Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General Entertainment (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=23)
-   -   War of the worlds (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=21262)

Graham 11-06-2005 02:12

Re: War of the worlds
 
If anyone's interested in the original book The War of the Worlds by H.G.Wells, I can also recommend "The Space Machine" by Christopher Priest.

I've just read this and it's pretty damn good, it effectively runs alongside The Time Machine and The War of the Worlds and is written in a proper "Wellsian" style (excpt from a couple of anachronistic goofs), but apart from those it's well worth a look.

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 07:49

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Halcyon
I cant wait to see this movie.
Should be quite good I think.

Just to clairfy I to plan to see both. But I definately plan to get hold of the pendragon version too (despite the reviews :)).
__________________

Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham
If anyone's interested in the original book The War of the Worlds by H.G.Wells, I can also recommend "The Space Machine" by Christopher Priest.

I've just read this and it's pretty damn good, it effectively runs alongside The Time Machine and The War of the Worlds and is written in a proper "Wellsian" style (excpt from a couple of anachronistic goofs), but apart from those it's well worth a look.

I will hunt it out - thanks :)

I do like War of the Worlds. Quite a bit.

allieyoung666 11-06-2005 07:57

Re: War of the worlds
 
I love the sound track, I remember when we were comming back from Leeds once down a dark country lane, no lights, it was scary as hell, infact I thought they were even here!!!!!!!!!

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 08:02

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
I love the sound track, I remember when we were comming back from Leeds once down a dark country lane, no lights, it was scary as hell, infact I thought they were even here!!!!!!!!!

Presuming you mean the Jeff Wayne musical?

It's been redone as an SACD. Now if only my dvd player could play those properly :(

http://www.play.com/play247.asp?page...=34&g=48&pa=sr

Or (with dvd - too much for me.... especially at the moment)

http://www.play.com/play247.asp?page...=34&g=48&pa=sr

allieyoung666 11-06-2005 08:11

Re: War of the worlds
 
Yeah totally amaizing and so real it had me spooked!!!

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 08:17

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
Yeah totally amaizing and so real it had me spooked!!!

It is very good. I liked the remix album too (ulla dub ulla). Although that is most definately not to everyones taste.

The original musical was the first thing Dilli heard in stereo so was even more impressive.

Mr_love_monkey 11-06-2005 08:19

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
The original musical was the first thing Dilli heard in stereo so was even more impressive.

Mr Love Monkey worries about people when they talk about themselves in the third person :)

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 08:20

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_love_monkey
Mr Love Monkey worries about people when they talk about themselves in the third person :)

It's too late to worry about me m8 - I'm beyond help. Save your worries for someone who you can still help ;):D

allieyoung666 11-06-2005 08:26

Re: War of the worlds
 
I have found the best way to listen to it is camping in the middle of a feild with no other tents about, ptich black, we did it a few years ago when we went to whitby, it totally freaked my mum out infact she would not got to sleep for the rest of the holiday!

Mr_love_monkey 11-06-2005 08:29

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
...when we went to whitby, it totally freaked my mum out infact she would not got to sleep for the rest of the holiday!

She was probably worried you might sneak off whilst she was asleep and leave her in whitby :)

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 08:32

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_love_monkey
She was probably worried you might sneak off whilst she was asleep and leave her in whitby :)

OT I know - but isn't Whitby where Dracula was supposed to have entered the country?

She could have been worried about a re-appearence;)

Mr_love_monkey 11-06-2005 08:41

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
OT I know - but isn't Whitby where Dracula was supposed to have entered the country?

Inded it was, which goes to show, that even being one of the undead, doesn't stop you from buying a rubbish holiday from a travel agent...

allieyoung666 11-06-2005 08:55

Re: War of the worlds
 
Indeedy!!!! We have a goth festival which celebrates Dracula and we even have the dracula experience, it is such a beautiful place, that is were we are currently looking for our next home. It is so beautiful around there.

Mr_love_monkey 11-06-2005 08:56

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
Indeedy!!!! We have a goth festival which celebrates Dracula and we even have the dracula experience, it is such a beautiful place, that is were we are currently looking for our next home. It is so beautiful around there.

It's important to invest and get a stake in the place...

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 08:56

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
Indeedy!!!! We have a goth festival which celebrates Dracula and we even have the dracula experience, it is such a beautiful place, that is were we are currently looking for our next home. It is so beautiful around there.

Dilli lived ('till he was 3/4ish) in Skinningrove.

allieyoung666 11-06-2005 09:39

Re: War of the worlds
 
OH NO NOT SKINNINGROVE it is really bad round there!!! Sorry dilly!

dilli-theclaw 11-06-2005 09:40

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
OH NO NOT SKINNINGROVE it is really bad round there!!! Sorry dilly!

Oddly enough I suspect it's a bit different in the 26 years since I've lived there :):D

allieyoung666 11-06-2005 09:42

Re: War of the worlds
 
Yeah it isnt very nice now, when I used to work in the community 2 of us would have to go, it got a bit dodgy about 5.5years ago. Plus it faces the CAT works now, what a nice view NOT!!!

etccarmageddon 20-06-2005 07:51

Re: War of the worlds
 
new exclusive yahoo trailer here:-

http://playlist.yahoo.com/makeplayli...tw=640&qth=400

Pierre 20-06-2005 09:55

Re: War of the worlds
 
The Pendragon version is released this week on DVD.

I, because I am intrigued, have pre-ordered a copy and I am waiting for delivery.

However, it has already been on sale in the states and apparently it is a huge turd of a movie. 3hrs long, bad acting, bad sfx and bad directing.

I can't wait :)

dilli-theclaw 20-06-2005 18:06

Re: War of the worlds
 
I got the SACD remixed Jeff Wayne one this morning :)

Halcyon 20-06-2005 20:51

Re: War of the worlds
 
It was funny seeing Tom Cruise being squirted with water at the premiere.
Fair play to the guy for being taken aback by it all. I'd be blooming annoyed if anyone did that to me.
He was with Katie Holmes and both of them looked great.

Hom3r 20-06-2005 21:01

Re: War of the worlds
 
chech this site out
http://www.war-ofthe-worlds.co.uk/filmandtv.htm

Ther is yet another WOTW film
http://www.war-ofthe-worlds.co.uk/wa...lum%202005.htm
its by a company called asylum
Looks very good

iron25 20-06-2005 22:05

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Halcyon
It was funny seeing Tom Cruise being squirted with water at the premiere.
Fair play to the guy for being taken aback by it all. I'd be blooming annoyed if anyone did that to me.
He was with Katie Holmes and both of them looked great.

I saw this on Sky News and it wasn't the slightest bit funny but surely I can't be the only one that is truly fed-up with this Cruise & Holmes saga, it is nothing but a big publicity stunt. They are playing with the press to prove how truly gullible people are. Did you see how Tom announced their 'engagement' :rolleyes: , how romantic :sick:

Does anyone truly believe that this is nothing but a publicity stunt, it also has a kind of 'I dare you' feel about it, in which they both try to outdo the other one to see what they can do to get their names & pictures in the press, it's all rather pathetic.

Even if it turns out to be true then Tom's actions over the past few weeks have been truly pathetic and extremely desperate, however, let me be the first to wish the happy couple :erm: a long and happy marriage :rolleyes:

dilli-theclaw 20-06-2005 22:21

Re: War of the worlds
 
Oh - and for all you Jeff Wayne fans.

The website is now live :)

www.thewaroftheworlds.com

edit - and for those of you who haven't heard it.... You can click on the red launch music player button near the top right.

Nemesis 22-06-2005 11:00

Re: War of the worlds
 
As promised ages ago .... Picture of the Martian in Woking

http://homepages.pavilion.net/nmarchant/woking3l.jpg

dilli-theclaw 22-06-2005 11:02

Re: War of the worlds
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Simon M
As promised ages ago .... Picture of the Martian in Woking

Now that's a nice picture :)

Don't forget the cylinder....

philip.j.fry 22-06-2005 11:12

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
Indeedy!!!! We have a goth festival which celebrates Dracula

No it doesn't! Be glad I warned you before the lynch mob got you :D

But there is a seperate vampire festival in Whitby.

Aragorn 22-06-2005 13:09

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
Oh - and for all you Jeff Wayne fans.

The website is now live :)

www.thewaroftheworlds.com

edit - and for those of you who haven't heard it.... You can click on the red launch music player button near the top right.

:tu:Excellent stuff - very tempted to buy the CD now - Forever Autumn is one of my favourite songs.

dilli-theclaw 22-06-2005 13:27

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aragorn
:tu:Excellent stuff - very tempted to buy the CD now - Forever Autumn is one of my favourite songs.

Are you on about the new version? I must be honest I'm not sure if it's worth it unless you can play SACD's....

Forever Autumn is very good. I like the one with the Parson in it.

Nemesis 22-06-2005 13:28

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
Forever Autumn is very good. I like the one with the Parson in it.

...ditto... Julie Covington

Graham 22-06-2005 16:21

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by philip.j.fry
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
Indeedy!!!! We have a goth festival which celebrates Dracula

No it doesn't! Be glad I warned you before the lynch mob got you :D

Where's a flaming torch and pitchfork when you need them...! :D

Flubflow 22-06-2005 16:46

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Halcyon
It was funny seeing Tom Cruise being squirted with water at the premiere.
Fair play to the guy for being taken aback by it all. I'd be blooming annoyed if anyone did that to me.
He was with Katie Holmes and both of them looked great.

They were only trying to wash the Hubbardarian Thetans from his brain.


http://service.spiegel.de/cache/inte...353577,00.html
www.xenu.net Andreas rules!
http://newssearch.bbc.co.uk/cgi-bin/...se+scientology

Aragorn 22-06-2005 18:57

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
Are you on about the new version? I must be honest I'm not sure if it's worth it unless you can play SACD's....

Is the new one only SACD or will it play on standard CD's? I don't have the original on CD - only vinyl (and broken deck :( ) - and Asda have the original '86 CD's and the new one at the same price! What is the difference between the versions (if you don't have a SACD compat player)?

dilli-theclaw 22-06-2005 21:09

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aragorn
Is the new one only SACD or will it play on standard CD's? I don't have the original on CD - only vinyl (and broken deck :( ) - and Asda have the original '86 CD's and the new one at the same price! What is the difference between the versions (if you don't have a SACD compat player)?

It will play on both ordinary and SACD players so don't worry about that.

The new one is remixed a bit. But it only sounds a bit different.

I'd go for the newer one I think if you've not got it anyway. And look out for the remix ulla dub ulla album.

Aragorn 26-06-2005 20:28

Re: War of the worlds
 
Got the new CD as a pressie this afternoon - brings back many memories - superb album. :) Apparently most of the shops around here are sold out!

allieyoung666 26-06-2005 20:30

Re: War of the worlds
 
i love it, we had on last night and I scared Paul

Millay 26-06-2005 21:45

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
I got the SACD remixed Jeff Wayne one this morning :)

What SA-CD player do you have, wouldnt mind getting one if they dont cost a bomb

dilli-theclaw 27-06-2005 08:04

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Millay
What SA-CD player do you have, wouldnt mind getting one if they dont cost a bomb

My sony dvd player plays sacd as well as dvd's model number to follow (when I get home from work)

It was around £400 I think.

Halcyon 30-06-2005 12:16

Re: War of the worlds
 
I'm definately looking forward to seeing it.
I just realised the other day the little kid in it is the same one who was in "Man on Fire".
Steven Speilberg's and Tom Cruises team up was briliant in Minority Report, so I'm guessing this is going to be just as good if not better.

dilli-theclaw 30-06-2005 12:17

Re: War of the worlds
 
I am going to see it on Saturday.

Hom3r 30-06-2005 17:45

Re: War of the worlds
 
I've just got back from seeing WOTW 10 out of 10, Young Dakota Fanning should get an Oscar fro her performance.

I'm not giving anything away. go and see it

dilli-theclaw 30-06-2005 20:21

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by david.ewles
I've just got back from seeing WOTW 10 out of 10, Young Dakota Fanning should get an Oscar fro her performance.

I'm not giving anything away. go and see it

I just got the soundtrack.... At least the music is good :) I'm looking forward to seeing it something chronic...

Hom3r 30-06-2005 21:30

Re: War of the worlds
 
Listen for the JAWS theme in it

Halcyon 30-06-2005 23:22

Re: War of the worlds
 
Ah thanks David.....10 out of 10 you say.... Sounds like its definately going to be a good film then.
I'm going next week. Can't wait.
I checked out the music the other day online and it is indeed, very good too.

Jarandco 01-07-2005 18:26

Re: War of the worlds
 
Amazing Film! You have to see it! I thought it was very well done, special effects were amazing, the budget on this film must have been massive!! Some tense bits, bits which make you jump and parts which are sort of scary! :D

The only problem i had with it is i would like a little bit more explanation at the end...

Other than that its great, but a 12A? id say it was more a 15.... :)

Hom3r 01-07-2005 23:12

Re: War of the worlds
 
I'm going again next week

dilli-theclaw 02-07-2005 23:00

Re: War of the worlds
 
It was ok I guess.

No where near as good as I'd hoped.

Spoiler: 
To my mind it was also severely let down by the aliens. The tripods were quite good tho. But the aliens seemed rushed and very similar to the ones from independance day. I liked the burning train. The voice over by morgan freeman was a good touch tho.

Hom3r 02-07-2005 23:11

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jarandco
Amazing Film! You have to see it! I thought it was very well done, special effects were amazing, the budget on this film must have been massive!! Some tense bits, bits which make you jump and parts which are sort of scary! :D

The only problem i had with it is i would like a little bit more explanation at the end...

Other than that its great, but a 12A? id say it was more a 15.... :)

Spoiler: 
When cruise saw the birds pecking at the aliens the sheild was down therefore vunerable to attack.

If you heard the end they were attack by bacteria which made them ill, thus causing there shield to fail.


Spoiler: 
I was pleased to hear there battle cry, and see the red weed.


Watch out for the other three films coming out soon

WOTW

Pendragon version is out on DVD in US (Amazon) no uk date as of yet
Asylum version unknown release date
Jeff Wayne Musical CGI movie due 2007ish

TheBlueRaja 03-07-2005 22:02

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
Spoiler: 
To my mind it was also severely let down by the aliens. The tripods were quite good tho. But the aliens seemed rushed and very similar to the ones from independance day. I liked the burning train. The voice over by morgan freeman was a good touch tho.

Good film really enjoyed it but ended a bit to abruptly for my liking. The voiceover was nowhere near as good as John Hurt but im not going to winge too much. A lot of 9/11 references in there with the clothes falling through the air and the dust, the documentary style way it was shot etc - not sure if that was a good or a bad thing but it did add to the drama of the film. I'd give it a 4/5 anyway.

Spoiler: 
The aliens did look like the independance day ones now you mention it - never though of that.

dilli-theclaw 04-07-2005 00:26

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
Good film really enjoyed it but ended a bit to abruptly for my liking. The voiceover was nowhere near as good as John Hurt but im not going to winge too much. A lot of 9/11 references in there with the clothes falling through the air and the dust, the documentary style way it was shot etc - not sure if that was a good or a bad thing but it did add to the drama of the film. I'd give it a 4/5 anyway.

Here's another one for you :)

Spoiler: 
Whole city affected by EMP.... NO TV, phone, cars (apart from teh one that got fixed) BUT they still find a working camcorder :)

Pierre 04-07-2005 15:45

Re: War of the worlds
 
I thought it was very good, lots of good jumpy bits,

The initial sequence with the first tripod was excellent, although I wasn't quite happy with the way the tripods got there. This was not explained enough.

Lots of good scenes from the old film updated into the new one. It did end quickly but I don't see how they could have done it differently.

On the whole very good.

I'm looking forward to the others (although I know they are much smaller budget films)

TheBlueRaja 04-07-2005 16:20

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
Here's another one for you :)

Spoiler: 
Whole city affected by EMP.... NO TV, phone, cars (apart from teh one that got fixed) BUT they still find a working camcorder :)

LOL... True! ;) Good spot.

allieyoung666 04-07-2005 16:23

Re: War of the worlds
 
I am taking Paul on Saturday!Thanks for the spoilers!

Pierre 04-07-2005 16:52

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
LOL... True! ;) Good spot.

HOW about

highlight to view:

Spoiler: 
A plane drops out of the sky, completely demolished a house, yet the car parked on the drive is untouched!!!!!!!

TheBlueRaja 04-07-2005 18:04

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre
HOW about

highlight to view:

Spoiler: 
A plane drops out of the sky, completely demolished a house, yet the car parked on the drive is untouched!!!!!!!

Agreed - i noticed that one (even thought about it before they showed it) - and.....

Spoiler: 
there was a perfect path out of the rubble that they could use to drive away on too.

Hom3r 04-07-2005 18:27

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
The voiceover was nowhere near as good as John Hurt

I don't think John Hurt did a voice over, Richard Burton did the voice over/Narrator for WOTW

Nemesis 04-07-2005 18:31

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by david.ewles
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
The voiceover was nowhere near as good as John Hurt

I don't think John Hurt did a voice over, Richard Burton did the voice over/Narrator for WOTW

He did on the Jeff Wayne LP, and it's Morgan Freeman in the Speilberg film.

bob_a_builder 04-07-2005 18:54

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

He did on the Jeff Wayne LP
You must have a differnet copy of the CD to the rest of us, but I note you from Horsell so may have inside information ;)
Is that the 1978 or the 1995 CD ?

I only recognise Burton as the journalist/narrator on my copy

Nemesis 04-07-2005 18:59

Re: War of the worlds
 
I meant Burton

TheBlueRaja 04-07-2005 19:28

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by david.ewles
I don't think John Hurt did a voice over, Richard Burton did the voice over/Narrator for WOTW

My bad... :p:

allieyoung666 04-07-2005 19:38

Re: War of the worlds
 
david Essex did the soilders voice, and sung brave new world. I think I might go and listen to it again.

dilli-theclaw 04-07-2005 20:20

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by allieyoung666
david Essex did the soilders voice, and sung brave new world. I think I might go and listen to it again.

Have you got the 2005cd?

It's still a brilliant piece of work, even after all this time.

bob_a_builder 04-07-2005 20:31

Re: War of the worlds
 
Unfortunatly, I think the only thing that lets the whole thing down for me, is david essex's voice as the soldier, something about it, very unconvincing.
Still since J.W. was his producer at the time fairly envitable he'd be on it
__________________

anyway back to the film,

Spoiler: 
Doesn't EMP destroy electronics, does a car solonoid count as electronics ?

TheBlueRaja 04-07-2005 20:43

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob_a_builder
anyway back to the film,

Doesn't EMP destroy electronics, does a car solonoid count as electronics ?

Whats your point caller - elaborate please!

bob_a_builder 04-07-2005 20:57

Re: War of the worlds
 
The point ..
Spoiler: 

Doesn't EMP destroy electronics, does a car solonoid count as electronics ?

When it all kicked off, and all the cars stopped working, Tom Cruise's mate was trying to fix his SUV, tried starter motor, still no go, ask Toms advise as he's passing, he says try the solonoid, which seems to do the trick, since he then takes the car and drives off with his kids, now your average car has one or two computer chips about its person nowadays, which are far more suseptible to EMP than some old coil of copper wire and an iron core

Yes, I know its only a film ...

dilli-theclaw 04-07-2005 21:00

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bob_a_builder
The point ..

..is that you should just add it to the increasing number of plot fudges ;):)

TheBlueRaja 04-07-2005 21:07

Re: War of the worlds
 
I would give them the benefit of the doubt with that one though - that car didnt look that new.

One more thing i just thought of regarding the car...
Spoiler: 
The radio worked too :D

dilli-theclaw 04-07-2005 21:12

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I would give them the benefit of the doubt with that one though - that car didnt look that new.

One more thing i just thought of regarding the car...
Spoiler: 
The radio worked too :D

Not to mention....

Spoiler: 
The fact that there must have been more camera systems and sattelite uplinks etc for the camera crew to have got the tape of the city's being destroyed by the tripods.


I could go on and on....

Sometimes you HAVE to fudge things a little or the film just won't work.

handyman 04-07-2005 21:23

Re: War of the worlds
 
damn its so hard not reading these before I watch it. Going to have to be tommorow.

Hom3r 04-07-2005 21:48

Re: War of the worlds
 
I believe that an EMP will only kill live electrical circuits so..

Spoiler: 
If the car stereo was turned off it would be unafected, and the bloke at the garage change the faulty parts with new boxed parts so also would be unefected


What we need is somebody who knows electrics & EMP effects

TheBlueRaja 04-07-2005 21:58

Re: War of the worlds
 
Ah ha... Found a linky...

Quote:

Effects of an EMP

Although the electric field created from an EMP lasts for only a short time, its effects can be devastating. It is predicted that a single high altitude burst 200 miles above Kansas could propagate an EMP enveloping the entire United States. Electrical systems connected to things that can conduct current like wires, antennas, and metal objects will suffer significant damage. EMP effects on electronics include interference of radio frequency links, irreparable damage to microcircuits, and even the disabling of satellites. Fortunately, electronic equipment that is turned off is less likely to be damaged.

So there you go - kudos to Spielberg for lucking out that one.

TracerTong 06-07-2005 07:00

Re: War of the worlds
 
I still have the original LP in it's sealed state since my brother bought me it for my 15th birthday in 1980!

Never got around to listening to my copy. My friend had it at the time and played it constantly!!! kinda put me off it for a long time. Hence the unbroken seal on mine.

Glad I did this now.

Mal 08-07-2005 20:46

Re: War of the worlds
 
The ending really ruined the ending for me...

Spoiler: 
One minute he was escaping from a tripod, then, totally unrelated, the aliens were dying. We're all saved!

The crop dusting/red weed, gory okay, but not really explained properly. Was that from the book?

The machines must have been buried thousands of years ago, but why bury them. Man at that time would have been very primitive at the time. I suppose, they must have seen potential in us.

Further to the above point, if correct, did the aliens not evolve/develop in that time? I mean that would be like someone around Roman times stashing a load of swords and us, now in the present, using them to invade another country.

If the aliens were here before, did they not know what would happen to them? I mean they took all that time to bury all those tripods, yet they die within 2 days of the invasion.


I was actually enjoying the film, aside from the above, but that was the last straw. :mad:

TheBlueRaja 08-07-2005 21:39

Re: War of the worlds
 
I Imagine nothing else other than the ending could have ruined the ending.

But i get your point... :erm:

:D

Mal 08-07-2005 21:43

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBlueRaja
I Imagine nothing else other than the ending could have ruined the ending.

But i get your point... :erm:

:D

Damn! I really should check my posts before I submit ;)
__________________

I nearly shouted out in the cinema "Is that effing it???" I was sooo annoyed by the ending :)

Mal 08-07-2005 23:49

Re: War of the worlds
 
...and another thing...

Spoiler: 
What was the thing with his son Robbie about? I want to look??? Aliens killing people at will and he wants to go and look??? :knock:

Also, how the hell did he manage to get to Boston alive and before his dad and sister???

Though I did like the train bit


:mad:

iron25 09-07-2005 23:23

Re: War of the worlds
 
All I can say to anyone yet to see this film is don't bother, save your money or rent the original film. I can understand why there weren't any advanced screenings to the critics because this film is truly atrocious & totally living on the hype. The film doesn't explain anything and the storyline is simply about a family moving from one place to another to escape the danger :sleep: The special effects weren't particulary special and with the poor storyline and abrupt ending it was a poor showing from Steven Spielberg. My rating is 'must do better'.

Mal 09-07-2005 23:24

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
All I can say to anyone yet to see this film is don't bother, save your money or rent the original film. I can understand why there weren't any advanced screenings to the critics because this film is truly atrocious & totally living on the hype. The film doesn't explain anything and the storyline is simply about a family moving from one place to another to escape the danger :sleep: The special effects weren't particulary special and with the poor storyline and abrupt ending it was a poor showing from Steven Spielberg. My rating is 'must do better'.

I'm not alone :)

Stephen 09-07-2005 23:26

Re: War of the worlds
 
well I thought it was great. a Very good retelling of the story.

iron25 10-07-2005 00:39

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mal
I'm not alone :)

You most definitely are not :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by DarthYoda
well I thought it was great. a Very good retelling of the story.

Unfortunately there's no 'scratching head' smiley so this one will have to do
:eh: A good retelling of the story :rofl: Are you sure you didn't fall asleep whilst watching it :D Story...what story :shrug:

I know 'liking' a film is about opinion but is it me or are recent 'blockbusters' getting to be rather boring and definitely over-rated :erm: The only big 'blockbuster' that I have enjoyed recently is Sin City, it was far from brilliant but at least it was enjoyable despite being about 25 minutes too long but other than that film I can't remember any recent films that have been any good. Batman Begins was just as bad and over-rated.

Stephen 10-07-2005 10:03

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
You most definitely are not :)



Unfortunately there's no 'scratching head' smiley so this one will have to do
:eh: A good retelling of the story :rofl: Are you sure you didn't fall asleep whilst watching it :D Story...what story :shrug:

I know 'liking' a film is about opinion but is it me or are recent 'blockbusters' getting to be rather boring and definitely over-rated :erm: The only big 'blockbuster' that I have enjoyed recently is Sin City, it was far from brilliant but at least it was enjoyable despite being about 25 minutes too long but other than that film I can't remember any recent films that have been any good. Batman Begins was just as bad and over-rated.

good retelling in terms of aliens attaking the earth and then us trying to beat them only for them to be defeated by a cold.

well Hollywood summer blockbusters recently seem to be all about the action and cast and not about the script and/or storyline.

Pierre 12-07-2005 12:43

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
All I can say to anyone yet to see this film is don't bother, save your money or rent the original film. I can understand why there weren't any advanced screenings to the critics because this film is truly atrocious & totally living on the hype. The film doesn't explain anything and the storyline is simply about a family moving from one place to another to escape the danger :sleep: The special effects weren't particulary special and with the poor storyline and abrupt ending it was a poor showing from Steven Spielberg. My rating is 'must do better'.

I thought the original was concisely, Mars send marshians and machines to earth to exterminate us and take over the planet.

Lots of running around, the horror, what shall we do, where shall we go.

Marshians are killed by earthly bacteria/viruses.

Just how exactly does the new hollywood version differ so greatly from all the other versions????

TheBlueRaja 12-07-2005 13:27

Re: War of the worlds
 
I would argue that in the original there really was a sense that - this is it - the end of the world, weve lost - never stood a chance and right at the end they all congregate in a church to sing together in what they belive would be their last words IIRC.

The new version didnt evoke that same sense of doom, but i still enjoyed it though.

Mal 12-07-2005 13:29

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre
I thought the original was concisely, Mars send marshians and machines to earth to exterminate us and take over the planet.

Strangely, they didn't mention a plane and the machines were buried in the ground, everywhere, under cities where people would notice the burial, if it was done recently. The pilots flew in later by lighting.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre
Lots of running around, the horror, what shall we do, where shall we go.

Marshians are killed by earthly bacteria/viruses.

Just how exactly does the new hollywood version differ so greatly from all the other versions????

The ending was abrupt. One minute he was running about, blowing a tripod up and then, as if by a miracle, they all die. There was no build up, they just died. It's pretty hard to explain. Maybe it's the story that it's based on, that I have a problem with, but this film just ends.

Just because it's based on the same story that a previous film was based on, doesn't mean that this version doesn't have flaws.

I have asked this in my earlier post, but can someone explain what happened to Robbie to me?

zing_deleted 12-07-2005 14:24

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
You most definitely are not :)



Unfortunately there's no 'scratching head' smiley so this one will have to do
:eh: A good retelling of the story :rofl: Are you sure you didn't fall asleep whilst watching it :D Story...what story :shrug:

I know 'liking' a film is about opinion but is it me or are recent 'blockbusters' getting to be rather boring and definitely over-rated :erm: The only big 'blockbuster' that I have enjoyed recently is Sin City, it was far from brilliant but at least it was enjoyable despite being about 25 minutes too long but other than that film I can't remember any recent films that have been any good. Batman Begins was just as bad and over-rated.

"Theres just no pleasing some people" said Brian. The peasant replies " thats just what jesus said sir" :LOL: .


I enjoyed it mindless pap but enjoyed it never the less

ntluser 12-07-2005 14:32

Re: War of the worlds
 
Though I enjoyed seeing War Of The Worlds I was disappointed that they didn't really use music to build up the atmosphere.

There was a lot of focus on the personal relationships, character development etc and maybe not enough on the action.

You could have filmed it without any humans present and the Tripods would still have died. Can't help feeling that if Arnold Schwarzenegger had been the lead there would have been a lot more resistance to the invaders and a lot more dramatic music.

iron25 12-07-2005 22:48

Re: War of the worlds
 
Have you seen the tv adverts for the film where they advertise it as 'one of the greatest sci-fi films ever made' and 'action packed' :erm: Action packed, I can't remember there being much action :shrug: I don't call a few buildings being blown up much action. Like most of these quotes they use, they obviously haven't used the entire quote so here are the quotes in full:

'If this film had a better storyline, better special effects and a better ending, it might possibly rate as one of the greatest sci-fi films ever made'.

'I was expecting it to be more action packed, instead it wasn't and I almost fell asleep watching it'.

Believe me, these are real quotes but unfortunately I threw out the magazines at the weekend and today is the day that the dustmen come. Damn :D

When I watched the film it wasn't at the cinema ;) so I saw it on the small screen so I was not seduced by the big picture & sound and perhaps that is why I felt the film was extremely poor. I say this because I remember thinking that Independence Day was really good when I saw it at the cinema but when I watched on TV I realised that it wasn't that good.

Lord Nikon 12-07-2005 23:03

Re: War of the worlds
 
the SFX weren't to blame, the fact was that they didn't bring forward enough of a story and the ending was somewhat anticlimactic.

It's like all too many computer games...... dazzle them with effects and they won't notice the lack of substance.

MovedGoalPosts 13-07-2005 01:06

Re: War of the worlds
 
I must admit to being dissapointed. Maybe I'm getting jaded and blase by all the big computerised effects. Maybe too, knowing these effects are computer generated rather than involving actors actually flinging themselves aroudn anything other than a blue scree, also takes any sense of realism out of it.

It was I suppose an alternative take on it to show less about the futile fightback against the invaders, and more the human impact. For me there seemed to be a major chunk missing between emerging from the basement (with no real explaination of what all the red stuff really was), and him suddenly being able to stroll into Boston (and why was Boston almost intact when everywhere else was decimated?).

aliferste 13-07-2005 08:32

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
........or rent the original film. .

The original film was not an accurate telling of the story iether! For a start it was american, they had the usuall male hero with his female hysterical companion........oh and was he not a scientist as well!!

dilli-theclaw 13-07-2005 08:41

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by aliferste
The original film was not an accurate telling of the story iether! For a start it was american, they had the usuall male hero with his female hysterical companion........oh and was he not a scientist as well!!

All true, in fact it's looking more and more likely that the Pendragon version will be the most accurate. Although from what I hear both the acting and special effetcs are pretty poor. I also suspect it won't get released over here, so you had better get importing if you want to see it (as I have - just waiting for it to show up).

Stephen 13-07-2005 10:03

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
All true, in fact it's looking more and more likely that the Pendragon version will be the most accurate. Although from what I hear both the acting and special effetcs are pretty poor. I also suspect it won't get released over here, so you had better get importing if you want to see it (as I have - just waiting for it to show up).

I have seen the Pendragon version and yes it appears to stick to the book but it looks even more low budget than some episodes of Doctor Who from the 70's.

I honestly was laughing at some of the acting and effects.

dilli-theclaw 13-07-2005 10:08

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DarthYoda
I have seen the Pendragon version and yes it appears to stick to the book but it looks even more low budget than some episodes of Doctor Who from the 70's.

I honestly was laughing at some of the acting and effects.

At the end of the day I can always read my copy of the book :)

My 1st edition print of the book ;):D

Of the tv/film versions - I enjoyed the '53 and Resurrection TV series the most.

aliferste 13-07-2005 20:33

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dilligaf1701
All true, in fact it's looking more and more likely that the Pendragon version will be the most accurate. Although from what I hear both the acting and special effetcs are pretty poor. I also suspect it won't get released over here, so you had better get importing if you want to see it (as I have - just waiting for it to show up).


I have the pendragon version!

It does stick to th ebook but the acting, special effects and all round general feel of the film is terrible. Honestly, I love cheesy sci fi but it really was quite poor.

Worth watching though just to see the lead actors moustache :)

zoombini 14-07-2005 01:37

Re: War of the worlds
 
I watched it tonight.

Damn the cinema does fill up on Orange Wednesdays :D

Noticed the camcorder etc straight away.
The bit in the cellar seemed true to the original, but the ending was very poor.

And where was the thunderchild ? (isn't that the battleship)

prefer the original.

zing_deleted 14-07-2005 01:51

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
<snip>
When I watched the film it wasn't at the cinema ;) so I saw it on the small screen so I was not seduced by the big picture & sound and perhaps that is why I felt the film was extremely poor..

With dolby 2 if your lucky and poor aspect video,damn them telecine would not give a thank you for one of those ;)

iron25 14-07-2005 23:11

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by zinglebarb
With dolby 2 if your lucky and poor aspect video,damn them telecine would not give a thank you for one of those ;)

I don't know what you mean by telecines ;) but from what I have heard these can be pretty good with good quality sound especially if an empty cinema is used along with professional camera and the sound input is hooked up to the projector :D

Stephen 15-07-2005 09:09

Re: War of the worlds
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iron25
I don't know what you mean by telecines ;) but from what I have heard these can be pretty good with good quality sound especially if an empty cinema is used along with professional camera and the sound input is hooked up to the projector :D

Maybe he meant a telesync? I have seen it at the cinema and also the Telecine and the quality on it is great.

Richard M 16-07-2005 19:06

Re: War of the worlds
 
Watched this movie when down in London this week - superb I thought, I might even see it again.
Those of you watching it at home in stereo and on a small screen have no idea what you're missing!


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:44.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum