Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Lifestyle (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   Out of Control Children (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33663730)

Gary L 08-04-2010 14:46

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Maggy J (Post 34997215)
Agreed.

I wonder if she managed to make it to Elizabeth Duke in Argos afterwards, or she went straight home to get over it?

Maggy 08-04-2010 14:47

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary L (Post 34997219)
I wonder if she managed to make it to Elizabeth Duke in Argos afterwards, or she went straight home to get over it?

Who cares?

Gary L 08-04-2010 14:48

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by peanut (Post 34997217)
Maybe the mother was a ventriloquist. :D

What, you think she was throwing her voice and it looked like it was the child saying it? maybe the child was a puppet? :D

Escapee 08-04-2010 16:00

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997145)
I think you've got that the wrong way round, what it shows a child is that violent solves everything. A case in point, I was physically bullied by a teacher at school. He would find any excuse to give me the slipper. One day, I had had enough. I refused to submit and when he tried to grab me, I turned and kicked him between the legs and punched him in the face. Hardly holds form to your theory.

I think others have covered the point sufficiently, but just to make my stance clear. I believe their is a huge difference between smacking a child as a punishment, compared to child abuse.

I never once got smacked by my father, his slightly raised voice was enough. The amount of times I received a slap from my mother can be counted on my hands, my nan also slapped me a few times but could be counted on one hand.

I do remember my nan chasing me with the boiler stick on one occasion, but to be fair I had been a right little sod that day.

Perhaps the few amounts of smacks I received is due to the fact that I was a little :angel:

My GF will smack her kids if needed, but her raised voice is enough to frighten most people. She did pick one up and hold her against the wall a few months ago, but this was due to the youngest taking something and letting the eldest have the blame and a smack.

I'm actually too soft, and in a difficult position with them not being my kids. They appreciate that when they are getting a good rollocking, I generally take the pee and add a bit of light hearted banter to deflect the telling off. Of course the blame then falls on me for making light of things. If I threaten to put the 9 year old across my knee and smack her bottom she doesn't take me seriously, but on the other hand when I have been out shopping with them on my own and they do something I'm not happy with, I only have to say stop and they stop doing whatever it is.

I must say though, that her kids are the best behaved kids I have come across because they are fully aware of right from wrong. I guess it's the way they have been brought up, respect is a huge thing in their culture.

Flyboy 08-04-2010 16:26

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Xaccers (Post 34997161)
Had his slipper use been restrained to only be used when justified, would you have reacted in the same way?

This happened nearly every single day. The incident I described occured when I was nine years old andy was due to me doing something I had been instructed to do, after being slippered the day before. The consequences of this teacher's actions was that he was suspended and interviewed by the police for assault. This was at a time when corporal punishment was no longer legal in primary schools. So, in reference to your question, I do not believe it is ever justified to beat a nine year old with any implement, do you?

Saaf_laandon_mo 08-04-2010 16:32

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I was on the train this morning and there was a mum and two kids, one about a couple of years old in a buggy, and the second - a girl of about 5 (same age as my daughter). I know she was the mum because the older girl called her Mum whenever she was talking to here.

During the journey 'mum' takes a call on her mobile, talking extremely loudly. A woman asked her if she minded lowering her voice (The conversation was not really suitable for public broadcast). The 'mum's' reply was extremely aggressive and contained quite a few expletives. It's parents like that who, in my opinion, shouldn't have kids. What sort of example is that to set to a 5 year old?

Xaccers 08-04-2010 16:40

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997283)
This happened nearly every single day. The incident I described occured when I was nine years old andy was due to me doing something I had been instructed to do, after being slippered the day before. The consequences of this teacher's actions was that he was suspended and interviewed by the police for assault. This was at a time when corporal punishment was no longer legal in primary schools. So, in reference to your question, I do not believe it is ever justified to beat a nine year old with any implement, do you?

That depends, are you able to tell the difference between a smack for discipline and a beating?

Flyboy 08-04-2010 17:09

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo (Post 34997288)
I was on the train this morning and there was a mum and two kids, one about a couple of years old in a buggy, and the second - a girl of about 5 (same age as my daughter). I know she was the mum because the older girl called her Mum whenever she was talking to here.

During the journey 'mum' takes a call on her mobile, talking extremely loudly. A woman asked her if she minded lowering her voice (The conversation was not really suitable for public broadcast). The 'mum's' reply was extremely aggressive and contained quite a few expletives. It's parents like that who, in my opinion, shouldn't have kids. What sort of example is that to set to a 5 year old?

These are the times at which I really despair, when someone demonstrates such disregard, not only for others, but their own children.

Xaccers 08-04-2010 17:38

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997298)
These are the times at which I really despair, when someone demonstrates such disregard, not only for others, but their own children.

GF and I were driving through Bletchley a couple of weeks ago, witnessed a kid, must have been 4 or 5 being a bit, well, like a 4/5 year old boy really in not wanting to go where his mum was takin him.
She swept her arm back to point in the direction she wanted them to go behind her, and he instantly cowered back with his arms up.
You do not have to smack children hard to get the message across that they've done wrong, just enough to give them a shock, such as a light tap on the back of the hand when a toddler is cought doing something wrong or dangerous. It's the shock of their parent hitting them which has the effect more than pain. No child should be hit by a fully pulled back hand.

papa smurf 08-04-2010 17:39

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997145)
I think you've got that the wrong way round, what it shows a child is that violent solves everything. A case in point, I was physically bullied by a teacher at school. He would find any excuse to give me the slipper. One day, I had had enough. I refused to submit and when he tried to grab me, I turned and kicked him between the legs and punched him in the face. Hardly holds form to your theory.

why am i not surprised:rolleyes:
kicking and punching a teacher now that's out of control ,or is it the norm
down your neck of the woods ? if we all went around beating up teachers because we didn't like discipline what kind of mess would we be in .
we all got the slipper in my class if we stepped out of line ,its not as though it hurt it was just embarrassing being put in our place by an authority figure .

Flyboy 08-04-2010 20:16

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by papa smurf (Post 34997323)
why am i not surprised:rolleyes:
kicking and punching a teacher now that's out of control ,or is it the norm
down your neck of the woods ? if we all went around beating up teachers because we didn't like discipline what kind of mess would we be in .
we all got the slipper in my class if we stepped out of line ,its not as though it hurt it was just embarrassing being put in our place by an authority figure .

And how do you think a nine year old should re-act to systematic physical abuse from a bully? As I understand it, that's a subject you have some extensive knowledge and experience.

papa smurf 08-04-2010 20:36

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997455)
And how do you think a nine year old should re-act to systematic physical abuse from a bully? As I understand it, that's a subject you have some extensive knowledge and experience.

no I've never actually abused a nine year old ,or any other age group -so you pretty much have no understanding of me whatsoever , you seem to think I'm some kind of bully ,I'm not and never have been ,but lets concentrate on you .
your the bully here- trying to suggest i have "extensive knowledge and experience" that smacks of bulling by keyboard ,its quite pathetic really ,but i can see why a teacher would want to wallop you ,but we only have your side of that story ,and if you did get slippered its no worse than thousands of other kids got at school your no special case ,you need to get over your self chum.

Flyboy 08-04-2010 21:17

Re: Out of Control Children
 
So, the boasts about shoving peoples' heads down the toilet was what?

Maggy 08-04-2010 21:24

Re: Out of Control Children
 
I think we are now wandering a long way off topic..which maybe about today's poor parenting skills shown in public or how some people prejudge a situation ... not about which of us is a bully.

papa smurf 08-04-2010 21:24

Re: Out of Control Children
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flyboy (Post 34997489)
So, the boasts about shoving peoples' heads down toilet was what?

school boy pranks -i had plenty of pranks played on me
but i never did nut bag the teacher and stick a gob on him ,you my have been school bully or your full of bull I'll let the readers decide.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:32.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum