Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Current Affairs (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Madeleine McCann (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33625944)

Arthurgray50@blu 14-03-2009 20:29

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Hi Foreverwar, l HAVE always accepted what people have said, especially what people think of what l say, this is all part of life, you learn by mistakes, and if l am wrong, l will say that.

All l am trying to say is, it takes a couple of seconds to take a child, by a an oppotunist, to take a child. That to me is the end of the matter.;)

TheDaddy 15-03-2009 05:48

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo (Post 34751668)
I have a few questions that I'd love to ask Gerry. One being how did an audience with the pope, no doubt paid for by the Maddie Fund, help in finding his daughter? I bet most people who paid into that fund were not happy at how it was being spent. It's not even like they were skint.

Does the Pope charge for an audience these days, you used to just phone up and he'd see you on any Wednesday he was free, it happened to some one I used to know quite well, he arranged for a chap to be presented with a medal by the old Pope.

I actually think the visit was one of their better ideas as well and not just for the spiritual benefits Chris pointed out in the other thread either

LondonRoad 18-03-2009 10:38

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34753204)
Does the Pope charge for an audience these days, you used to just phone up and he'd see you on any Wednesday he was free, it happened to some one I used to know quite well, he arranged for a chap to be presented with a medal by the old Pope.

That proves what I've thought for a while, it is easier to get an audience with the pope than it is with my dentist. Does anybody know if Benedict can handle a bit of root canal work?;)

Saaf_laandon_mo 18-03-2009 14:29

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Although the pope might or might not have charged for the visit, flights to and from Rome as well as any other related costs were certainly not met by the Vatican. The Maddie Fund was not as far as I recall a Mr & Mrs McCann Spiritual Healing or Comfort Fund. My point is that Gerry is pointing the finger at other elements for profiteering from his daughter's disappearance, when in fact he is open to the same sort of accusation from others.

TheDaddy 18-03-2009 14:43

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo (Post 34755928)
Although the pope might or might not have charged for the visit, flights to and from Rome as well as any other related costs were certainly not met by the Vatican. The Maddie Fund was not as far as I recall a Mr & Mrs McCann Spiritual Healing or Comfort Fund. My point is that Gerry is pointing the finger at other elements for profiteering from his daughter's disappearance, when in fact he is open to the same sort of accusation from others.

I thought the fund was there to raise awareness in the hope of finding her, the biggest Portuguese speaking country on the planet is Brazil with it's massive Catholic population, any better ideas of how to get the message out there?

Gary L 07-05-2009 14:41

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
New Madeleine McCann suspect

An artist's impression has been drawn of the latest suspect in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

The image shows a "very ugly" man who appeared to watch the apartment where the three-year-old's family was staying on the day before she vanished.

Investigators have received hundreds of phone calls since the McCanns appeared on the Oprah Winfrey show in the US.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8036937.stm

RizzyKing 07-05-2009 17:07

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Yes on the 2nd anniversary of her disappearence a whole new suspect turns up who if what we are told is true would be very hard to have not noticed and yet only now does he appear. I am not too sure about this or why only now he has come to anyone's attention.

STONEISLAND 07-05-2009 17:42

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 34790738)
Yes on the 2nd anniversary of her disappearence a whole new suspect turns up who if what we are told is true would be very hard to have not noticed and yet only now does he appear. I am not too sure about this or why only now he has come to anyone's attention.

Why would they lie? Yes the timing is odd, I'm sure this suspect has been one for a while they have brought it up now as it is the adversary and in the public eye again. No good bring a new suspect when the profile is low key

RizzyKing 07-05-2009 19:53

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I am not saying they are lying i think someone somewhere probably thought this was a good way to get things moving again. Given the time and media attention that was devoted to this at the time i find it almost impossible to believe such a physically obvious suspect wasn't mentioned at all given the amount of innocent people that were dragged into the accusatio ring that surrounded this. I don't know whats going on but i am struggling to believe this is only just coming out now and why no one prior has mentioned him or anyone like him at the time she went missing which would seem to be the time to mention it.

joglynne 07-05-2009 20:26

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I think I would find this sudden emergence of new suspect more believable if the artist's impression of the man didn't portray him as the archetypal baddie.

I could understand if this new suspect was the type of person who looked so average that he could have been almost invisible but the man in the sketch looks so dodgy anyone seeing him would surely have noticed him and mentioned him to the police/reporters/private investigators at the time.

Arthurgray50@blu 07-05-2009 21:09

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
See no one believes me, l have said from the beginning, about this stranger, and it hinges on this person on the disappearance of Maddie, you see IF people look into the facts of what hppened, the whole question hinges on this guy, and as the retired police officers have said, there are still some unanswered on the Island.

I said at the time, that it was known that Phedo's were in the area, there was a known sex offender killed the day after she went missing, and then it went quiet on the matter and it was all hinging on the main suspect,. Therefore the main culprit was riding off into the sunset with Maddie.

RizzyKing 08-05-2009 14:34

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
With all due respect Arthur you can say paedo's are about anytime you like in relation to anywhere in the world so that statement while accurate doesn't really prove a point beyond doubt. I will admit i might have missed it but i certainly don't remember any mention of this guy before recently and given this description of him i find it hard to believe it was completely missed wile so many others were dragged into the suspects arena.

Gary L 08-05-2009 14:46

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
It seems as it was reported before.

Quote:

The couple have carried out their own six-month trawl of the 30,000-page Portuguese police files, which were released last year when the investigation was shelved.

This uncovered the four witness statements about the prowler buried in the dossier.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...apartment.html

joglynne 08-05-2009 14:54

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Thanks Garry. It makes a bit more sense now. Maybe the distinctive features of this man will now work in Madeleine's favour. Let's hope so.

RizzyKing 08-05-2009 15:11

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Well lets hope it leads somewhere positive and not where many of us fear this is all going to end.

Arthurgray50@blu 08-05-2009 16:52

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Hi Rizzyking, Although, the stranger, who is now the prime target, doesn't have to be a phedo, It was said at the time of the kidnapping, that there area was known to the police, that they were in the area, at the time.

It appears very strange, that the police did not take up this stranger situation, as this is where it all hinges. I must confess, it saddens me, when Gerry McCann was walking down the road, to the apartment, the locals were shouting 'go home' which is sick too me, we have a child that has gone missing, HOW do we know if more children have not gone missing in the area, and no one has bothered talking about it.:)

Hugh 08-05-2009 17:35

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Arthurgray50@blu (Post 34791611)
Hi Rizzyking, Although, the stranger, who is now the prime target, doesn't have to be a phedo, It was said at the time of the kidnapping, that there area was known to the police, that they were in the area, at the time.

It appears very strange, that the police did not take up this stranger situation, as this is where it all hinges. I must confess, it saddens me, when Gerry McCann was walking down the road, to the apartment, the locals were shouting 'go home' which is sick too me, we have a child that has gone missing, HOW do we know if more children have not gone missing in the area, and no one has bothered talking about it.:)

Extremely inappropriate use of a smiley face there, Arthur (imho).

In your last statement, you are asking a non-provable question.

btw, re your post last night - the Algarve is in Portugal, which is part of the Iberian Peninsula, which is part of mainland Europe; not an island.
https://www.cableforum.co.uk/images/...2009/05/31.gif

Arthurgray50@blu 08-05-2009 20:28

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Hi Foreverwar, the smiley face, was my sign of friendship between forum members, it was not placed in an appropriate manner.

I for one, really feel for this family, their child has been snatched, and someone, somewhere must know where she is, my saying of ' there could be more children gone missing' you never know, children go missing everyday, all over the world, the Maddie affair has higlighted this, although there are organisations, that look for these poor kids or the vulnerable, adults etc, what we should have in this big TV world, is a Tv Station that should show 24 hours a day, when these people go missing, we have a series on BBC, that is for this purpose, that is long enough.

Hom3r 08-05-2009 21:05

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I would be suprised if the police didn't have a list of people's know to be capable of this and in the area.

Tuftus 08-05-2009 21:36

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Admin edit (Chris): If you want to place yourself at risk of a libel claim, please go and do it elsewhere. Comments removed.

Chris 08-05-2009 21:56

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Potentially libellous comments are NOT WELCOME at Cable Forum, as has been made abundantly clear in this thread many times. They may be your genuinely held opinion but that DOES NOT give you an absolute right to air them here.

Posters who cannot respect this simple rule will find they start getting infractions. Infractions mean points. Points means suspension. Too many points means a ban. There will be no more warnings.

Tuftus 08-05-2009 21:59

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
My apologies.

RizzyKing 09-05-2009 18:35

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Whatever anyone's views on other aspects of this affair are i hope this is a genuine new suspect and one that leads somewhere. Although i sadly don't think maddie is alive would dearly love to be proved wrong i do think closure in some form on this matter is needed for all concerned.

papa smurf 17-05-2009 10:26

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
this from todays mail

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...-accident.html

an interesting twist to the story ,i will not speculate as to its validity the mccanns are in suing mode so best to keep opinions out of this .

Hugh 17-05-2009 11:34

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 34796866)
this from todays mail

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...-accident.html

an interesting twist to the story ,i will not speculate as to its validity the mccanns are in suing mode so best to keep opinions out of this .

But to be fair, it's not for the money, it's because he is stating they were involved in some form of cover up in her death (imho).
"Mr Amaral must show he had good reason to believe his allegations were true and he made them in good faith.

Unlike in the UK, the McCanns would be eligible for only nominal compensation."

zing_deleted 17-05-2009 11:36

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
They are saying its damaged their reputation I would have though leaving 3 young children unattended and 1 going missing is more damage than what this book can cause

papa smurf 17-05-2009 11:45

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foreverwar (Post 34796897)
But to be fair, it's not for the money, it's because he is stating they were involved in some form of cover up in her death (imho).
"Mr Amaral must show he had good reason to believe his allegations were true and he made them in good faith.

Unlike in the UK, the McCanns would be eligible for only nominal compensation."

he seems to be sticking to his guns though ,- he named them as suspects and has not wavered from his belief that maddy died in the resort apartment

Russ 17-05-2009 12:37

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 34796902)
he seems to be sticking to his guns though ,- he named them as suspects and has not wavered from his belief that maddy died in the resort apartment

But given his department's "Laurel and Hardy" approach to the investigation I'd second guess the guy even if he told me it was raining and I was standing there getting wet.

RizzyKing 17-05-2009 13:44

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
While we all know the investigation was not a shining example of police work he has written this book and made his tv show quite a while after the events i would assume he has taken some if not a lot of legal advice and feels comfortable he can validate what he is claiming. He is certainly a persistent man and while it might all be a big scam to cover up any failings maybe he does have something i guess time will tell as this is definately going to a court soon.

Arthurgray50@blu 17-05-2009 23:19

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I bet anyone, that IF this does go to court - Sky will be there to film every minute, if this idiotic cop, is prepared to fight this claim against the McCanns, then my saying is - watch this space.

Neptune 13-05-2011 21:16

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Madeleine McCann inquiry timeline

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-13386785

Should the PM Have Got Involved?

Following an open letter from Madeleine McCann's mother Kate, David Cameron has agreed for the Government to help the search for Maddie, four years after her disappearance in Portugal.


Is he playing to the gallery?

http://www.lbc.co.uk/madeleine-mccan...involved-39858

martyh 13-05-2011 21:28

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neptune (Post 35235957)
Madeleine McCann inquiry timeline

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-13386785

Should the PM Have Got Involved?

Following an open letter from Madeleine McCann's mother Kate, David Cameron has agreed for the Government to help the search for Maddie, four years after her disappearance in Portugal.


Is he playing to the gallery?

http://www.lbc.co.uk/madeleine-mccan...involved-39858


No he should not ,and yes he is playing to the gallery and i think he has opened himself wide open to justified criticism .There will be countless hours lost by police officers in a open ended inquiry that could be better served elsewhere .

budwieser 13-05-2011 22:46

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 35235962)
No he should not ,and yes he is playing to the gallery and i think he has opened himself wide open to justified criticism .There will be countless hours lost by police officers in a open ended inquiry that could be better served elsewhere .

So is not finding Maddie a good enough cause for you then mate?:erm:
She went missing abroad and everyone seems too saying ` Oh Well. She`s gone so thats that then`.......:mad::td: This is a child we`re talking about here you know. FFS if it was your own child, you`d have gone over the edge by now, I would`ve.:confused:

Paul 13-05-2011 22:55

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neptune (Post 35235957)
Is he playing to the gallery?

Are you ?

martyh 13-05-2011 23:36

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by budwieser (Post 35236011)
So is not finding Maddie a good enough cause for you then mate?:erm:
She went missing abroad and everyone seems too saying ` Oh Well. She`s gone so thats that then`.......:mad::td: This is a child we`re talking about here you know. FFS if it was your own child, you`d have gone over the edge by now, I would`ve.:confused:

What about all the other missing children ? why hasn't he jumped in to save the day for those ,it wouldn't be because they haven't grab the medias attention would it ?and so he couldn't be seen to be taking control

There's a website full of missing children here all from the uk and all within the last 5 yrs

http://uk.missingkids.com/missingkid...eSearchServlet

Zing 13-05-2011 23:51

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by budwieser (Post 35236011)
So is not finding Maddie a good enough cause for you then mate?:erm:
She went missing abroad and everyone seems too saying ` Oh Well. She`s gone so thats that then`.......:mad::td: This is a child we`re talking about here you know. FFS if it was your own child, you`d have gone over the edge by now, I would`ve.:confused:

if it was my child she would never have been left on her own in the first place

mrmistoffelees 14-05-2011 00:05

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zing (Post 35236041)
if it was my child she would never have been left on her own in the first place

is the correct answer.

I wonder how the mcanns mortgage payments are going...........?

budwieser 14-05-2011 00:19

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zing (Post 35236041)
if it was my child she would never have been left on her own in the first place

Of Course mate, That goes without saying.;)

Saaf_laandon_mo 14-05-2011 01:35

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I've been reading this searliasation in the Sun. To me, when reading it, they seem to blame everyone else apart from themselves for maddie still being missing. From the police, to the hotel receptionist. They said they didnt get a baby sitter because they didnt want their kids in the company of a stranger whilst they were out eating only about 'a 45 second walk' away. What a load of crock. The people most to blame for the kid being missing is themselves, through their own selfishness of leaving 3 kids, the oldest being 4, in a room alone (not even in their own home) whilst they went out to enjoy wine and tapas with their mates.

Paul 14-05-2011 01:38

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
The "who is to blame" has already been done to death, and really is a bit irrelevant four years later, no need to go around in circles again.

Saaf_laandon_mo 14-05-2011 01:44

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul M (Post 35236103)
The "who is to blame" has already been done to death, and really is a bit irrelevant four years later, no need to go around in circles again.

I think that should apply to the McCanns too. Why do they keep blaming everyone else in their book? Thsy should expect a reaction even if it has 'been done to death'.

RizzyKing 14-05-2011 02:14

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
To answer you directly Budweiser we all feel bad that a 4 year old has gone missing and being honest by making this public they forced david cameron's hand a bit. If he turns round and says no more time or resources will be spent he would be villified by the mc'canns something they have become quite adept at doing to all but themselves.

He has to give public support but in reality what exactly would the mc'canns like us to have our intelligence services devoting time and resources on this perhaps we can have an sas unit on standby to fly in and investigate sightings i mean seriously what do they expect us to do. Also in the last few years you've had everyone from ex sas, sbs, mossad, kgb\fsb, stasi and cia looking to claim both the reward and the kudos that would go with it and what has come of all those people all their time and effort zilch nothing not a damn thing.

Like it or not we have to face the very real possibility that she is gone (putting aside my own personal beliefs which i won't repeat) and is never coming back now the choice here is for the mc'canns to move on much as anyone can and also start to take their lion share of the blame in this something they seem to fail to do.

Marty has a good point it isn't just this child or person that has gone missing why not all of them, no sorry but this issue has become so medialised (yes i know not a word but you know what i mean) that anything other then enthusiasm and pledges of support and efforts is political and almost with some people social suicide.

Gary L 14-05-2011 10:31

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Is it true that they waited till her Birthday to ask the PM for help?
why not 2 or even 6 months ago?

why wait long agonising months before you ask?

peanut 14-05-2011 10:34

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I'm trying not to read anything about the Mccanns, I don't want to spoil the movie when it comes out.

slowcoach 14-05-2011 12:58

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 35236170)
Is it true that they waited till her Birthday to ask the PM for help?
why not 2 or even 6 months ago?

why wait long agonising months before you ask?

The book wasn't ready then. ;)

Zing 15-05-2011 00:08

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35236171)
I'm trying not to read anything about the Mccanns, I don't want to spoil the movie when it comes out.

ironically there was a movie released in the US at the time ofthe abducstion that was delayed a number of months in the UK due to the abduction of MM. It was called Gone Baby Gone

budwieser 17-05-2011 00:08

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35236109)
To answer you directly Budweiser we all feel bad that a 4 year old has gone missing and being honest by making this public they forced david cameron's hand a bit. If he turns round and says no more time or resources will be spent he would be villified by the mc'canns something they have become quite adept at doing to all but themselves.

He has to give public support but in reality what exactly would the mc'canns like us to have our intelligence services devoting time and resources on this perhaps we can have an sas unit on standby to fly in and investigate sightings i mean seriously what do they expect us to do. Also in the last few years you've had everyone from ex sas, sbs, mossad, kgb\fsb, stasi and cia looking to claim both the reward and the kudos that would go with it and what has come of all those people all their time and effort zilch nothing not a damn thing.

Like it or not we have to face the very real possibility that she is gone (putting aside my own personal beliefs which i won't repeat) and is never coming back now the choice here is for the mc'canns to move on much as anyone can and also start to take their lion share of the blame in this something they seem to fail to do.

Marty has a good point it isn't just this child or person that has gone missing why not all of them, no sorry but this issue has become so medialised (yes i know not a word but you know what i mean) that anything other then enthusiasm and pledges of support and efforts is political and almost with some people social suicide.

So, Can you please PM me your personal beliefs on what happened to Madeline McCann? I`d love to hear from you.;)

RizzyKing 17-05-2011 13:46

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
They are in this thread for all to see and agree or disagree with ;).

Stuart 17-05-2011 17:33

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by budwieser (Post 35236011)
So is not finding Maddie a good enough cause for you then mate?:erm:
She went missing abroad and everyone seems too saying ` Oh Well. She`s gone so thats that then`.......:mad::td: This is a child we`re talking about here you know. FFS if it was your own child, you`d have gone over the edge by now, I would`ve.:confused:

Another way to look at it is that the Police have finite resources. If they are looking at what happened to Maddie (where any evidence they have has probably been gone over many times, so may not produce any new info) they aren't looking at and potentially solving a new kidnapping.

RizzyKing 17-05-2011 22:00

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
This country is in a mess financially police forces are seeing resources cut and the mc'canns want an already scarce resource spent on something that by any definition is a cold case. What happened to all the money they got and the private people they hired if they didn't get anywhere why should the met suddenly uncover something new. Sorry this stinks to me of getting the media spotlight back.

gazzae 17-05-2011 23:08

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Is the government offering the same support to all families with children missing abroad? When does Ben Needham's review start?

Arthurgray50@blu 17-05-2011 23:25

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I would say that without this insistance by the McCann's, is good for all missing kids.

Lets be honest about this, There is NOTHING being done about missing kids in this country, apart from the excellant being done by Kids charities, But if a child goes missing in this country or another, everything goes quiet after a couple of months.

BUT, with the Maddie situation, they are forcing the governments hands in doing something about it.

I applaud the McCanns for doing what they are doing, and l trust and hope that Maddie is alive, IF she is found IT will be done by The Yard.

Stuart 18-05-2011 10:51

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Arthurgray50@blu (Post 35238961)
Lets be honest about this, There is NOTHING being done about missing kids in this country, apart from the excellant being done by Kids charities, But if a child goes missing in this country or another, everything goes quiet after a couple of months.

You know this how?

Mr_love_monkey 18-05-2011 11:07

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stuart (Post 35239103)
You know this how?

You can understand what Arthur is saying, how? :)

Jimmy-J 18-05-2011 11:21

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
If there's enough money to provide drug addicts with methadone, then there should NOT be a shortage of money and resources to help find missing children.

RizzyKing 18-05-2011 14:44

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
There are many good and noble things that we could plough time and resources into problem is both time and resources are finite and have to be managed accordingly. Allowing heart to rule head however distasteful it is isn't the way to run things and never should be allowed. Personally i hope there is public "we will do all we can" and in private carrying on as before.

martyh 18-05-2011 16:28

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Product 13 (Post 35239119)
If there's enough money to provide drug addicts with methadone, then there should NOT be a shortage of money and resources to help find missing children.

All the available evidence points to her not being found ,obviously that's not 100% but it is much more likely she is dead or at best being raised by a different family so why waste time and money looking for someone that is most likely never going to be found ,how long will the met keep looking tieing up recourses that would be better used saving a life that can be saved? .Eventually the perpetrator/s will make a mistake and get caught then hopefully we will know the truth

Hom3r 18-05-2011 19:51

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
It's hard to believe that when I first started this thread 4 years ago she is still missing.

I believe one of the following scenarios has happened. (in no particular order)

1. She was stolen to order by a family who are rasing her as their own.

2. She woke up and tried to find her parents and was taken by a paedo in the area

3. A Paedo entered the house and took her for their person use.

4. She was taken by a sex gang to sell her.

5. The parent accidently killed her and disposed of the body somewhere. (I doubt this one but it has been voiced)

6. Kidnapped for a ransom, but something went wrong.

If she is alive (which I doubt) she may turn up in her twenties.

Chris 18-05-2011 19:56

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
(1) or (4) are most likely. (5) is laughable and several British newspapers have made eye-watering out-of-court payments for saying less. Please be careful.

RizzyKing 18-05-2011 21:12

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Well legal issues aside 5 cannot be completely ruled out by virtue that no one knows what happened to her nothing libellous there just a simple fact. I don't think she is going to be found by conventional methods police work is not going to do it. If and it is in my mind a big if she's still alive she will only reappear due to a screw up on the part of those who took her not very likely or she grows up finds out who she really is and comes forward.

Whatever your personal theory on all this one thing is for certain this incident was a tradegy for maddie but it is a tradegy that has happened to many others and i don't belileve the mc'canns have the right to emotionally blackmail anyone.

As i said hard as it is they have to move on and let this go constantly pressuring people to do ths and that isn't going to help and certainly after all this time isn't going to magically make her appear. By all means run a full page spread each year i bet a few papers would probably waive their normal fee maybe even make the odd tele appeal but thats it.

Waldo Pepper 19-05-2011 19:42

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
What I find sad is that:

1) She is a Brit citizen.
2) She is a child.
3) She certainly didn't have parents like poor Shannon Matthews had.

And apart from the parents nobody in authority seems to want it on their shift.

Disgraceful!!!!

RizzyKing 20-05-2011 01:40

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Well maybe you'll answer Waldo if we should continue with this what exactly should we be doing that has not already been done exactly and how much time and resources should be allocated to this and for how long till it's ok to let it drop. Just so you know answers along the lines of "whatever it takes for as long as it takes" are not very practical so something realistic is what i am after given the finite resources this country has ?.

Waldo Pepper 20-05-2011 15:55

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RizzyKing (Post 35240981)
Well maybe you'll answer Waldo if we should continue with this what exactly should we be doing that has not already been done exactly and how much time and resources should be allocated to this and for how long till it's ok to let it drop. Just so you know answers along the lines of "whatever it takes for as long as it takes" are not very practical so something realistic is what i am after given the finite resources this country has ?.

Well Rizz that maybe so. But we do have cold case units within the Police and I can't believe this can be shoved under the carpet as it is still so recent.

Many believe the McCanns may have done it themselves, but that's just another conspiracy until proven otherwise. If this was the case I think they would let sleeping dogs lie. However they haven't. They are still appealing for information which could muddy the waters and bring up something they wanted to avoid if this was the case..

I do believe they were negligent in leaving the kids alone, but boy they are now paying the price and no one seems to care. It's a missing child.

The same accusations were never levelled against the victims of Fred & Rose West for allowing them to be picked up by this evil couple.

Nor against the parents of the victims of the Moors Murderers for letting their child go to a shop on their own.

Milly Dowler's Parents for allowing her to walk home alone from school.

It's a fine line re- allowing any child out of your sight.

Not sure the Tabloids and the McCanns need to tell everyone that Kate went off sex. I thought this would be pretty obvious under the circumstances.

Osem 20-05-2011 16:38

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
My feeling on this is that, whilst it's unfair for all this effort to be expended on one missing child and not all the others out there (whose parents possibly aren't quite so educated and articulate), it's always been the case that those who make the most noise get heard and the McCanns have certainly done that. I'd do the same if I were them but, equally, I wouldn't blame other people for feeling a degree of resentment about it.

Waldo Pepper 21-05-2011 15:59

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35241324)
My feeling on this is that, whilst it's unfair for all this effort to be expended on one missing child and not all the others out there (whose parents possibly aren't quite so educated and articulate), it's always been the case that those who make the most noise get heard and the McCanns have certainly done that. I'd do the same if I were them but, equally, I wouldn't blame other people for feeling a degree of resentment about it.

So in your eyes, stupid people don't deserve/get help but the educated do?

I don't remember the Police taking a light heart re Shannon Mathews. She was a missing kid born of evil parents who exploited her,

RizzyKing 21-05-2011 16:28

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
This abduction\murder\accident occurred in another country straight away our right to investgate gets a lot more complicated and thats forgetting that no police force in the UK has jurisdiction. Add in the time that has passed and the effect of that on evidence\witnesses most of which wasn't good when this was all fresh.

Yet were supposed to continue to plough in resources and time for something that didn't even happen in our country they may be british citizens and all that but they chose to go aborad they chose to leave their kids alone and now everyone else has to sort out the mess.

Were in a mess in this country right now services that you and i rely on everyday are either being cut or are at risk of being cut and money should be spent on this seriously. You didn't answer my part about what to do what is there left to do that hasn't been done.

They have already spent all the money from the maddie fund which was no small amount and got nothing numerous individuals have spent a lot of time and effort and got nothing. I would dearly love for her to turn up tomorrow and be ok i would dearly love all the kiddies that have gone missing abroad to turn up safe and sound but we have to be realistic.

Chris 24-04-2012 19:50

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Another year on and British detectives are conducting a review of the case, claiming to have all the evidence in the same place, at the same time, for the first time. Five years after Madeleine McCann's disappearance, I'm a tad surprised if this really is the *first* time the evidence has been sifted so thoroughly.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17828015

Osem 24-04-2012 23:04

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I'd like to think that the Police expend the same amount of time and effort on all missing children but somehow doubt they do. I wonder how many parents who've been in similar circumstances have received this sort of attention. Whilst I'm sure they don't begrudge the McCanns anything, they must feel like second class citizens.

Damien 24-04-2012 23:25

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Osem (Post 35418797)
I'd like to think that the Police expend the same amount of time and effort on all missing children but somehow doubt they do. I wonder how many parents who've been in similar circumstances have received this sort of attention. Whilst I'm sure they don't begrudge the McCanns anything, they must feel like second class citizens.

At the time I was annoyed. Canterbury town center had posters everywhere. In McDonalds, massive ones in the Superdrug window and, well, everywhere else. Given where she went missing it's highly unlikely anyone in Canterbury would have seen her and would have missed the wall-to-wall coverage in the press. You kind of think that if they had done the same for a local missing person the posters would stand a far greater chance of being effective.

You can't begrudge the McCann family for being so effective in keeping the search going, good luck to them, everyone hopes this tale has a happy ending. However it is probably evidence of the emotive storms that envelop the country from time to time. The annual Poppy crusades where newspapers start becoming judge and jury on who in the public eye hasn't displayed the required level of respect is another example.

Osem 25-04-2012 10:02

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Very true. So who's responsible for this decision and why was it made after all the previous goings on? As a genuine attempt to solve a crime? Has powerful (even political) pressure been brought to bear behind the scenes? Or is this just a way of demonstrating how thorough they've been and covering their backs in a high profile case? If this sort of thing isn't being routinely practised in similar, albeit less well known, unsolved cases, it seems to me the upper echelons of the Police may be behaving like politicians.

Horace 25-04-2012 17:46

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Updated image of Madeleine using CGI http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17838052

From the article :
""We are working on the basis of two possibilities here - one is that Madeleine is still alive; and the second that she is sadly dead," he said."

He seems to be implying there are other possibilities and I'm struggling to work out what they might be.

Hom3r 25-04-2012 19:22

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Horace (Post 35419084)
Updated image of Madeleine using CGI http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17838052

From the article :
""We are working on the basis of two possibilities here - one is that Madeleine is still alive; and the second that she is sadly dead," he said."

He seems to be implying there are other possibilities and I'm struggling to work out what they might be.

I think they meant alive and being treated as "their daughter", the other is to horrible to put in to words or even think, but IMHO a fate worse than death:(

Anonymouse 26-04-2012 16:09

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I saw articles such as this, this and others in today's papers which suggest she is alive and has been seen. Here's hoping...

Pierre 26-04-2012 17:46

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Although there has been the odd case, such as the one America, and Fritzel which is similar, where the abducted has been kept alive and hidden it is rare.

And whilst you can never give up hope............ I would expect her to have been killed soon after she was abducted.

TheDaddy 27-04-2012 03:01

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I think she's still alive, don't know why just got a feeling

TheDaddy 15-05-2012 05:13

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
She's dead, according to psychic scoundrel and proven liar Derek accorah

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage...ead-claim.html

Osem 15-05-2012 09:43

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Don't suppose he'll mind all the publicity.

Maggy 15-05-2012 10:44

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
So let us not give him any more.;)

Osem 15-05-2012 12:16

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
:tu:

budwieser 15-05-2012 23:50

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
I still believe she`s safe and well somewhere.

thenry 24-10-2013 15:52

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Quote:

Police in Portugal have reopened the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann - five years after the original probe was closed.

http://news.sky.com/story/1159161/ma...ps-reopen-case

Hom3r 24-10-2013 17:21

Who would have thought when I started this thread 6 years ago she still would be missing.

I hope she was stolen to a family that would look after her, and not a fate worse than death.

joglynne 13-01-2014 15:00

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Madeleine McCann: Police ‘preparing to make first arrests’

http://metro.co.uk/2014/01/13/madele...rests-4260951/

I realise that this development could just rule out these possible suspects but maybe ......

RizzyKing 13-01-2014 23:04

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Three burglers to be arrested sounds more like "we gotta be seen to have been doing something" then anything meaningful.

richard s 14-01-2014 16:44

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Do not forget the Ben Needham case 1991 in Greece the poor Mother has not received no were near as much help as the McCann's have.

I hope they are both found and reunited with their parents.

weenie 15-01-2014 02:38

Re: [MERGED] Madeleine McCann
 
Could not agree with you more, let's pray they are found safe and well...

Arthurgray50@blu 02-06-2014 12:43

Madeline McCann - New search
 
http://news.sky.com/story/1273546/ma...e-at-scrubland

Watching this article on Sky, is really good to think that something is finally being done.

The only thing that has started this thread is the stinking attitude of the holiday maker. Who has said that the island is very pleased to see holidaymakers and that they are very friendly - buts it is sad that this dig, has come at a bad time for the tourist season.

What if it was his own child ?

The part that has to be looked at here, is that at the time of her disappearance - the island had sex assaults and burglaries at the time.

I think that IF, they do find her body,then, it will be who killed her.:(

MalteseFalcon 02-06-2014 12:49

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
At the risk of infractions, I have long had my view of who killed her. I am not the only one who thinks that. What upsets me is that nobody has investigated the parents (or if they were investigated it was kept quiet) for negligence and bad parenting. If they can leave children alone on holiday in a foreign country, they can do it in this country.

weenie 02-06-2014 13:29

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Arthurgray50@blu (Post 35703379)


I would hope that he would not leave the child alone and vulnerable either at home or in a foreign country.

Pierre 02-06-2014 13:37

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkC1984 (Post 35703386)
At the risk of infractions, I have long had my view of who killed her. I am not the only one who thinks that. What upsets me is that nobody has investigated the parents (or if they were investigated it was kept quiet) for negligence and bad parenting. If they can leave children alone on holiday in a foreign country, they can do it in this country.

been done, and argued to the umpteenth degree in another thread.

weenie 02-06-2014 13:38

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkC1984 (Post 35703386)
At the risk of infractions, I have long had my view of who killed her. I am not the only one who thinks that. What upsets me is that nobody has investigated the parents (or if they were investigated it was kept quiet) for negligence and bad parenting. If they can leave children alone on holiday in a foreign country, they can do it in this country.

:tu:
The McCann's seem to still refuse any fault of their actions IMO. I wonder if I ever left my children here or abroad if I would have been allowed to keep my other children after showing negligence as I see no other word that could possibly describe their actions in leaving three children under the age of 3 alone while they dined out.

Sirius 02-06-2014 13:42

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkC1984 (Post 35703386)
At the risk of infractions, I have long had my view of who killed her. I am not the only one who thinks that. What upsets me is that nobody has investigated the parents (or if they were investigated it was kept quiet) for negligence and bad parenting. If they can leave children alone on holiday in a foreign country, they can do it in this country.

:clap:

Pierre 02-06-2014 13:47

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by weenie (Post 35703411)
:tu:
The McCann's seem to still refuse any fault of their actions IMO. I wonder if I ever left my children here or abroad if I would have been allowed to keep my other children after showing negligence as I see no other word that could possibly describe their actions in leaving three children under the age of 3 alone while they dined out.

Now that summer is here, I leave my 3year old in bed from 19:00 onwards, whilst his mum and I see sit out on our decking which is located at the far end of our property approx 45m from our house.

So if a monster was to break into the house and steal our child, would we be classed a negligent?

Or should one of us stay in the house at all times our little one is asleep?

peanut 02-06-2014 13:49

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35703414)
Now that summer is here, I leave my 3year old in bed from 19:00 onwards, whilst his mum and I see sit out on our decking which is located at the far end of our property approx 45m from our house.

So if a monster was to break into the house and steal our child, would we be classed a negligent?

Or should one of us stay in the house at all times our little one is asleep?

Would you leave your property and go out for meal whilst your child is in bed?

MalteseFalcon 02-06-2014 13:51

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
No, because even sitting out in the garden you are still on the premises and would assume you would hear someone breaking into your property. They weren't in the apartment, or near enough to the apartment to see whoever it was that took Maddie (ignoring my suspicions anyway) from the apartment. That is negligent behavior from the parents and also the friends who did not speak up (again, if they did it was never reported) about leaving 3 young children alone whilst they went out drinking.

Pierre 02-06-2014 13:51

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 35703417)
Would you leave your property and go out for meal whilst your child is in bed?

Last week we had a barbecue, again, approx 45m from our house at the far and of our property and left our child in his bed.

So we did.

weenie 02-06-2014 13:52

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35703414)
Now that summer is here, I leave my 3year old in bed from 19:00 onwards, whilst his mum and I see sit out on our decking which is located at the far end of our property approx 45m from our house.

So if a monster was to break into the house and steal our child, would we be classed a negligent?

Or should one of us stay in the house at all times our little one is asleep?

You can see your house from the decking yes I take it.

peanut 02-06-2014 13:55

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pierre (Post 35703420)
Last week we had a barbecue, again, approx 45m from our house at the far and of our property and left our child in his bed.

So we did.

I said leave your property. Would you also do this in a foreign country and not in opinion of your safe surroundings of your home.

Pierre 02-06-2014 13:59

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkC1984 (Post 35703419)
No, because even sitting out in the garden you are still on the premises and would assume you would hear someone breaking into your property.

We had loud music on

Quote:

They weren't in the apartment, or near enough to the apartment to see whoever it was that took Maddie (ignoring my suspicions anyway) from the apartment.
They where in the tapas bar across the way, within the complex. Probably closer to the apartment than my decking/BBQ area is to my house

Quote:

That is negligent behavior from the parents and also the friends who did not speak up (again, if they did it was never reported) about leaving 3 young children alone whilst they went out drinking.
My BBQ had my child and two cousins staying, we are partied down the far end of the property, we went and checked on the kids peridoically

Just as the McCanns did.

---------- Post added at 12:59 ---------- Previous post was at 12:58 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by weenie (Post 35703421)
You can see your house from the decking yes I take it.

Only 1 side of it, I can't see all around the house.

Pauls9 02-06-2014 14:00

re: Madeline McCann - New search
 
Perhaps you should carry a baby alarm with you?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:43.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum