Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   Sport (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=88)
-   -   Football : Season 2009/2010 (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33653632)

Derek 14-11-2009 20:03

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34909629)
I'm almost considering a "our manager is more rubbish than yours" debate :D

I'd win that. Our manager is so bad we just got beaten by the Welsh! ;)

Russ 14-11-2009 20:12

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Our manager is so bad the score was 3-0 to us but I still had to check if we'd lost.

Niles Crane 14-11-2009 20:32

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Egypt have scored in the 95th minute!! 2-0, meaning a one match play-off in Sudan if it ends like this.

EDIT: Final whistle. Egypt and Algeria finish on the same points, goal difference, goals scored, goals conceded and match records.

How anybody can dislike international football, i'll never know. As i'd hoped, this was magnificent.

Shadow Demon UK 14-11-2009 20:34

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Brilliant, Egypt!!

Niles Crane 14-11-2009 20:41

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
It has to be said though; this may well be a case of "Cairo Stadium Overtime". I feel sorry for Algeria.

Shadow Demon UK 14-11-2009 20:50

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34909656)
It has to be said though; this may well be a case of "Cairo Stadium Overtime". I feel sorry for Algeria.


I thought 6 minutes added time was very, very generous. I'm glad it was that long though because of that ending.

Niles Crane 14-11-2009 20:54

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shadow Demon UK (Post 34909661)
I thought 6 minutes added time was very, very generous. I'm glad it was that long though because of that ending.

I agree. They came so close to getting a third too.

Niles Crane 14-11-2009 23:27

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

There was bad news for Holland and Arsenal, though, with Dutch striker Robin van Persie leaving the pitch nursing an injury just 16 minutes in.

http://soccernet.espn.go.com/report?id=284409&cc=5739
Now this is a great reason to hate the international break. Our squad is ridiculously injury prone.

SB_07 16-11-2009 21:08

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Larissa have confirmed Mexico international Antonio de Nigris has died at the age of 31.
http://www.skysports.com/story/0,195...699220,00.html

Niles Crane 16-11-2009 22:43

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Security forces have been deployed to protect the Egyptian embassy in Algiers after Egyptian businesses in the Algerian capital were attacked.

The offices of Egypt Air and an Egyptian phone company were ransacked on Sunday during a rally in support of the Algerian football team.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/8362215.stm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzGNjrElmHE

Niles Crane 17-11-2009 19:19

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
A British TV channel has finally woken up to this encounter, so the Egypt vs Algeria play-off will be live on Eurosport at 17:30 tomorrow.

SB_07 18-11-2009 20:04

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
The audio on Eurosport is terrible.

NoKnowledge 18-11-2009 20:29

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
I think this is gonna be a draw

---------- Post added at 19:29 ---------- Previous post was at 19:12 ----------

And Algeria qualify by winning 1 zip

SB_07 18-11-2009 23:12

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Ireland 1 up in France!

---------- Post added at 22:12 ---------- Previous post was at 20:33 ----------

Wow, most blatent handball ever. Poor Ireland.

Damien 18-11-2009 23:16

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Defiantly a Hand Ball. I did think it could have well been a penalty before though. Given got a hand on Anelka's ankle.

iadom 18-11-2009 23:17

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Cheating French b******s, what an absolute disgrace. :mad: Ireland have been so much the better side but should have put away at least one of the four clear chances they had in the second half.

Fingy 18-11-2009 23:21

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
arrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Damien 18-11-2009 23:22

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iadom (Post 34911729)
Cheating French b******s, what an absolute disgrace. :mad: Ireland have been so much the better side but should have put away at least one of the four clear chances they had in the second half.

Calm Down a bit. Sky Sports are quite on the Irish side here, that could easily been been a penalty to France and it wasn't given. While Sky pretty much say it was a dive.

Still this won't be a nice way for France to go though. :erm:

SB_07 18-11-2009 23:24

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
He even handled it again to push it to his feet.

What happened to you Thierry =(

Damien 18-11-2009 23:28

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Raymond Domenech needs to be fired. These performances won't get them past the group stage.

Niles Crane 18-11-2009 23:30

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
I'm really disappointed Russia didn't qualify. To a lesser extent, Bosnia too.

SB_07 18-11-2009 23:32

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Now we have cheating France & cheating Portugal in the WC.

tbf it looks like Henry knows he's cheated Ireland.

Damien 18-11-2009 23:36

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34911742)
I'm really disappointed Russia didn't qualify. To a lesser extent, Bosnia too.

Russia didn't qualify :O

---------- Post added at 22:36 ---------- Previous post was at 22:33 ----------

Got to say this is more evidence that we need video replays. It's not as if this would even out over the course of a season.

Niles Crane 18-11-2009 23:36

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Sad Ireland didn't qualify, especially due to a missed handball. Though i have to admit i'm a bit of a francophile.

Damien 18-11-2009 23:38

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SB_07 (Post 34911743)
tbf it looks like Henry knows he's cheated Ireland.

Extra time. You need a goal to go to the world cup and a massive chance has opened up but you need the hand to stop it going out of play. He looked ashamed but he would do it again. As would a lot of players.

Russ 18-11-2009 23:39

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Once an Arsenal cheat...

Niles Crane 18-11-2009 23:40

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34911744)
Russia didn't qualify :O[COLOR="Silver"]

The sight of Arshavin at the end was hard to watch, i really feel sorry for him. This was meant to be Russia's "golden generation" and yet they've failed to qualify for both World Cups this decade.

SB_07 18-11-2009 23:41

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Arshavin can focus on us now \o/

Damien 18-11-2009 23:42

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34911750)
The sight of Arshavin at the end was hard to watch, i really feel sorry for him. This was meant to be Russia's "golden generation" and yet they've failed to qualify for both World Cups this decade.

Shame Arshavin won't be at World Cup :(

Hiddink back to Chelsea?

iadom 18-11-2009 23:42

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34911749)
Once an Arsenal cheat...


Ain't that the truth. :mad:

Damien 18-11-2009 23:42

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Yes. Arsenal are the only team to have players who cheat/handball. Whatever.

SB_07 18-11-2009 23:43

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Don't remember Henry ever using a hand to assist/score a goal before? He only ever scored quality goals which is why he's a legend.

iadom 18-11-2009 23:46

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34911733)
Calm Down a bit. Sky Sports are quite on the Irish side here, that could easily been been a penalty to France and it wasn't given. While Sky pretty much say it was a dive.

Still this won't be a nice way for France to go though. :erm:


Whilst it could 'easily have been given' there was no way that was a penalty, it was a dive and the ball was well out of Anelka's reach by then.

Didn't Anelka once play for Arsenal, to quote that well known football sage Russ," once an Arsenal cheat" .....;)

Damien 18-11-2009 23:47

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SB_07 (Post 34911758)
Don't remember Henry ever using a hand to assist/score a goal before? He only ever scored quality goals which is why he's a legend.

He was cost a goal in the FA Cup Final when a Liverpool Player cleared it off the line. (That wasn't cheating because it was a English Defender I believe).

Rooney would have done the same, Torres would have done the Same, Keane would have done the same, Van Persie would have done the same. We need video replays because how many players would do the honest thing with so much mistake.

---------- Post added at 22:47 ---------- Previous post was at 22:47 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by iadom (Post 34911759)
Whilst it could 'easily have been given' there was no way that was a penalty, it was a dive and the ball was well out of Anelka's reach by then.

Didn't Anelka once play for Arsenal, to quote that well known football sage Russ," once an Arsenal cheat" .....;)

Given got a clear hand on his ankle.

sir_drinks_alot 18-11-2009 23:48

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
classic fifa fix :( france where never going to lose with refs being paid off and told that france must win at all costs ;(

LondonRoad 18-11-2009 23:48

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
EXCLUSIVE FROM Paris. Thierry Henry has been named as captain to spearhead France's challenge for the Rugby 6 nations championship in 2010. French spokesperson Jendorse Le cheats said "clearly handling skills such as Thierry is capable of will be of grande benefit to us"

Damien 18-11-2009 23:53

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sir_drinks_alot (Post 34911762)
classic fifa fix :( france where never going to lose with refs being paid off and told that france must win at all costs ;(

:rolleyes:

---------- Post added at 22:53 ---------- Previous post was at 22:48 ----------

Why do reports always say controversial when it isn't. I don't anyone can argue it was a goal.

Niles Crane 18-11-2009 23:54

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iadom (Post 34911759)
Whilst it could 'easily have been given' there was no way that was a penalty, it was a dive and the ball was well out of Anelka's reach by then.

Didn't Anelka once play for Arsenal, to quote that well known football sage Russ," once an Arsenal cheat" .....;)

Practically half the France team either play or played for Arsenal and that's been the case for the last 10 years. Congratulations on finally noticing that.

Did you know Arsene Wenger is French?

Same as Russia, i'm also disappointed Egypt didn't qualify, they have a great squad are can play some great football. But Algeria certainly aren't a bad substitute.

adzii_nufc 18-11-2009 23:56

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
after tonight.. Thierry Henry.. Legend status? Revoked

250+ Goals dont give him the right to cheat..

Ever see Pele use his hand to get a goal
Shearer?
Lineker?
Maradonna .. Oh nevermind

Goals dont make you a legend.. a heart for the game makes you a legend.. Henry has shown us now all he cares about is a paycheck hence the move to barca in the first place

Bring back players like Shearer and Lineker... Players who wee proud to wear any football shirt wether the team was trophyless or pennyless

TheDaddy 18-11-2009 23:59

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iadom (Post 34911729)
Cheating French b******s, what an absolute disgrace. :mad: Ireland have been so much the better side but should have put away at least one of the four clear chances they had in the second half.

:Yes: well said robbed by the hand of frog

Damien 19-11-2009 00:00

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adzii_nufc (Post 34911770)
after tonight.. Thierry Henry.. Legend status? Revoked

Nope. Almost every player has done things like this. As you said Maradonna is still a legend of a player, a rubbish manager but a legend of a player. Henry has won almost Every Major Spanish, British, and World Trophy.


Quote:

Goals dont make you a legend.. a heart for the game makes you a legend.. Henry has shown us now all he cares about is a paycheck hence the move to barca in the first place
He moved because he didn't want to be the 'main' player at Arsenal in the way it was, to had too much pressure, and because he (correctly) thought he would have a better chance of winning the trophy that most alluded him. The Champions League.

LondonRoad 19-11-2009 00:04

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34911772)
Maradonna is still a legend of a player, a **** manager but a legend of a player. He has won almost Every Major Spanish, British, and World Trophy.

I don't recall Maradonna willing a Scottish League Cup winners medal and there may be other major British Trophies he didn't win too. ( Did he even play in the Welsh Premier League) ;) :D

.... the same applies to Thierry

NoKnowledge 19-11-2009 00:05

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
As the saying goes "Don't hate the player, hate the game" or is that a saying for something else.

Damien 19-11-2009 00:07

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LondonRoad (Post 34911774)
I don't recall Maradonna willing a Scottish League Cup winners medal and there may be other major British Trophies he didn't win too. ( Did he even play in the Welsh Premier League) ;) :D

.... the same applies to Thierry

Sorry, Meant England. Not Wales and Scotland, who have something in common with Ireland now. They are not going to the World Cup :D

iadom 19-11-2009 00:07

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34911760)



Given got a clear hand on his ankle.

The ball was already yards over the dead ball line by then.

Damien 19-11-2009 00:09

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by iadom (Post 34911778)
The ball was already yards over the dead ball line by then.

No it wasn't. Although I doubt he could have gotten to it. Still a penality in this crazy game though.

iadom 19-11-2009 00:10

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34911769)

Did you know Arsene Wenger is French?

No, I didn't notice that, perhaps its because I use the same optician as Wenger.:p:

soicky 19-11-2009 00:16

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Henry :td:

Niles Crane 19-11-2009 00:21

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
The higher than mighty faux outrage is basically a load of *******s.

Any player would try and help their team win a match like that, at any cost. This isn't just some run of the mill match, it's a make or break, once in a lifetime match which literally has the hopes of millions on the players shoulders. To suggest Henry's handball has anything to do with money is plain illogical. As is the notion he's no longer a legend or decent person.

If an English or Irish player had done the same (ignore the fact English players obviously never cheat), that's all we'd be hearing; they did it for their country! But no, as it was a dirty Frenchman, it's the act of Satan.

At least it's given an oppurtunity for people to dish out a good bit of old fashioned francophobia.

Shadow Demon UK 19-11-2009 00:32

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34911783)
The higher than mighty faux outrage is basically a load of *******s.

Any player would try and help their team win a match like that, at any cost. This isn't just some run of the mill match, it's a make or break, once in a lifetime match which literally has the hopes of millions on the players shoulders. To suggest Henry's handball has anything to do with money is plain illogical. As is the notion he's no longer a legend or decent person.

If an English or Irish player had done the same (ignore the fact English players obviously never cheat), that's all we'd be hearing; they did it for their country! But no, as it was a dirty Frenchman, it's the act of Satan.

At least it's given an oppurtunity for people to dish out a good bit of old fashioned francophobia.


Are you saying it's ok for a player to cheat, as long as it's in a big game?

I'm suprised people are sticking up for him, but on the other hand it doesn't suprise me those people are Arsenal fans. I wonder what their reactions would be if it was Ronaldo in Henry's position?

Niles Crane 19-11-2009 00:38

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shadow Demon UK (Post 34911786)
Are you saying it's ok for a player to cheat, as long as it's in a big game?

I'm suprised people are sticking up for him, but on the other hand it doesn't suprise me those people are Arsenal fans. I wonder what their reactions would be if it was Ronaldo in Henry's position?

I'm not saying that in the slightest. Understanding and sympathy doesn't equate to condoning.

I'm not a hypocrite and i don't get caught up knee jerk hysteria or scape goatting. Despite my massive dislike for Ronaldo i was the first pointing out the ridiculous hysteria, hypocrisy and stupidity surrounding the winking saga at the last WC. Same as i was doing last week with the Drogba/Evans incident, despite as you correctly pointed out, supporting Arsenal.

It doesn't surprise me the people castigating him aren't Arsenal fans, or France fans, or putting the situation in context, or considering what it would be like if the shoe was on the other foot.

LondonRoad 19-11-2009 00:39

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34911777)
Sorry, Meant England. Not Wales and Scotland, who have something in common with Ireland now. They are not going to the World Cup :D

Touche. ;) Only got 31 teams to support now :D

SB_07 19-11-2009 00:45

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Just seen a link to a 'anti-henry' group on FB which already has 12,000 members, alot of racist comments on there:rolleyes:

Niles Crane 19-11-2009 00:53

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SB_07 (Post 34911793)
Just seen a link to a 'anti-henry' group on FB which already has 12,000 members, alot of racist comments on there:rolleyes:

Inevitable. Like i said earlier; situations like this are like a wet dream for bigots. This is a double whammy too; he's black and he's French. Jackpot!

punky 19-11-2009 01:03

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Hey Bobby, what's the french for 'cheating *******'?

http://img.thesun.co.uk/multimedia/a...90_931617a.jpg

Damien 19-11-2009 09:42

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
I am worried England won't be able to win the World Cup though. Obviously there are all these cheating foreigners and since English players are fundamentally honest we won't win these decisions :(

---------- Post added at 08:40 ---------- Previous post was at 08:38 ----------

Anyway Henry admitted he handballed it. Apparently he did so to Dunn as well which is why they seemed to be, surprising, getting on after the final whistle.

---------- Post added at 08:42 ---------- Previous post was at 08:40 ----------

Incidentally give credit to the Irish team for how well they handled, no pun intended, it after the game.

TheDaddy 19-11-2009 10:26

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34911794)
Inevitable. Like i said earlier; situations like this are like a wet dream for bigots. This is a double whammy too; he's black and he's French. Jackpot!

Triple whammy surely, he's also a unscrupulous, cheating git.

---------- Post added at 09:26 ---------- Previous post was at 09:23 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shadow Demon UK (Post 34911786)
Are you saying it's ok for a player to cheat, as long as it's in a big game?

I'm suprised people are sticking up for him, but on the other hand it doesn't suprise me those people are Arsenal fans. I wonder what their reactions would be if it was Ronaldo in Henry's position?

I'm not surprised tbh some people have no shame what he did was wrong and he is now deservedly getting criticised for it, all this nonsense about what if it was an Englishman is crap to, we'd never hear the end of it, vilified for a generation.

Damien 19-11-2009 16:00

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Ireland asking for a replay, although I don't see that happening to be honest.

Saaf_laandon_mo 19-11-2009 18:03

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Fifa should ban Henry for the next 3 competitive internationals. They go on about fair play and respect, so let's see them administer a punishment like they would do so if he had stamped on someone and not been spotted by the ref.

Damien 19-11-2009 18:23

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saaf_laandon_mo (Post 34912070)
Fifa should ban Henry for the next 3 competitive internationals. They go on about fair play and respect, so let's see them administer a punishment like they would do so if he had stamped on someone and not been spotted by the ref.

Well it's not the same as if he stamped on someone. There was no violence there, he handled the ball, and it's not a fair comparison.

The match ban, or a rematch, opens a can of worms because then what about other times when a rule of the game is broken leading to an unfair goal? I think video replays are better because this kind of thing won't be eradicated otherwise, it's not the first time a player has attempted to control a difficult ball with their hands.

By the way it's been reported as if qualification was a sure thing until that goal. France had regained a foothole in the match after Keane missed that one on one chance. They barely featured in the last 10 minutes and in extra time. Also, before than goal Ireland needed 1 goal to go though, afterwards they needed one goal to go though. Henry's handball meant it didn't get to penalties is all. It was a con, very unfair, but it's not as if Ireland had it in the bag.

Niles Crane 19-11-2009 19:11

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34912008)
Ireland asking for a replay, although I don't see that happening to be honest.

A WC 2006 qualifier between Uzbekistan and Bahrain was replayed due to an incorrect refereeing decision a few years ago - at FIFA's own order.

A replay is unlikely, but it's possible, and bearing in mind the above match perhaps it definitely should happen. The draw is on 4th December, so they'd need to get a move on.

Also, do you remember the Arsenal vs Sheffield United FA Cup replay due to Kanu's misunderstanding?

Shadow Demon UK 19-11-2009 19:47

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34912114)
A WC 2006 qualifier between Uzbekistan and Bahrain was replayed due to an incorrect refereeing decision a few years ago - at FIFA's own order.

A replay is unlikely, but it's possible, and bearing in mind the above match perhaps it definitely should happen. The draw is on 4th December, so they'd need to get a move on.

Also, do you remember the Arsenal vs Sheffield United FA Cup replay due to Kanu's misunderstanding?

But they're different to what happened last night. If they're going to replay because of a handball, i want them to replay the United v Chelsea match because the goal shouldn't have stood. I can think of about a dozen games this season where a team lost because of a dodgy goal. I know the Irish are annoyed but it's a bit embarrasing that they're asking for the game to be replayed imo.

Damien 19-11-2009 19:52

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shadow Demon UK (Post 34912139)
But they're different to what happened last night. If they're going to replay because of a handball, i want them to replay the United v Chelsea match because the goal shouldn't have stood. I can think of about a dozen games this season where a team lost because of a dodgy goal. I know the Irish are annoyed but it's a bit embarrasing that they're asking for the game to be replayed imo.

Well exactly. I was thinking about the Ashley Cole Dive. It's was not a cheat that caused the goal to go in, but it did lead to a goal. Like last night, it was a cheat to control the ball which lead to the pass. It's not as if he did the actual hand of god thing.

The thing is one dodgy goal is always something in football. We need video (come on FIFA) so the incidents like this which are in-your-face blatent handballs like that are caught. However we can't have rematches based on dodgy goals.

Niles Crane 19-11-2009 20:17

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
What you've both said is true, but this wasn't 1 game of a 50 match season. This is never going to "equal itself out throughout the course of a season". It's literally once in a lifetime. The magnitude of this match outweighs the examples you've given, in every sense. For that reason i can understand FAI's replay request.

The Uzbekistan/Bahrain example is only different in the type of mistake by the referee(s). It's essentially the same scenario - a mistake made which may well have changed the outcome of the tie.

Pog66 20-11-2009 13:20

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34912162)
The Uzbekistan/Bahrain example is only different in the type of mistake by the referee(s). It's essentially the same scenario - a mistake made which may well have changed the outcome of the tie.

There's a slight difference between a referee not knowing the rules (e.g Bahrain eg above) and missing something on the pitch.

FIFA have stated now the game will not be replayed

Damien 20-11-2009 15:20

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Niles Crane (Post 34912162)
What you've both said is true, but this wasn't 1 game of a 50 match season. This is never going to "equal itself out throughout the course of a season". It's literally once in a lifetime. The magnitude of this match outweighs the examples you've given, in every sense. For that reason i can understand FAI's replay request.

The Uzbekistan/Bahrain example is only different in the type of mistake by the referee(s). It's essentially the same scenario - a mistake made which may well have changed the outcome of the tie.

Loads of mistakes could affect the outcome of a game. I don't care what some in the press say, France should have had the penalty, and the only reason it's being denied is because it takes away from the outrage some wish to express at the result. The same reason the press neglect to mention Keane controlling the ball with this hand earlier in the match (albeit getting caught, unlike Henry).

We have replays for 'big games' then both teams will always look at every single incident in a game looking for grounds to call a replay. That was a dive, rematch! That wasn't a free kick, rematch! He was offside, rematch!

Then you have the problem of what counts as a big game? All cup matches? A regulation battle in the league? Every World Cup game?

The only time I would think this should even be considered is for systematic poor referring throughout the game, as was the case for the Chelsea vs Barcelona Champions League Semi-Final.

A result needs to be final in all but the most outrageous incidents. This was not that, this was a handball leading to a goal. It was not systematic cheating or poor referring. Ireland did not have the game 'in the bag' as is being reported, they were under pressure for a while before the goal. So as unfair as it was, it's not as if it's was a cert they were to go though.

---------- Post added at 14:20 ---------- Previous post was at 12:58 ----------

Wonder if Ireland would be happy for this match to be replayed:

YouTube - Ireland - Georgia RIDICULOUS Penalty

danielf 20-11-2009 15:33

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34912483)
Wonder if Ireland would be happy for this match to be replayed:

YouTube - Ireland - Georgia RIDICULOUS Penalty

:LOL:

Russ 21-11-2009 12:51

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Big Sam has heart op - http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/foot...rs/8371989.stm

Kymmy 21-11-2009 13:44

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
I hope it all goes well for SA

In the mean time Liverppol v ManCity is just about to kick off, hopefully should be an interesting game as both Liverpool and City need to start winning to be seriously considered as Premiership contenders

Russ 21-11-2009 20:19

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
So is Liverpool's flatulent season over already?

soicky 21-11-2009 20:36

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34913299)
So is Liverpool's flatulent season over already?

Yes :)

superbiatch 21-11-2009 20:38

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34913299)
So is Liverpool's flatulent season over already?

You are such a stirrer Russ :D

Russ 21-11-2009 20:52

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
I'd expect the same if the situation was reversed :D

Mal 22-11-2009 02:29

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Russ (Post 34912954)

Even though he has strong links with Bolton, I do like Big Sam and hope that he will be okay.

Derek 22-11-2009 15:56

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Things get interesting up in Scotland.

After years of the old firm being out of sight by Xmas there is only three points between the top four teams thanks to another exceptional display of crapness from Mowbrays muppets.

SB_07 22-11-2009 17:57

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Wigan are getting crushed by Spurs.

5 for Defoe now.

---------- Post added at 16:57 ---------- Previous post was at 16:38 ----------

Spoiler: 
9-1

Kymmy 22-11-2009 18:04

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Is that a record???

---------- Post added at 17:04 ---------- Previous post was at 17:02 ----------

Closest I could find was

Quote:

Andy Cole was the first player to score five goals in a Premiership match, for Manchester United vs. Ipswich in the 1994/95 season. The final score was 9-0, which is also a Premiership record for the biggest victory/defeat

SB_07 22-11-2009 18:04

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 34913896)
Is that a record???

I think Man Utd beat Ipswich 9-0 a few years ago.

EDIT: You got it! lol.

superbiatch 22-11-2009 18:05

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
:shocked: Bad day for the pie eaters

Kymmy 22-11-2009 18:07

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Is it a record then for the most goals scored in a single 90minute game inthe premiership I wonder??

punky 22-11-2009 18:08

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 34913896)
Is that a record???

---------- Post added at 17:04 ---------- Previous post was at 17:02 ----------

Closest I could find was

And bloody typical that Wigan's only goal was illegal. Henry eat your heart out.

What a game though. We could have easily had 3 more.

nffc 22-11-2009 18:14

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kymmy (Post 34913903)
Is it a record then for the most goals scored in a single 90minute game inthe premiership I wonder??

Yes.

There have been 9-0, 8-1, 7-2, 6-3, 5-4 but nothing with 10 goals.

Russ 22-11-2009 19:31

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Well done to Roberto Martinez for keeping the score below 10....

I wonder if he has any regrets about leaving Swansea after they reached their highest league position in 26 years on the weekend.

yesman 23-11-2009 08:15

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Henry sucks...

CLEANERS in Ireland have decided their Henry vacuum cleaners really suck - after Thierry Henry's handball ended the nation's World Cup dream


http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage...-cleaners.html

:rofl::rofl::rofl:

punky 23-11-2009 10:16

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
And they mocked the Americans over Freedom Fries?

dev 23-11-2009 10:21

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nffc (Post 34913907)
Yes.

There have been 9-0, 8-1, 7-2, 6-3, 5-4 but nothing with 10 goals.

There was 7 - 4 between Pompy and Reading couple seasons ago which is the highest afaik.

punky 23-11-2009 10:57

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dev (Post 34914220)
There was 7 - 4 between Pompy and Reading couple seasons ago which is the highest afaik.

There was a Spurs 6 - Reading 4 as well.

---------- Post added at 09:57 ---------- Previous post was at 09:34 ----------

This made me laugh.... in the MLS there is a team called Real Salt Lake (as in Real Madrid), but they play in Barcelona's colours :p:

punky 23-11-2009 17:26

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
So much for the Kick It Out campaign...

http://soccernet.espn.go.com/news/st...ngland&cc=5739

Quote:

Amr Zaki has astonishingly claimed that he will not consider signing for Portsmouth on the grounds that they employ two Israelis - Tal Ben Haim and Avram Grant - as well as an Algerian in the form of Nadir Belhadj.
As that is a completely racist statement, I wonder if FIFA will act on him? I say probably not. al-Faraj (a Saudi) deserves an honourable mention for employing Grant and Ben-Haim.

Damien 23-11-2009 17:28

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by punky (Post 34914426)
So much for the Kick It Out campaign...

http://soccernet.espn.go.com/news/st...ngland&cc=5739



As that is a completely racist statement, I wonder if FIFA will act on him? I say probably not. al-Faraj (a Saudi) deserves an honourable mention for employing Grant and Ben-Haim.

It proves he is a racist, I don't think he made a racist statement though. He just said "I do not want to work here because I am a racist". Just like "I don't want to work here because of the black people" is an admission of racism rather than a racist statement?

TheDaddy 23-11-2009 17:49

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34914427)
It proves he is a racist

I don't think it does, did he say I don't want to work here because of Jews, no, good on him I say, Israel operates an apartheid system and it's about time people in the media spotlight had the balls to say so.

punky 23-11-2009 18:05

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34914438)
did he say I don't want to work here because of Jews

Yes. That was the whole point of the post really.

---------- Post added at 17:05 ---------- Previous post was at 16:57 ----------

Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 34914427)
It proves he is a racist, I don't think he made a racist statement though. He just said "I do not want to work here because I am a racist". Just like "I don't want to work here because of the black people" is an admission of racism rather than a racist statement?

Its a thin line IMO.

TheDaddy 23-11-2009 18:06

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by punky (Post 34914440)
Yes. That was the whole point of the post really.

Do you not read links or quotes then?

---------- Post added at 17:05 ---------- Previous post was at 16:57 ----------



Its a thin line IMO.

Read it again couldn't find any mention of Jews, just Israelis

punky 23-11-2009 18:08

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34914443)
Read it again couldn't find any mention of Jews, just Israelis

Except for Avram Grant and Tal Ben-Haim you mean?

TheDaddy 23-11-2009 18:16

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by punky (Post 34914445)
Except for Avram Grant and Tal Ben-Haim you mean?

Who he objects to playing with/for because they are Israeli not because they are Jewish, there are loads of Jews in football who aren't Israeli like Juan Pablo Sorin and your own David Pleat who he may well have played with or for without issue.

punky 23-11-2009 18:27

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
So you think that descriminating on the basis that they are Israeli and not Jewish is not racist?

I almost thought you were serious there for a moment.

In case you are...

http://www.ask.com/web?q=dictionary%...&o=13919&l=dis

Quote:

Definitions of 'race'
(rās)
Dictionary.com · The American Heritage® Dictionary - (21 definitions)

[French, from Old French, from Old Italian razza, race, lineage.]
(noun)

1. A local geographic or global human population distinguished as a more or less distinct group by genetically transmitted physical characteristics.
2. A group of people united or classified together on the basis of common history, nationality, or geographic distribution: the German race.
3. A genealogical line; a lineage.
4. Humans considered as a group.
5. Biology
1. An interbreeding, usually geographically isolated population of organisms differing from other populations of the same species in the frequency of hereditary traits. A race that has been given formal taxonomic recognition is known as a subspecies.
2. A breed or strain, as of domestic animals.
6. A distinguishing or characteristic quality, such as the flavor of a wine.
Note the word "geographic", mentioned several times.

And anyway, its news to me that Avram Grant and Tal Ben-Haim are solely responsible for Israel's policies for the last 40-odd years. You learn something new every day.

Damien 23-11-2009 18:29

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34914438)
I don't think it does, did he say I don't want to work here because of Jews, no, good on him I say, Israel operates an apartheid system and it's about time people in the media spotlight had the balls to say so.

Not every Israeli or Jew supports Israel's policies towards Palestine*. Treating the entire people as one is a recipe for trouble. Imagine an American not wanting to play for a team that contained Iranians or Afghans? Think of all the countries that wouldn't want to play with a team that contained Britons because of the screwed up stuff 'we' have done in the past?

He also doesn't want to play with an Algerian! He is at best xenophobic.


*Personally, although I obviously intensely dislike some of it, I think not all are without merit.

nffc 23-11-2009 18:36

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34914451)
Who he objects to playing with/for because they are Israeli not because they are Jewish, there are loads of Jews in football who aren't Israeli like Juan Pablo Sorin and your own David Pleat who he may well have played with or for without issue.

Pleat doesn't work for Tottenham (sadly, for us).

TheDaddy 23-11-2009 18:45

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by punky (Post 34914456)
So you think that descriminating on the basis that they are Israeli and not Jewish is not racist?

I dont consider him racist considering Israel is made up of more than just Jews and it's the treatment of Arab Israeli's he is making this stance for but you knew that anyway I'd imagine and have resorted to weakest resort possible by using dictionary definitions.

Quote:

And anyway, its news to me that Avram Grant and Tal Ben-Haim are solely responsible for Israel's policies for the last 40-odd years. You learn something new every day
Not solely responsible for but if they haven't come out and denounced their government for their actions then they bare some responsibility. You know it'd be funny if it wasn't so tragic that any criticism of that countries policies are shot down amid accusations of racism, even when foreign Jews criticise they are labled as self loathers and the like.

punky 23-11-2009 18:55

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34914465)
I dont consider him racist considering Israel is made up of more than just Jews and it's the treatment of Arab Israeli's he is making this stance for but you knew that anyway I'd imagine and have resorted to weakest resort possible by using dictionary definitions.

Its called evidence. Evidence to prove that are wrong and have not got the faintest idea what you are talking about. That or you are trying to (pathetically) defend your own prejudices. Which one then?


Quote:

Not solely responsible for but if they haven't come out and denounced their government for their actions then they bare some responsibility. You know it'd be funny if it wasn't so tragic that any criticism of that countries policies are shot down amid accusations of racism, even when foreign Jews criticise they are labled as self loathers and the like.
More nonsense from you then.

Niles Crane 23-11-2009 20:02

Re: Football : Season 2009/2010
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 34914465)
I dont consider him racist considering Israel is made up of more than just Jews and it's the treatment of Arab Israeli's he is making this stance for but you knew that anyway I'd imagine and have resorted to weakest resort possible by using dictionary definitions.



Not solely responsible for but if they haven't come out and denounced their government for their actions then they bare some responsibility. You know it'd be funny if it wasn't so tragic that any criticism of that countries policies are shot down amid accusations of racism, even when foreign Jews criticise they are labled as self loathers and the like.

Does this standard also apply to you and your country's actions? Or is it only famous people who should abide by this?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:22.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
All Posts and Content are © Cable Forum