Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Lifestyle (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   Out of Control Children (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33663730)

Chris 11-04-2010 14:21

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34998990)
well that just about sums it up ....make excuses ,don't blame anybody ,can't you just accept that sometimes people are bad parents and teach their kids unaceptible behaviour

I expect Flyboy fully accepts that. However, can you accept that this thread was opened with a very specific example of a specific child? In that specific case we simply don't know the circumstances. It's all very well you insisting that 'sometimes people are bad'; well, the Pope's Catholic and bears have a preference for tree cover whilst attending to their toilet. So what. The fact that 'sometimes people are bad' doesn't in any way mean we can pass judgement on this specific situation without knowing the circumstances.

martyh 11-04-2010 14:26

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34999078)
I expect Flyboy fully accepts that. However, can you accept that this thread was opened with a very specific example of a specific child? In that specific case we simply don't know the circumstances. It's all very well you insisting that 'sometimes people are bad'; well, the Pope's Catholic and bears have a preference for tree cover whilst attending to their toilet. So what. The fact that 'sometimes people are bad' doesn't in any way mean we can pass judgement on this specific situation without knowing the circumstances.

no-one was asked to comment on one specific incident just comment on bad parents/unruly children in general ...the ones without disorders

Chris 11-04-2010 14:33

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by martyh (Post 34999085)
no-one was asked to comment on one specific incident just comment on bad parents/unruly children in general ...the ones without disorders

Actually we were asked to comment on a specific incident. The OP's first sentence was this:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Welshchris (Post 34996624)
Isnt it a wonder that there are so many idiots on the streets now when Parents cant be bothered to correct their kids...

... and afterwards he used a specific incident that he had just witnessed as 'evidence' for his generalisation.

The obvious weakness of his argument is that it is based on one incident, whose background we're unaware of. In arguing that point, commenting on the specific incident is unavoidable.

Xaccers 11-04-2010 20:22

Re: Out of Control Children
 
So he opened with a general statement on parents not being bothered to correct their kids, in a thread titled "Out of control children" and gave an example of a parent not bothering to correct her preschool child.
Yes, of course, it's obvious that he was asking us to comment on the specific answer, the thread title and opening sentence make that blatant...

Chris 11-04-2010 20:27

Re: Out of Control Children
 
The point being, neither you, nor I, nor the OP are in a position to make a judgement of the attitude of the mother in question. And 'not bothered' as you put it is most definitely a judgement of her attitude and disposition. Do you have some kind of crystal ball?

martyh 11-04-2010 20:34

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34999328)
The point being, neither you, nor I, nor the OP are in a position to make a judgement of the attitude of the mother in question. And 'not bothered' as you put it is most definitely a judgement of her attitude and disposition. Do you have some kind of crystal ball?

well the op saw the incident ,and was better placed to make judgement ,it's not hard to tell if a person is grinning out of amusement or embarrassment

Xaccers 11-04-2010 22:06

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34999328)
The point being, neither you, nor I, nor the OP are in a position to make a judgement of the attitude of the mother in question. And 'not bothered' as you put it is most definitely a judgement of her attitude and disposition. Do you have some kind of crystal ball?

So what you're saying is, you believe the parents he said are not bothered are all infact this one woman, and the children in the thread title are infact the one child in the push chair, and he wasn't giving an example when he mentioned the woman and child he had seen?

Why he didn't title the thread "Chav mother with obnoxious kid" and start his first post talking about the woman rather than parents in general is anyone's guess I suppose then.

Chris 11-04-2010 22:55

Re: Out of Control Children
 
What I'm saying Xac, as per usual, is what is found in my post, not what is found in yours. ;)

Xaccers 11-04-2010 23:56

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris (Post 34999418)
What I'm saying Xac, as per usual, is what is found in my post, not what is found in yours. ;)

What your post contains is illogical given what is contained in the OP.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:20.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum