what did the teacher and parents do NOTHING!

When i was attacked and i went back to school i hit one of the attackers so hard i put him through a plaster board wall and he ended up in hospital with stitches and then the parents wanted to sue my parents along with the school until my parents stated they would make the ongoing problems public.

Only then did the school try and do anything which to be honest was very little.

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:25

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I dont like to see people fighting and I do love this forum but it seems like this thread is getting out of control and getting very heated which I hate to see and its a pity. Cant people agree to disagree

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:26

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996877)
have u noticed tho that on the whole its only the mods that really disagreed with me?

Funny that ;)

Then I suggest you use the usual avenues of complaint if you think I have been particularly harsh in my behaviour towards you.

I've a completely clear conscience in this thread about my treatment of you myself.;)

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:27

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996881)
defrish, ive been the victim of out of control kids since the age of 7, Bullied for having Psoriasis, Attacked at the age of 11 for having Psoriasis which left me with spinal problems which is debilitating, and what did the teacher and parents do NOTHING!

When i was attacked and i went back to school i hit one of the attackers so hard i put him through a plaster board wall and he ended up in hospital with stitches and then the parents wanted to sue my parents along with the school until my parents stated they would make the ongoing problems public.

Only then did the school try and do anything which to be honest was very little.

Im really sorry to hear that you have a lot of health issues and so sorry to hear that you were the victim of bulling. I do hope things will get better for you. I do wish you all the best :D

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:29

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34996885)
Then I suggest you use the usual avenues of complaint if you think I have been particularly harsh in my behaviour towards you.

I've a completely clear conscience in this thread about my treatment of you myself.;)

rubbish

speedfreak 08-04-2010 00:32

Re: Out of Control Children
 
wow. I was going to post about how I disagree with welshchris as I have a 2yr old who is really well behaved but if he went like that in a queue of people Id probably be embarassed and wouldnt know what to do tbh but I read on and this is the second thread (as a newcomer on here) where I genuinely feel he gets "picked on" and singled out on here by some (not all) mods. Im shocked by it all. People posting some views on here about religion,mosques,drugs etc dont get anywhere near this amount of stick.

I hope I never have to feel the wrath of the mods :( I thought they were all great before but one or two have changed that view. Russ had a point but then everyone seemed to jump in. Im really confused, have you upset the mods on here in the past chris?

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:33

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I too have had my problems.I lost one of my parents at 13 and the other when I was barely 24..I however try not to prejudge others and I won't stand by when some people do...

The trouble with the internet is that some hide behind anonymity to cast aspersions on others who can't answer for themselves.

Mostly I stay out of such issues but sometimes I just have to put their side.It's not easy being a parent.in fact it's the hardest thing I've ever had to do.. and I've not been perfect at it..so I really hate it when parents aren't given the benefit of doubt or understanding at times.

speedfreak 08-04-2010 00:35

Re: Out of Control Children
 
maggy, could one or two not have made that point without all the mods joining in? Any other thread doesnt seem to attract this much mod attention, it just makes it look like chris has a point about being bullied/singled out on here

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:35

Re: Out of Control Children
 
i can understand its not easy being a parent but one has to control the kids in their care and correct them.

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:42

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Im sorry for both of your losses Maggie. I do agree its the hardest and one of the most thankless jobs being a parent. The thing is that if you bring them up with manners and show them how to respect people and check them when they do wrong they hopefully turn out to be decent adults. But I have seen parents that go of to the pub and let the kids run riot and are on the road making peoples lives a living hell till they the parents return from the pub. I dont blame the kids but I do blame the parents.

---------- Post added at 23:42 ---------- Previous post was at 23:38 ----------

I am a parent and my kids are now growing up and have left home. When they were young I practally sat on them and they were thought to respect there elders and they were brought in at 6 in the winter and 8 in the summer so they would not be causing any trouble and I was a single parent at that and done it on my own. I never made the excuse it was to hard to keep track of them as I was on my own.

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:42

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by speedfreak (Post 34996892)
maggy, could one or two not have made that point without all the mods joining in? Any other thread doesnt seem to attract this much mod attention, it just makes it look like chris has a point about being bullied on here

Look the Mods here as human as anyone else.They also have opinions,some of them strong ones.

However there do seem to be some CF members who seem to think that they should never ever express them..

If you stick you head up over the battlements then you must expect a robust attack on any weak opinions by anyone including any Mods.Else why have forums?;)

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:44

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Yeah its truly fair isnt it they r human

and if u disagree they warn u or block ur account

Thats being fair, an adult and human :-)

Jimmy-J 08-04-2010 00:45

Re: Out of Control Children
 
But there are also very good parents that have done everything in their power to bring up their children, and still, despite this, some of them turn out bad kids.

Sasha222 08-04-2010 00:46

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Unfortunaly thats true as well. They fall into the wrong crowds and all your hard work you done is gone.

Maggy 08-04-2010 00:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996899)
Yeah its truly fair isnt it they r human

and if u disagree they warn u or block ur account

Thats being fair, an adult and human :-)

Well if you can't debate with out resorting to suggesting we are unfair for debating with you then maybe you are in the wrong site..:shrug:

Gary L 08-04-2010 00:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Product 13 (Post 34996900)
But there are also very good parents that have done everything in their power to bring up their children, and still, despite this, some of them turn out bad kids.

That's becaue they mix with Chavs kids :)

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:49

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Product 13 (Post 34996900)
But there are also very good parents that have done everything in their power to bring up their children, and still, despite this, some of them turn out bad kids.

true but what we are discussing here is the fact that person did nothing at all to show disaproval and stop the child.

---------- Post added at 00:49 ---------- Previous post was at 00:48 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34996902)
Well if you can't debate with out resorting to suggesting we are unfair for debating with you then maybe you are in the wrong site..:shrug:

or some of the people with to much power going to their head, ever thought of that?

speedfreak 08-04-2010 00:53

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34996898)
Look the Mods here as human as anyone else.They also have opinions,some of them strong ones.

However there do seem to be some CF members who seem to think that they should never ever express them..

If you stick you head up over the battlements then you must expect a robust attack on any weak opinions by anyone including any Mods.Else why have forums?;)

lol it would be boring if you werent all human, nobody wants robotic mods. Theres a few mods on here whos posts/views I enjoy reading. My point is if you look at other threads i.e ones not started by chris, you dont really see this sort of posting from the mods. Viewing it from here (I know Ive not been around long) it does seem like chris gets a very hard time on here. Even gary with his muslim/mosque views doesnt get this sort of stick (no offence gary :D )

Anyhow Ive had my say so I'll try and leave it there. Without all this I would say, my girlfriend gets all sort of looks because she looks young and doesnt drive so when shes getting the bus to go out with our 2yr old, some snotty people look down at her, you know the view people have when they think they see a jobless single mum :rolleyes: So yes, it is wrong to be judgemental.


edit: i cant keep up with this thread, 5 or more posts since i started typing :dunce:

Welshchris 08-04-2010 00:57

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Speedfreak i have no quibles about single mums they have a hard time, my problem is if u have a child in ur care wheather its urs on not its ur responsibility to look after that child and correct it if it does wrong. I know what its like for a young single mum. My mates boyfriend died 2 years ago from a heart attack, he was much older than her leaving a 4 year old son and 4 month old daughter but she never give up on correctling her kids.

Gary L 08-04-2010 00:59

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by speedfreak (Post 34996907)
lol it would be boring if you werent all human, nobody wants robotic mods. Theres a few mods on here whos posts/views I enjoy reading. My point is if you look at other threads i.e ones not started by chris, you dont really see this sort of posting from the mods. Viewing it from here (I know Ive not been around long) it does seem like chris gets a very hard time on here. Even gary with his muslim/mosque views doesnt get this sort of stick (no offence gary :D )

I have an excuse. I'm doing a book on psychology :)

Quote:

edit: i cant keep up with this thread, 5 or more posts since i started typing :dunce:
I'm sober and I get the impression some are a bit tipsy and not just plain crazy too :)

Jimmy-J 08-04-2010 01:00

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996905)
true but what we are discussing here is the fact that person did nothing at all to show disaproval and stop the child.

She might have given the kid a thrashing when she got her home, because she was too embarrassed to discipline her in the PO? Who knows?

Welshchris 08-04-2010 01:03

Re: Out of Control Children
 
but doesnt grinning at a child give the child and others around the wrong impression.

Even if she did thrash the child when she got home, grinning at her for it and then thrasing her is totalling confusing.

speedfreak 08-04-2010 01:07

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34996910)
I have an excuse. I'm doing a book on psychology :)



Thats the odd thing about forums, you could well be but then again you might not even be gary as his accounts been hacked. You could be Shirley, you could even be Bin Laden (how ironic would that be with your views lol) who knows :)

On that note Im off to bed, maybe Im one of the tipsy ones :p:



Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996912)

Even if she did thrash the child when she got home, grinning at her for it and then thrasing her is totalling confusing.

If she grinned AT the child then Id have the same view as you, if not then who knows

Sasha222 08-04-2010 01:09

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Im stone cold sober. I can vouch for that. Anyway Im of to bed as well.

Jimmy-J 08-04-2010 01:14

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996912)
but doesnt grinning at a child give the child and others around the wrong impression.

Even if she did thrash the child when she got home, grinning at her for it and then thrasing her is totalling confusing.

The only way of knowing what she was thinking would be to ask her... Humans are very complicated animals, they can do strange things when stressed or under pressure. ;)

Chris 08-04-2010 10:14

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996853)
"yet you jump on her from behind the comfortable anonymity of your keyboard"

u do realise that could be taken as a threat?

That would be funny if it wasn't so sad.

Welshchris 08-04-2010 10:24

Re: Out of Control Children
 
well u would know all about that :-)

Nugget 08-04-2010 10:55

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Let's be honest here - if the subject of the thread is that people who have responsibility for kids should actually act to control them, then it's not a bad point.

If the subject is the prejudicial views of the OP (specifically) and others (generally), then that's a different subject, even though it can impact on this thread.

If the OP believes that he's being 'picked on' by certain members due to his dyslexia, then he's wrong. There's a certain irony in being able to spell 'dyslexia' but not 'you' - just my opinion, but it does display a certain laziness in typing :shrug:

Hom3r 08-04-2010 11:11

Re: Out of Control Children
 
My nephew and niece are angels out in public, they hold door for people, when they see another kid is going mental they look at their with a look of why.

Flyboy 08-04-2010 11:37

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996667)
But that foster mother would atleast try and silence the kid and tell her what she is saying and doing is wrong.

I'm going to take a wild guess (a prejudgement, if you like), that you don't have any experirience in raising, looking after, or adminstering to the needs of, children. You haven't taken into account the age of the child any potential developmental issues the child might have or even the fact that the woman might not even have been the mother of the child in question.

As a parent of a child who has a range difficulties such as ADD, ASD, APD and other co-morbid conditions, we have given up trying to explain to others why he acts the way he does. We have decided that those who look down their noses at him as though he is some alien from another planet, are the ones with the problem why they can't accept him the way he is.

Oh, by the way, ALL children throw things from their prams. I would have thought after spending time on here would have proven that. ;)

---------- Post added at 10:37 ---------- Previous post was at 10:25 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by budwieser (Post 34996703)
I was just saying that people have the right to have a nice pleasant post office experience without having someone elses child being obnoxious and the mother not reprimanding them, thats all.:)

Whereas the title of this thread would have been:

"Chav mum screams at kids in Post Office, oh, the horror of it."

peanut 08-04-2010 11:37

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I quite like Maggy's #2 post, 'what if the child that was in a pushchair or whatever had tourettes'?

Well I never knew that a child that age would automatically know that kind of language that is associated with tourettes. Normally they need to know it's derogatory or offensive, so at that age I presume they wouldn't know. So it's quite natural to presume that the parent must be someone who doesn't mind using that kind of language in front of a child that may or may not have a problem. So I wouldn't jump to a conclusion that a child that age who swears that it is caused by tourettes.

I also have a good friend who has a kid with ADHD/Schizo, he says the occasional bad word and plays up quite a lot in public (from about the age of 5-6 or so) and from what I've seen he'll never tire of apologising if it caused offense to others.

I must admit I've come across the type of people the OP means, and it is obvious, and quite clearly so. And the way the OP has been beaten down on this thread is quite sad as most as been from the mods.

Chris 08-04-2010 11:58

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Agreed, I don't think Tourette's Syndrome is at all likely. Tourettes sufferers typically find that they know a certain comment would be entirely inappropriate, but once that comment is in their head it's almost impossible for them not to vocalise it. A small child would be unlikely to reason in this way.

The likelihood is that they are simply modelling the behaviour they experience at home, and are getting away with it due to a long-term lack of structured discipline. Whether that's the fault of the person who happened to be pushing the pram is another matter entirely.

Maggy 08-04-2010 12:08

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34997094)
Agreed, I don't think Tourette's Syndrome is at all likely. Tourettes sufferers typically find that they know a certain comment would be entirely inappropriate, but once that comment is in their head it's almost impossible for them not to vocalise it. A small child would be unlikely to reason in this way.

The likelihood is that they are simply modelling the behaviour they experience at home, and are getting away with it due to a long-term lack of structured discipline. Whether that's the fault of the person who happened to be pushing the pram is another matter entirely.

It probably isn't,I was just offering up a devil's advocate suggestion because I thought the OP was quite judgemental about the situation..Having friends with children that do have behavioural problems I know that sometimes parents cannot be buggered to keep explaining what is wrong with their child..and yes I swear too..it's better than thumping someone..;)

peanut 08-04-2010 12:19

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34997097)
It probably isn't,I was just offering up a devil's advocate suggestion because I thought the OP was quite judgemental about the situation..Having friends with children that do have behavioural problems I know that sometimes parents cannot be buggered to keep explaining what is wrong with their child..and yes I swear too..it's better than thumping someone..;)

There's a big difference from explaining and apologising. Or just have a 'think it's funny look' about themselves.

We're all judgemental in one way or another if we're the persons involved.

Maggy 08-04-2010 12:24

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 34997108)
There's a big difference from explaining and apologising. Or just have a 'think it's funny look' about themselves.

We're all judgemental in one way or another if we're the persons involved.

I do try not to be when noisy children are involved.I try not to get irritated because I know that sometimes you just can't shush a young child...

Flyboy 08-04-2010 12:28

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

I also have a good friend who has a kid with ADHD/Schizo, he says the occasional bad word and plays up quite a lot in public (from about the age of 5-6 or so) and from what I've seen he'll never tire of apologising if it caused offense to others.
Well, this remark alone destroys any credibility you may have had? I have never heard a parent express such a term in relation to their child, I am pretty sure that if your friend ever heard you describe their child iwn such derogatory terms, they wouldn't be your friend for very much longer. Secondly, for as long as I live, I don't think I will ever see a genuine diagnoses of schizophrenia or bi-polar disorder in a child of five years old.

peanut 08-04-2010 12:32

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34997112)
I do try not to be when noisy children are involved.I try not to get irritated because I know that sometimes you just can't shush a young child...

That's true, but when a child in a push chair shouts F off, and the parent (or guardian) just smiles, I would have thought he made pretty much a fair judgement on the situation at that time.

When it's just 'noisy' children, (I certainly put up a lot of those on a bus I can tell you), then the thoughts of the OP wouldn't even come to my mind, why would I think chavs let alone out of control etc, they are just being noisy and doing their job like any other noisy kids.

The difference is a scenario, I've certainly been in that kind and yeah I'd get annoyed when people can't control their 'abusive' kids, because the parents do think it's funny and they are no better than their kids.

Escapee 08-04-2010 12:36

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I started reading this thread but found it another typical example of someone making a point and the other side making every excuse to disagree.

It just takes a visit to any town centre to see chav like parents with misbehaved children, ADHD and Tourettes seem to be easy excuses for poor parenting and badly behaved children.

A good smacked bottom is what's needed.

Maggy 08-04-2010 12:40

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Escapee (Post 34997119)

A good smacked bottom is what's needed.

sometimes..yes.My children weren't usually the noisy ones except when they were really small and when they were older they did get smacked..However just because a child is noisy,disruptive and a nuisance is no reason to accuse a parent of being a bad parent.Sometimes there is more to a situation than you or I is seeing. ;)

peanut 08-04-2010 12:45

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997114)
Well, this remark alone destroys any credibility you may have had? I have never heard a parent express such a term in relation to their child, I am pretty sure that if your friend ever heard you describe their child iwn such derogatory terms, they wouldn't be your friend for very much longer. Secondly, for as long as I live, I don't think I will ever see a genuine diagnoses of schizophrenia or bi-polar disorder in a child of five years old.

He's now 10-11, but his behaviour hasn't change much in all that time, just good days and bad days with the help of his medication. It is hard to diagnose schizo at that age, to a point they just don't, it doesn't mean he did or didn't have those problems back then. ADHD was diagnosed from an earlier age, even though it's been a struggle to get that far.

Saying that he's a great kid.

I use the term Schizo because personally I don't find it derogatory, he's not my child so I don't know if it is or isn't derogatory and if it is, I know certainly he doesn't take any offense by it. So get off your high horse.

If you would like more of their story/history just let me know, I'll get more info from him.

Escapee 08-04-2010 12:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34997120)
sometimes..yes.My children weren't usually the noisy ones except when they were really small and when they were older they did get smacked..However just because a child is noisy,disruptive and a nuisance is no reason to accuse a parent of being a bad parent.Sometimes there is more to a situation than you or I is seeing. ;)

Agreed, but I have also noticed exactly what the original poster was pointing out. There seems to be a section of society who laugh and find it very amusing when their children are naughty.

I once watched such a series of events, then as a final straw after the kid had climbed on his fathers car he attempted to climb on mine. It resulted in some verbal abuse and some shaping up between his father and myself who I was ready to take action against. This example was no more than a ****/chav parent with a child who had never been taught right from wrong.

Flyboy 08-04-2010 12:49

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Escapee (Post 34997119)
I started reading this thread but found it another typical example of someone making a point and the other side making every excuse to disagree.

It just takes a visit to any town centre to see chav like parents with misbehaved children, ADHD and Tourettes seem to be easy excuses for poor parenting and badly behaved children.

A good smacked bottom is what's needed.

Aah yes, violence. The panacea of the lazy parent. How do you think this thread would have gone, if the OP had started describing a chav mother beating their child in the post office?

Chris 08-04-2010 12:51

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Oh here we go, the nanny-knows-best anti-smack mafia are in the building. :rolleyes:

Escapee 08-04-2010 12:58

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I was smacked as a child if I did not behave, it taught me that there is always someone bigger and stronger than yourself.

I believe that since smacking has almost disappeared children have grown up thinking they can get away with almost anything. Many young adults now are abusive to others because they see no consequence, if someone puts them in their place they are quick to run off to the police and complain.

If you get a smack when you misbehave at a young age, if nothing else it teaches you that other people can also hit back when you strike them. It makes you less likely to go around picking on people because you think they will not hit you back.

Mick 08-04-2010 13:07

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997129)
Aah yes, violence. The panacea of the lazy parent. How do you think this thread would have gone, if the OP had started describing a chav mother beating their child in the post office?

There you go again with that flippant attitude of yours - A good hiding never did any harm to me or my 4 other siblings - Yes, I am one of 5 kids my parents had 5 children and two of them were twins and my parents still worked!!! And if you told my mother she was a lazy parent for hitting her kids - she would have dropped kicked you where you stand.

I cannot believe the amount of crap you come out with on here lately but then again that is you all over isn't it? The great 'pretender' who thinks he knows everything and all the answers - but when it boils down to it - it appears you know sweet FA. :rolleyes:

Flyboy 08-04-2010 13:10

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Escapee (Post 34997138)
Many young adults now are abusive to others because they see no consequence, if someone puts them in their place they are quick to run off to the police and complain.

If you get a smack when you misbehave at a young age, if nothing else it teaches you that other people can also hit back when you strike them. It makes you less likely to go around picking on people because you think they will not hit you back.

I think you've got that the wrong way round, what it shows a child is that violent solves everything. A case in point, I was physically bullied by a teacher at school. He would find any excuse to give me the slipper. One day, I had had enough. I refused to submit and when he tried to grab me, I turned and kicked him between the legs and punched him in the face. Hardly holds form to your theory.

Xaccers 08-04-2010 13:36

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997145)
I think you've got that the wrong way round, what it shows a child is that violent solves everything. A case in point, I was physically bullied by a teacher at school. He would find any excuse to give me the slipper. One day, I had had enough. I refused to submit and when he tried to grab me, I turned and kicked him between the legs and punched him in the face. Hardly holds form to your theory.

Had his slipper use been restrained to only be used when justified, would you have reacted in the same way?

superbiatch 08-04-2010 13:41

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 34997081)
I also have a good friend who has a kid with ADHD/Schizo, he says the occasional bad word and plays up quite a lot in public (from about the age of 5-6 or so) and from what I've seen he'll never tire of apologising if it caused offense to others.

Oh peanut thats a hurrendous word to use :erm: I sincerely hope the parents don't use it as a way to describe him (god forbid in front of him!)

My brother has schizoprenia and he works tirelessly to rid these awful terms surrounding people with mental health conditions.

Kellargh 08-04-2010 13:41

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Me and my sisters were smacked when we were young and all of us would never dream of hurting someone now - this idea of "violence promotes voilence" is rubbish if the punishment is used correctly.

peanut 08-04-2010 13:50

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by superbiatch (Post 34997164)
Oh peanut thats a hurrendous word to use :erm: I sincerely hope the parents don't use it as a way to describe him (god forbid in front of him!)

My brother has schizoprenia and he works tirelessly to rid these awful terms surrounding people with mental health conditions.

You do learn something every day. But it's only bad when it's meant in those terms, and he knows full well I'd never insult his kids (why would I) so therefore he took that term in a different light, I on the other hand is (or was) just plain ignorant of the facts. I think he was the one that told me using that very word, maybe he is/was the same?

The amount of things you're supposed to know these days, what you can and can't say, in context or out of context is forever changing. I think I'll put it down to my old age.

Mick 08-04-2010 13:51

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kellargh (Post 34997165)
Me and my sisters were smacked when we were young and all of us would never dream of hurting someone now - this idea of "violence promotes voilence" is rubbish if the punishment is used correctly.

:clap:Absolutely spot on.

superbiatch 08-04-2010 13:57

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 34997169)
You do learn something every day. But it's only bad when it's meant in those terms, and he knows full well I'd never insult his kids (why would I) so therefore he took that term in a different light, I on the other hand is (or was) just plain ignorant of the facts. I think he was the one that told me using that very word, maybe he is/was the same?

The amount of things you're supposed to know these days, what you can and can't say, in context or out of context is forever changing. I think I'll put it down to my old age.

I think its acceptable if you're willing to move with the times ;)

I used to work in learning disabilities and regularly heard people with downs syndrome being called 'mongs', sometimes by staff and it used to break my heart.

I would never comment on your age in a derogatory manner otherwise you could have me for age discrimination ;) - and yes thats how ridiculous it has become!

Maggy 08-04-2010 14:03

Re: Out of Control Children
 
And again there is a lot of difference between smacking and beating.

Flyboy got beaten and I respect and understand his dislike for the whole process.If he had been merely smacked he might feel differently.

I got smacked by my father 5 times in all and I was never beaten by anyone.I didn't beat my children either.I merely smacked them and I'm sure they remember the occasions on which I did.They are perfectly sane and not prone to violence in any manner.They use the old verbal to good effect as does their father who I may add never had to be the chastiser in our family as he was away for the most part.

Kymmy 08-04-2010 14:05

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Society though finds it's own balance no matter what punishment people use.. I think that the kids who don't respect their parents would not respect them irrestpective of if they were spanked or not.. I don't believe thought that society should prevent an parent spanking their own child but I think in this instance I don't think it would matter and I believe it's more the attitude of the parents these days that is more to blame..

Gary L 08-04-2010 14:18

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Escapee (Post 34997138)
I believe that since smacking has almost disappeared children have grown up thinking they can get away with almost anything. Many young adults now are abusive to others because they see no consequence, if someone puts them in their place they are quick to run off to the police and complain.

If you get a smack when you misbehave at a young age, if nothing else it teaches you that other people can also hit back when you strike them. It makes you less likely to go around picking on people because you think they will not hit you back.

I strongly agree with this. children do think they can get away with anything because there's no consequences. the parents aren't a consequence. another adult is never going to be a consequence. and the Police are no consequence.
the only consequence there is is another person wiping them off the face of the earth.

Maggy 08-04-2010 14:27

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I'm reminded of a situation last year where a father smacked his son so hard he fell over.The father was reported to the police and was consequentially in trouble with the law..

Maybe the woman wanted to smack her child but was constrained against doing so because she was worried about the flack she would get for doing so...

Sometimes parents just can't win.

I remember when my eldest was about 2 and prone to tantrums.My reaction was to leave her to it and just get on with my shopping..however the rest of the inhabitants in the store thought I was a terrible parent and that I should have smacked her.The fact is smacking a child in a tantrum is pointless and you just make them worse.It's far better to ignore them as eventually they soon learn that they are achieving nothing and give up.Same with a child holding their breath..eventually they pass out and start to breath again..

So like I say it may not always be as simple as it appears at first look.

Gary L 08-04-2010 14:38

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34997198)
Maybe the woman wanted to smack her child but was constrained against doing so because she was worried about the flack she would get for doing so...


Maybe. maybe it's the first time she's ever heard the child swear too.
she was probably in shock when she heard it, and the smile was an involuntary reaction.

Maggy 08-04-2010 14:43

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34997211)
Maybe. maybe it's the first time she's ever heard the child swear too.
she was probably in shock when she heard it, and the smile was an involuntary reaction.

Agreed.

peanut 08-04-2010 14:44

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34997211)
Maybe. maybe it's the first time she's ever heard the child swear too.
she was probably in shock when she heard it, and the smile was an involuntary reaction.

Maybe the mother was a ventriloquist. :D

Gary L 08-04-2010 14:46

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34997215)
Agreed.

I wonder if she managed to make it to Elizabeth Duke in Argos afterwards, or she went straight home to get over it?

Maggy 08-04-2010 14:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34997219)
I wonder if she managed to make it to Elizabeth Duke in Argos afterwards, or she went straight home to get over it?

Who cares?

Gary L 08-04-2010 14:48

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 34997217)
Maybe the mother was a ventriloquist. :D

What, you think she was throwing her voice and it looked like it was the child saying it? maybe the child was a puppet? :D

Escapee 08-04-2010 16:00

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997145)
I think you've got that the wrong way round, what it shows a child is that violent solves everything. A case in point, I was physically bullied by a teacher at school. He would find any excuse to give me the slipper. One day, I had had enough. I refused to submit and when he tried to grab me, I turned and kicked him between the legs and punched him in the face. Hardly holds form to your theory.

I think others have covered the point sufficiently, but just to make my stance clear. I believe their is a huge difference between smacking a child as a punishment, compared to child abuse.

I never once got smacked by my father, his slightly raised voice was enough. The amount of times I received a slap from my mother can be counted on my hands, my nan also slapped me a few times but could be counted on one hand.

I do remember my nan chasing me with the boiler stick on one occasion, but to be fair I had been a right little sod that day.

Perhaps the few amounts of smacks I received is due to the fact that I was a little :angel:

My GF will smack her kids if needed, but her raised voice is enough to frighten most people. She did pick one up and hold her against the wall a few months ago, but this was due to the youngest taking something and letting the eldest have the blame and a smack.

I'm actually too soft, and in a difficult position with them not being my kids. They appreciate that when they are getting a good rollocking, I generally take the pee and add a bit of light hearted banter to deflect the telling off. Of course the blame then falls on me for making light of things. If I threaten to put the 9 year old across my knee and smack her bottom she doesn't take me seriously, but on the other hand when I have been out shopping with them on my own and they do something I'm not happy with, I only have to say stop and they stop doing whatever it is.

I must say though, that her kids are the best behaved kids I have come across because they are fully aware of right from wrong. I guess it's the way they have been brought up, respect is a huge thing in their culture.

Flyboy 08-04-2010 16:26

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34997161)
Had his slipper use been restrained to only be used when justified, would you have reacted in the same way?

This happened nearly every single day. The incident I described occured when I was nine years old andy was due to me doing something I had been instructed to do, after being slippered the day before. The consequences of this teacher's actions was that he was suspended and interviewed by the police for assault. This was at a time when corporal punishment was no longer legal in primary schools. So, in reference to your question, I do not believe it is ever justified to beat a nine year old with any implement, do you?


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:32.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum